What Years Did Mahomes Win the Super Bowl? Why the Records Keep Changing

It is honestly wild how fast the NFL landscape shifts. One day you’re watching a young kid from Texas Tech scramble for his life, and the next, he's basically the gatekeeper of the entire league. If you are trying to pin down exactly what years did Mahomes win the Super Bowl, you've probably noticed the numbers get a little blurry depending on who you ask or what year of the "dynasty" they are talking about.

Patrick Mahomes hasn't just won; he’s redefined what a "winning window" looks like for a modern quarterback. As of 2026, he’s sitting on three rings, though the journey to those titles was anything but a straight line.

The Breakthrough: Super Bowl LIV (2020)

The first one always feels the most surreal. In February 2020, Mahomes led the Kansas City Chiefs to a victory over the San Francisco 49ers. This wasn't a blowout. For about three and a half quarters, it actually looked like the Chiefs were cooked. They were down 20-10 with less than seven minutes left on the clock.

Then "Jet Chip Wasp" happened.

Mahomes hit Tyreek Hill for a massive 44-yard gain on 3rd and 15, and the floodgates just... opened. The Chiefs put up 21 unanswered points in the blink of an eye. Mahomes finished that game with 286 passing yards and two touchdowns, securing his first Super Bowl MVP. It was the moment everyone realized the "Chiefs Kingdom" wasn't just a fun story—it was a problem for the rest of the AFC.

The Resilience: Super Bowl LVII (2023)

Fast forward through a painful loss to Tom Brady’s Buccaneers and a heartbreaking AFC Championship exit to the Bengals. By 2023, people were starting to wonder if the magic had faded. Mahomes entered Super Bowl LVII against the Philadelphia Eagles with a high-ankle sprain that looked genuinely season-ending just weeks prior.

He basically played on one leg.

In a high-scoring 38-35 thriller, Mahomes was surgical. He didn't put up 500 yards, but he didn't have to. He was efficient, throwing three touchdowns and zero interceptions. The most iconic moment was probably his late-game scramble on that bad ankle to set up the winning field goal. That 2023 win proved he could win without a deep-threat superstar like Tyreek Hill, silencing a lot of the critics who thought he was a product of the system.

The Back-to-Back Milestone: Super Bowl LVIII (2024)

Winning one is hard. Winning two in a row is statistically improbable. In February 2024, Mahomes and the Chiefs did the unthinkable by beating the 49ers again—this time in a grueling overtime battle in Las Vegas.

This game was a defensive slog for the most part. Mahomes threw for 333 yards and two touchdowns, including the walk-off winner to Mecole Hardman. It was the first time a team had gone back-to-back since the Patriots in the early 2000s. Mahomes took home his third Super Bowl MVP, tying him with Joe Montana in that specific category.

🔗 Read more: Why the 8 team single elimination bracket is the perfect tournament format

What Happened in 2025 and 2026?

You might be wondering why there isn't a fourth or fifth ring listed here. In 2025, the Chiefs actually made it back to the big game for Super Bowl LIX, aiming for a historic "three-peat." They faced off against the Philadelphia Eagles in a rematch of the 2023 game. However, the Eagles took that one 40-22, officially ending the quest for three straight titles.

As we move through the 2026 postseason, Mahomes remains the gold standard, but the NFL parity is finally catching up.

Mahomes’ Super Bowl Track Record

• 2020 (Super Bowl LIV): Won vs. San Francisco 49ers (31-20).
• 2021 (Super Bowl LV): Lost vs. Tampa Bay Buccaneers (9-31).
• 2023 (Super Bowl LVII): Won vs. Philadelphia Eagles (38-35).
• 2024 (Super Bowl LVIII): Won vs. San Francisco 49ers (25-22 OT).
• 2025 (Super Bowl LIX): Lost vs. Philadelphia Eagles (22-40).

Why These Wins Matter for His Legacy

Honestly, the sheer volume of appearances is what’s terrifying for other teams. Mahomes has started five Super Bowls in his first seven seasons as a starter. That is a higher frequency than even Tom Brady managed in his early years.

Experts like Andy Reid and former players often point to his "processing speed" as the reason for this success. It’s not just the arm talent—plenty of guys have big arms. It’s the fact that he can see a defensive rotation in the 2024 overtime win and immediately know that Hardman is going to be open in the flat before the ball is even snapped.

📖 Related: Why Every Fantasy Football Nicknames Generator Kinda Sucks (And How to Fix It)

Key Stats Across His Victories

1. Comeback King: In all three of his wins, Mahomes trailed by double digits at some point. He’s the only QB to ever do that.
2. Efficiency: He has a career postseason passer rating of 105.8, which is the highest in NFL history for anyone with a decent sample size.
3. Versatility: He’s averaged over 40 rushing yards in his Super Bowl wins, proving he’s just as dangerous with his legs as his arm when the trophy is on the line.

Common Misconceptions About Mahomes' Rings

A lot of people get the years mixed up because the NFL season spans two calendar years. For example, the "2023 Season" champion is actually crowned in February 2024. If you see someone say Mahomes won in 2019, they're referring to the season, not the calendar year of the game.

Also, there's a weird myth that he has never lost a playoff game by more than a score. That was true for a long time, but the 31-9 blowout against the Bucs in 2021 and the 2025 loss to the Eagles definitely shattered that narrative. He's human, even if he doesn't play like it most of the time.

Moving Forward in 2026

If you're tracking Mahomes' career for betting, fantasy, or just pure fandom, keep an eye on his health and the Chiefs' offensive line rebuilding. The 2025 loss showed that even Mahomes can't overcome a truly dominant pass rush if his protection isn't elite.

To stay ahead of the curve on his stats:

• Monitor his completion percentage against "two-high" safety shells, which teams are using more to stop his deep ball.
• Track his chemistry with newer, younger receivers as the Kelce era eventually winds down.
• Compare his win-loss record in "one-score games," where he has historically been almost unbeatable.

The road to the Super Bowl still runs through Kansas City, but the path is getting narrower every year.