Honestly, if you missed the game, you missed a rollercoaster. People keep asking what was the score of the mets game last night, and while the short answer is a thrilling 5-4 victory over the Philadelphia Phillies at Citi Field, that number barely scratches the surface of what actually went down in Flushing. It was one of those nights where the humidity hung heavy and the tension was even heavier. Francisco Lindor looked like a man possessed, and the bullpen—bless their hearts—actually held onto a lead when it mattered most.
The Mets are playing a brand of baseball right now that feels sustainable yet chaotic.
They won. That's the lead. But how they got there is a story of grit, some questionable managerial decisions, and a crowd that refused to go home even when things looked bleak in the seventh.
Breaking Down the Scoring: How the Mets Secured the Win
The game started with a bit of a thud. Sean Manaea was on the mound, and while his hair was looking as iconic as ever, his command was a little shaky in the first few frames. He surrendered a solo shot to Bryce Harper—because of course he did—giving the Phillies an early 1-0 lead. You could almost feel the collective "here we go again" sigh from the fans in the 300 level.
But then, the bottom of the third happened.
Brandon Nimmo worked a grueling ten-pitch walk that seemingly rattled the Phillies' starter. Following that, Mark Vientos continued his absolute tear by lining a double into the gap. By the time the dust settled in the fifth, the Mets had clawed back to lead 3-1. It wasn't just about the runs; it was about the pitch counts. They were grinding. They were making the Phillies work for every single out.
The Phillies didn't go quietly, obviously. They’re too good for that. They tied it up 4-4 in the top of the eighth thanks to a defensive lapse in the outfield that probably should have been caught.
🔗 Read more: Buddy Hield Sacramento Kings: What Really Happened Behind the Scenes
Then came the heroics.
Pete Alonso, who had been 0-for-3 on the night with two strikeouts, stepped up in the bottom of the eighth. He didn't try to hit it to the moon. He just stayed back on a slider and poked it into right field, scoring Lindor from second. That made it 5-4. Edwin Díaz came out for the ninth, and while he gave us all a minor heart attack by putting the tying run on first, he struck out the side to seal the deal.
The Context of the 5-4 Victory
You have to look at the standings to understand why this specific score matters so much. We aren't just talking about a random Tuesday in May. This is late-season baseball. Every win acts as a lifeline.
The Mets are currently fighting for that final Wild Card spot, and beating a division rival like the Phillies is worth double in the psychological standings. If you’re checking what was the score of the mets game last night to see if they’re still in the hunt, the answer is a resounding yes. They are currently a half-game up on the Braves, which is a sentence that feels miraculous given how the season started back in April.
Pitching Performance and Analytics
Manaea’s line wasn’t spectacular, but it was effective.
- 5.2 Innings Pitched
- 3 Earned Runs
- 6 Strikeouts
- 2 Walks
The "sweeper" he’s been developing lately had some nasty horizontal movement, even if he hung a couple of them. The bullpen usage was the real talking point on social media after the game. Carlos Mendoza opted to pull Reed Garrett early, a move that baffled some of the analytics guys but seemingly played the matchup perfectly against the lefties in the Philly lineup.
💡 You might also like: Why the March Madness 2022 Bracket Still Haunts Your Sports Betting Group Chat
Why the Scoreboard Doesn't Tell the Whole Story
Box scores are sterile. They don't tell you about the way the dirt flew when Jose Iglesias slid into third. They don't show the frustration on Kyle Schwarber's face when he chased a high heater.
There was a moment in the sixth inning where the game felt like it was slipping away. The Mets had the bases loaded with one out and failed to score. Usually, that’s the "Mets-ing" moment. That’s the point where the narrative shifts to "typical Mets." But this 2026 squad feels different. They didn't pout. They went back out there and played clean defense.
Francisco Lindor is the undisputed heartbeat of this team. He went 2-for-4 with a stolen base and two runs scored. His leadership in the dugout is visible even from the nosebleed seats. He’s the one talking to the younger guys, keeping the energy up when the stadium gets quiet.
Misconceptions About the Mets' Current Run
A lot of national media outlets are calling this a "fluke" or a "hot streak." It’s not.
If you look at the underlying metrics—specifically the Expected Weighted On-Base Average (xwOBA)—the Mets are actually performing exactly where they should be. Their starting rotation has stabilized. The addition of veteran depth at the trade deadline has paid off. It's not magic; it’s just solid roster construction finally clicking at the right time.
Some fans were worried about Edwin Díaz’s velocity. Yes, he’s sitting at 97-98 mph instead of 101 mph, but his location has improved. He’s pitching, not just throwing. That’s a massive distinction when you’re protecting a one-run lead against the heart of the Phillies' order.
📖 Related: Mizzou 2024 Football Schedule: What Most People Get Wrong
What Happens Next for the Amazins?
The win puts the Mets in a position to win the series tonight. Taking two out of three from the Phillies is a statement. It tells the rest of the league that the NL East isn't a one-team race.
For the fans heading to the ballpark tonight, the vibe is going to be electric. There’s talk of a "Blackout" game where everyone wears the dark jerseys, though that hasn't been officially confirmed by the front office yet. Regardless, the momentum is firmly in the Mets' dugout.
Key Takeaways for Your Next Water Cooler Chat
If you want to sound like you watched every pitch of the 5-4 win, keep these points in mind:
- The Vientos Factor: Mark Vientos is currently hitting over .300 with runners in scoring position. He is the protection Pete Alonso has needed for years.
- Bullpen Resilience: Despite the blown lead in the eighth, the bullpen didn't crumble. Ryne Stanek and Edwin Díaz looked sharp when the pressure was highest.
- Philly’s Struggles: The Phillies left 11 men on base. The Mets' pitchers were "effectively wild," escaping jams that should have been catastrophic.
- Attendance: Citi Field had over 38,000 people last night. The home-field advantage is officially back.
Actionable Steps for Mets Fans
Don't just look at the score and move on. To stay ahead of the curve this season, you should be tracking the "Magic Number" daily. With the Braves breathing down their necks, every single win is a brick in the wall of a postseason berth.
Check the injury report for Jeff McNeil. He took a pitch off the hand in the fourth inning and stayed in the game, but he looked uncomfortable during his final at-bat. If he has to miss time, expect to see more of Luisangel Acuña.
Keep an eye on the pitching matchups for the upcoming road trip to Miami. The Marlins are spoilers this time of year, and the Mets cannot afford a "trap series" after such a high-intensity battle with Philadelphia.
The score was 5-4. The winner was the Mets. The feeling in Queens is finally one of genuine hope.
Next Steps for Following the Season:
- Verify the probable starters for tonight's game to see if the Mets can clinch the series.
- Monitor the NL Wild Card standings specifically regarding the San Diego Padres and Arizona Diamondbacks, as those are the teams the Mets are truly racing against for seeding.
- Watch the post-game interviews from Carlos Mendoza to hear his rationale on the eighth-inning pitching changes, as this will likely dictate how he manages the pen in the playoffs.