If you're a fan of the "Who Dey" nation, you already know the vibe. It’s a mix of incredible pride and that lingering "what if" that keeps you up at night. The Cincinnati Bengals have a history that’s basically a rollercoaster. They’ve reached the mountaintop three times, but they’ve never quite been able to plant the flag at the summit.
So, when did Bengals go to Super Bowl? It’s happened in three distinct eras: 1982, 1989, and 2022.
Every single one of those games was a heartbreaker. We’re talking about games decided by a few yards, a dropped interception, or a final-minute drive by a legendary quarterback. Honestly, the Bengals might be the best team in NFL history to have zero rings. Let’s break down exactly how they got there and why they came home empty-handed.
The First Trip: Super Bowl XVI (1982)
The 1981 season was a total shift for Cincinnati. This was the year they debuted those iconic tiger-striped helmets. Before that, they just had "BENGALS" written on a plain orange lid. Maybe the stripes gave them powers?
They finished 12-4 under head coach Forrest Gregg. Ken Anderson was the man back then. He didn't just play; he dominated. He won the NFL MVP and led the league in passing. When January 24, 1982, rolled around, the Bengals found themselves in the Pontiac Silverdome in Michigan, facing off against the San Francisco 49ers.
It started out like a nightmare.
💡 You might also like: Pro Football Focus QB Rankings: Why Your Favorite Passer Is Probably Undergraded
The Bengals turned the ball over early and often. By halftime, they were down 20-0. You don't usually come back from that in a Super Bowl. But Ken Anderson didn't quit. He threw for 300 yards—a huge number for that era—and tight end Dan Ross caught 11 passes, which was a record at the time.
The moment everyone remembers is the "Goal Line Stand." The Bengals were on the 1-yard line. They tried to punch it in three times. The 49ers defense, led by Dan Bunz, stuffed them every single time. If the Bengals score there, they probably win. Instead, they lost 26-21.
The Rematch: Super Bowl XXIII (1989)
Fast forward seven years. Different vibe, same opponent. This was the Boomer Esiason era. Boomer had that left-handed swagger and a lethal connection with wideouts like Eddie Brown and Cris Collinsworth. Sam Wyche was the coach, and his "no-huddle" offense was driving the rest of the NFL crazy.
They met the 49ers again on January 22, 1989, in Miami.
This game was a defensive slugfest for three quarters. The most electric moment came late in the third when Stanford Jennings took a kickoff 93 yards for a touchdown. Suddenly, Cincinnati had the lead.
But then, Joe Montana happened.
With 3:10 left on the clock, Montana stepped into the huddle at his own 8-yard line. He reportedly pointed into the stands and asked his teammates, "Hey, isn't that John Candy?" He was that cool. He marched the Niners 92 yards and hit John Taylor for the winning touchdown with 34 seconds left.
The Bengals lost 20-16. It's still considered one of the most painful losses in the city's history. One dropped interception by Lewis Billups earlier in that drive could have ended it. Tiny margins.
The Modern Miracle: Super Bowl LVI (2022)
Nobody—and I mean nobody—saw this one coming. The Bengals had won four games the year before. They were 4-11-1 in 2020. They were the underdogs of all underdogs. But they had Joe Burrow and Ja'Marr Chase.
The run to Super Bowl LVI was pure magic. They beat the Raiders. They upset the Titans in Tennessee. They went into Arrowhead and stunned Patrick Mahomes and the Chiefs.
On February 13, 2022, they played the Los Angeles Rams at SoFi Stadium. This was basically a road game for the Bengals since it was the Rams' home turf.
It was a wild game. Tee Higgins had a monster performance, including a 75-yard touchdown to start the second half. The Bengals lead 20-16 for most of the fourth quarter. But the offensive line just couldn't hold up. Aaron Donald and Von Miller were living in the backfield.
Matthew Stafford eventually found Cooper Kupp for a touchdown with 1:25 left. On the final drive, Burrow tried to make a play, but Aaron Donald got to him one last time. The game ended 23-20.
Why the Bengals Keep Getting So Close
If you look at these three games, a pattern emerges. The Bengals are almost never "blown out." They lose by 5, 4, and 3 points.
- Super Bowl XVI: Lost by 5.
- Super Bowl XXIII: Lost by 4.
- Super Bowl LVI: Lost by 3.
They are a few plays away from being 3-0 in Super Bowls. Usually, it comes down to a legendary opposing quarterback (Montana twice, Stafford once) making one more play than the Bengals' defense can handle in the final two minutes.
Real Insights for the Future
If you're looking at the current state of the team, the window isn't closed. Joe Burrow has proven he can get there. The front office has spent heavily on the offensive line to prevent a repeat of the 2022 collapse.
📖 Related: Dennis Rodman Explained: Why "The Worm" Still Matters in 2026
To actually win the next one, the stats suggest they need to fix their turnover margin in big games. In Super Bowl XVI, they had four turnovers. You can't do that. In Super Bowl LVI, they allowed seven sacks. You definitely can't do that.
Next steps for fans and collectors:
If you're hunting for memorabilia, the 1988 AFC Championship program or any "Joey B" signed items from the 2021 run are currently holding the highest market value. For those tracking the team's progress, keep a close eye on the AFC North standings in November; historically, the Bengals only make Super Bowl runs when they sweep at least two of their divisional rivals in the first half of the season.