New York City is loud. It’s constant. But just a few feet below the churning, grey-green surface of the water separating Manhattan from Brooklyn and Queens, there is a weird, pressurized silence. Most people crossing the Brooklyn Bridge look out at the skyline and think about real estate or where they’re getting dinner. They don’t think about the bottom of the river. Honestly, why would they? It’s dark down there. It’s cold.
The East River isn't even a river.
It’s a salt-water tidal strait. Because of that, the currents are absolutely vicious. We’re talking about water moving at four knots, creating a scouring effect that keeps the floor of the channel a graveyard of New York’s discarded history. If you dropped a weighted bag into the water today, the silt and the sheer force of the tide would likely swallow it before the week is out.
The Piano Myth and the Concrete Reality
People love a good urban legend. You’ve probably heard the one about the East River being a dumping ground for the mob. While there’s some truth to the "cement shoes" trope in a historical sense, the bottom of the river is mostly home to things far more mundane and, occasionally, far more bizarre than a 1920s gangster.
Take the pianos.
In 2014, a photo went viral of a lone upright piano sitting on a sandbar under the Brooklyn Bridge. It looked poetic. It looked like a music video set. But the reality is that the East River floor is littered with bulky debris that people simply didn't want to pay to haul away. In the decades before strict environmental soul-searching became the norm, the river was the city’s basement. If it didn’t fit in the trash can, it went over the railing.
What the Divers See
The NYPD Scuba Team has one of the hardest jobs in the world. Visibility is usually near zero. They aren't swimming; they’re feeling. They describe the bottom of the river as a "black soup." You reach out and your hand might hit a shopping cart, a rusted-out 1970s sedan, or a literal mountain of oyster shells.
✨ Don't miss: The Long Haired Russian Cat Explained: Why the Siberian is Basically a Living Legend
Oysters used to be the bedrock of New York. Before the water became a chemical cocktail during the industrial revolution, the riverbed was white with shells. Some of those reefs are still down there, buried under layers of "black Mayonnaise." That’s the actual term marine biologists use for the thick, toxic sludge made of decayed organic matter, heavy metals, and oil runoff that coats the floor. It’s nasty stuff. It’s also surprisingly good at preserving things.
The Legend of the HMS Hussar
We have to talk about the gold.
Every few years, a new group of treasure hunters gets obsessed with the HMS Hussar. This was a British frigate that went down in 1780 during the Revolutionary War. It struck a rock in the Hell Gate—a notoriously treacherous stretch of the East River—and sank fast. The rumor? It was carrying the payroll for British troops. Some estimates put the value at $4 million in gold coins.
The British government denied it, of course. They claimed the money was offloaded before the ship hit the rocks. But that hasn't stopped people from looking. The problem is that the Hell Gate is a vortex. The current there is so strong it can rip the mask right off a diver’s face. If that gold is at the bottom of the river, it’s likely buried under twenty feet of silt or wedged into a rocky crevice that hasn't been touched in two centuries.
Dead Bodies and Cold Cases
It’s a grim topic, but it’s the one everyone asks about. Does the river hold secrets? Yes. But it’s not always a thriller movie scenario. Most of the remains found at the bottom of the river are the result of tragic accidents or suicides.
The water is cold enough to slow decomposition during the winter, but when spring hits, the gases build up. That’s why "floaters" usually appear in April or May. However, some things stay down. If a body gets pinned under a submerged pier or trapped in the wreckage of a sunken barge, it stays there. There are likely dozens of missing persons from the last century who ended up in the silt, becoming part of the river’s geological record.
🔗 Read more: Why Every Mom and Daughter Photo You Take Actually Matters
The Strange Case of the Ice Age Bones
In 2017, a guy named Don Ginao claimed he found a cache of woolly mammoth bones at the bottom of the river. He wasn't totally crazy. During the Pleistocene era, what is now New York was a frozen tundra. Animals died. Their bones got buried.
While most of the "mammoth" talk turned out to be more about a discarded collection of museum-grade fossils that were allegedly dumped by a frustrated collector in the 1940s, the geological truth is that the river sits on a bed of Forsyth Gneiss. This is bedrock that is over a billion years old. When you touch the very bottom, you aren't just touching trash; you’re touching the ancient skeleton of the continent.
Modern Trash and Micro-Habitats
It isn't all 18th-century shipwrecks and mammoth tusks. If you scanned the bottom of the river with side-scan sonar today, you’d see a lot of "E-waste."
- Thousands of iPhones and Androids, their batteries leaking lithium into the mud.
- Lime scooters and Citi Bikes, tangled in nests of discarded fishing line.
- Thousands upon thousands of "single-use" plastics that have been sanded down into microplastics.
Strangely, life finds a way.
The hulks of sunken cars and old construction cranes have become artificial reefs. Eels love the dark crevices of a submerged Toyota Corolla. Blue crabs scuttle over the remains of rotting wooden pilings from the 1800s. There’s a whole ecosystem living on our garbage. It’s a messy, resilient version of nature that mirrors the city above it.
Why We Can't Just Clean It Up
You might wonder why we don’t just dredge the whole thing and start over.
💡 You might also like: Sport watch water resist explained: why 50 meters doesn't mean you can dive
It’s a logistical nightmare. For one, the East River is a major shipping lane. You can't just park a vacuum ship in the middle of the channel without shutting down the economy of the Eastern Seaboard. More importantly, the bottom of the river is stable right now. All those toxins—the PCBs, the lead, the arsenic from the old factories—are trapped in the "black mayonnaise."
If you stir it up, you re-contaminate the water column. You kill the fish. You make the air smell like a chemical fire. We’ve collectively decided that it’s better to let the ghosts stay buried.
Finding the Bottom Yourself
You can actually see parts of the river bottom without diving. During an extreme low tide, especially after a "moon tide," parts of the shoreline at places like Gantry Plaza State Park or the South Street Seaport reveal what’s usually hidden.
You’ll see the "timber cribs." These are massive wooden crates filled with stones that were used to build the city’s piers in the 19th century. They look like ancient ruins. You’ll see rusted iron bolts the size of your head. You’ll see the blue-black mud that smells like rotten eggs (that's the sulfur).
Practical Steps for the Curious
If you’re fascinated by what lies at the bottom of the river, don't just jump in. The East River will kill you. The currents are faster than an Olympic swimmer. Instead, engage with the history safely.
- Visit the City Reliquary: This museum in Williamsburg often has exhibits on the "found objects" of New York, including things pulled from the waterways.
- Study the Bathymetric Maps: The NOAA (National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration) provides detailed charts showing the depth and topography of the river floor. It’s fascinating to see where the deep trenches are.
- Support Billion Oyster Project: This group is actively working to restore the oyster reefs that once defined the river bottom. They are literally rebuilding the floor of the harbor.
- Check out the "Dead Horse Bay" Archives: While technically on the south side of Brooklyn, this area shows what happens when an old landfill at the water's edge spills out. It’s a preview of the debris field that covers the East River floor.
The bottom of the river isn't a void. It’s a mirror. Everything we’ve built, everything we’ve thrown away, and everything we’ve tried to forget is down there, preserved in the cold, dark silt of the Atlantic.
Next time you’re crossing a bridge, look down. You aren't just looking at water. You’re looking at the ceiling of New York’s most crowded, chaotic, and permanent basement.