You know the voice. It's gravelly but smooth, like someone rubbing sandpaper on silk. When Roger L. Jackson first hissed that question through a phone line to a terrified Drew Barrymore in 1996, he wasn't just asking about her Friday night plans. He was resetting the entire clock of horror history. What's your favourite scary movie became more than a catchphrase; it became a litmus test for whether you were a fan or a victim. Honestly, it’s kinda wild that a single sentence could change the way we look at a whole genre, but here we are, decades later, still jumping when the phone rings.
The 90s were weird for horror. The slashers of the 80s had grown stale, bloated with endless sequels that felt more like chore lists than nightmares. Then came Kevin Williamson. He was sitting in his house, alone, watching a news report about the Gainesville Ripper, and he got so spooked he started calling a friend. That conversation—about horror tropes and the sheer stupidity of people in movies—became the DNA of Scream.
The Opening Scene That Broke Every Rule
Most movies play it safe with their stars. You don't hire the biggest name on the poster just to kill her off before the opening credits finish rolling. But Wes Craven did exactly that. By the time Casey Becker is hanging from a tree, the audience is collectively losing its mind because the "safety net" of Hollywood stardom just evaporated.
That phone call is a masterclass in tension. It starts flirtatious. It feels like a prank. Then it shifts. Suddenly, the voice knows she’s making popcorn. It knows she’s alone. When the voice asks, "What's your favourite scary movie?", the answer—Halloween—is a nod to the masters who came before. But the trivia game that follows? That's the real kicker. It forces the audience to realize that their own knowledge of horror is the only thing that might save them. Or get them killed.
"You should never say 'Who's there?' Don't you watch scary movies? It's a death wish."
💡 You might also like: Not the Nine O'Clock News: Why the Satirical Giant Still Matters
That line basically told the world: the characters are as smart as you are. They've seen Friday the 13th. They know who the killer is in the first one (it's Pamela Voorhees, by the way—don't pull a Casey Becker and forget that). This meta-awareness was revolutionary. It wasn't just a movie anymore; it was a conversation between the screen and the seat.
Why Ghostface is Different
Unlike Michael Myers or Jason Voorhees, Ghostface is human. Very human. He trips over furniture. He gets kicked in the face. He misses his stabs. This makes him terrifying in a way a supernatural juggernaut can't be. He’s just some guy with a knife and a grudge. Or two guys.
The reveal that Billy Loomis and Stu Macher were working together changed the "whodunnit" game. You spent the whole movie tracking one person’s whereabouts, only to realize the logistics worked because there were two of them. It was a slap in the face to every viewer who thought they had the "rules" figured out.
The Evolution of the Question
As the franchise moved into the 2000s and beyond, the question evolved. In Scream 4, it mocked the trend of torture porn like Saw and Hostel. By the time we got to the "requels" of 2022 and Scream VI, the conversation shifted to toxic fandom and the obsession with "elevated horror."
📖 Related: New Movies in Theatre: What Most People Get Wrong About This Month's Picks
- 1996: The original trivia game.
- 2011: The commentary on remakes and social media fame.
- 2022: The critique of "elevated" horror like Hereditary or The Babadook.
- 2026: The upcoming Scream 7 is reportedly circling back to the roots of Sidney Prescott’s trauma.
The phrase has been parodied, sampled in songs, and used in every Halloween prank call for thirty years. But why does it still work? Because everyone has an answer. Whether you love the slow burn of The Shining or the jump scares of The Conjuring, the question invites you into the world. It makes you a participant.
What Most People Get Wrong About Scream
There’s this misconception that Scream is a parody. It’s not. Scary Movie is a parody. Scream is a satire. There's a big difference. A parody makes fun of the genre to be funny; a satire uses the tropes to tell a sharper, more biting version of the story. Scream is genuinely scary. The kills are brutal. The stakes are real.
Another thing? The mask wasn't some custom-designed monster. It was a "Peanut-Eyed Ghost" mask found in a box by producer Marianne Maddalena while they were scouting houses. It was a cheap, store-bought item. That’s why it’s so unsettling—it’s something anyone could buy at a local pharmacy. It brings the horror into the mundane reality of suburban life.
The Future of Ghostface in 2026
We’re now looking at Scream 7, and the landscape has changed again. With Kevin Williamson returning to direct and Neve Campbell back as Sidney, the "legacy" feel is stronger than ever. Fans are debating if Stu Macher (Matthew Lillard) is actually dead—spoiler: Williamson says he is, but horror fans never believe a body count until they see a funeral.
👉 See also: A Simple Favor Blake Lively: Why Emily Nelson Is Still the Ultimate Screen Mystery
The franchise survived the departure of its new leads, Melissa Barrera and Jenna Ortega, by leaning back into the nostalgia that made the original a hit. It proves that the "final girl" isn't just a trope; she's an icon. Sidney Prescott isn't a victim; she's a survivor who learned the rules and then rewrote them.
How to Master Your Own Horror Trivia
If you want to be the person who survives the opening scene, you need to know more than just the basics. Don't just watch the classics; study the patterns.
- Watch the "Big Three": Halloween (1978), Friday the 13th (1980), and A Nightmare on Elm Street (1984). These are the foundations Ghostface builds on.
- Learn the Subversion: Watch Wes Craven's New Nightmare. It was Craven’s "prototype" for the meta-commentary he perfected in Scream.
- Check the Credits: Pay attention to the directors. Knowing that Sean S. Cunningham directed Friday but didn't write the script matters when the killer starts asking questions.
- Identify the Trope: When a character says "I'll be right back," recognize it as a death sentence.
The next time someone calls you and asks "What's your favourite scary movie?", don't just give a title. Explain why. Discuss the cinematography of the original Suspiria or the psychological depth of The Silence of the Lambs. Or just hang up. Hanging up is usually the smartest move.
To truly understand the impact of the franchise, revisit the 1996 original with the lights off and your phone on silent. Notice how the silence between the rings is more frightening than the jumpscares. Pay attention to the way the camera lingers on open doors and windows. That is the legacy of Ghostface: making you realize that the scariest thing isn't the monster under the bed, but the person on the other end of the line.
Find a copy of the original screenplay by Kevin Williamson to see how much of the "meta" dialogue was there from day one. Compare the 1996 kills to the modern "requels" to see how the "rules" of gore have shifted in the digital age. Check out the 2025 book Your Favorite Scary Movie by Ashley Cullins for deep-dive interviews with the cast about how they kept the "whodunnit" secrets on set.