You know that feeling when the clock strikes Sunday night and the Crumbl app finally refreshes? It's basically a weekly ritual for anyone with a serious sweet tooth. Honestly, February is probably the biggest month of the year for the Utah-based cookie giant, and the Crumbl menu February 2025 lineup is leaning hard into the vibes of romance, chocolate, and maybe a little too much pink frosting.
Crumbl has changed. It isn't just about large, circular cookies anymore.
Since the introduction of "non-cookie" desserts—what the company officially calls "Cakes & More"—the weekly rotation has become a bit of a gamble. Some people hate it. They want the classic Pink Sugar (which, by the way, isn't always a permanent fixture anymore). Others are obsessed with the Tres Leches cakes and the squares. For February 2025, the strategy is clear: grab the Valentine's Day crowd by the throat with decadent, shareable desserts that look good on a grid.
The Valentine’s Week Powerhouse
If you’re looking at the Crumbl menu February 2025 during the week of the 14th, you’re seeing a very specific curation. Crumbl usually doubles down on the "Red Velvet" and "Strawberry" motifs during this window.
One of the heavy hitters returning this year is the Red Velvet Cupcake. It isn't just a cookie that tastes like cake; it’s a dense, cocoa-infused base topped with a massive swirl of cream cheese frosting. People get weirdly defensive about the frosting-to-cookie ratio here. Some say it's too much. I say, if you're going to Crumbl, you've already committed to a 900-calorie sugar bomb, so why stop now?
But the real star of the mid-month menu is the Molten Lava. It’s a dark chocolate cookie with a gooey center that actually stays liquid if you eat it within ten minutes of leaving the store. If you let it sit on your counter for three hours, it’s just a dense chocolate lump. Pro tip: pop it in the microwave for eight seconds. It changes everything.
Why the Non-Cookie Options are Taking Over
Crumbl’s CEO, Jason McGowan, has been pretty vocal on social media about the brand's evolution. They are trying to be a "dessert shop," not just a cookie shop. This February, we’re seeing more of those tiered cakes.
✨ Don't miss: The Long Haired Russian Cat Explained: Why the Siberian is Basically a Living Legend
The Berry Trifle Cake Square is a big one for 2025. It’s a chilled dessert. This is a polarizing move. Traditionalists think a cookie should be warm, but the chilled cake squares have a cult following because they feel slightly "lighter," even though they definitely aren't. It features layers of vanilla cake, fresh berries, and a light cream. It’s basically Crumbl’s way of saying they can do more than just flour and butter.
The Mystery of the Pink Sugar
Let’s talk about the Pink Sugar cookie for a second. It used to be there every single week. Then it was gone. Then it was back every other week. In the Crumbl menu February 2025, it’s being cycled in sporadically. Why? Because scarcity sells. By making the almond-flavored classic a "rotating" flavor, they force the nostalgia hunters to show up when it finally drops. If you see it on the app this month, grab two.
Dietary Realities and the "Share Size" Myth
We have to be real about the nutrition facts. A single Crumbl cookie is technically four servings. Nobody eats a quarter of a cookie.
If you’re tracking macros or just trying not to vibrate from a sugar rush, February is a dangerous month. Most of the February offerings—especially the chocolate-heavy ones like the Chocolate Covered Strawberry cookie—clock in at over 800 calories per unit.
The Chocolate Covered Strawberry is a bit of a technical marvel, though. It usually features a chilled strawberry-infused base with a hard chocolate shell on top. It’s messy. You will get chocolate on your shirt. It’s worth it.
The Early February Warm-up
Before we get to the heart-shaped chaos of Valentine's, the first week of February 2025 focused on comfort. We saw the return of the Churro cookie. This is arguably one of the top five cookies they’ve ever produced. It’s warm, it’s coated in cinnamon sugar, and it has that swirl of buttercream that tastes exactly like the inside of a fried dough stand at a county fair.
🔗 Read more: Why Every Mom and Daughter Photo You Take Actually Matters
Then there’s the M&M’s Valentine's edition. It’s a basic sugar cookie with red, pink, and white M&Ms. Is it groundbreaking? No. Does it satisfy a very specific childhood craving? Absolutely.
Understanding the Crumbl Tech Stack
It sounds nerdy to talk about an app for cookies, but the reason the Crumbl menu February 2025 is so successful is the "Mink" platform. Crumbl uses their proprietary tech to track which flavors perform best in specific regions. That’s why you might see a "Mystery Cookie" at your local shop that is different from the one three towns over.
In February, the Mystery Cookie often leans into "leftover" ingredients from the previous month’s bakes. If a store had a surplus of peanut butter in January, don’t be surprised if your local February mystery flavor is Peanut Butter Blossom. It’s smart business, honestly.
Looking Toward Late February
Once the red and pink decor comes down, the menu usually shifts toward "breakfast" flavors or salty-sweet combos.
We are seeing the Cereal Milk featuring Fruity Pebbles making a late-month appearance. It’s a weirdly salty-sweet experience. The milk glaze has that distinct "bottom of the bowl" flavor. It’s polarizing. You either love the artificial fruitiness or you think it tastes like a chemistry experiment. There’s no middle ground.
The Cookie Journal and Community Feedback
Crumbl is one of the few brands that actually listens to the "Cookie Journal" ratings in their app. If a flavor gets a 2.5-star average in early February, you probably won't see it again until 2026, if ever. They are ruthless with their data.
💡 You might also like: Sport watch water resist explained: why 50 meters doesn't mean you can dive
The Crumbl menu February 2025 reflects this by sticking to high-performers. They aren't taking many risks this month because February is their "Super Bowl." They want guaranteed hits. This means lots of:
- Cream cheese frosting (it’s their signature, for better or worse).
- Chilled cake bases.
- Heavy chocolate ganache.
- Fruit-flavored glazes that cut through the richness.
Real Talk: Is It Worth the Hype?
Look, $5 or $6 for a cookie is a lot. You’ve gotta be intentional about it. If you’re going for the Crumbl menu February 2025, go for the flavors that are hard to replicate at home. Don’t buy the semi-sweet chocolate chip unless you really just love their specific dough. Go for the Red Velvet Cupcake or the Berry Trifle. Go for the stuff that requires three different types of frosting and a chilled prep station.
The logistics of these stores are wild. Most of the staff are teenagers or college students working at a breakneck pace to keep up with DoorDash orders. If your cookie looks a little lopsided, just remember they're probably pumping out 2,000 cookies a day during Valentine's week.
How to Maximize Your February Cookie Run
- Check the App Monday Morning: The "official" drop happens Sunday night, but the reviews start rolling in Monday. Read the comments in the Cookie Journal to see if a batch is running "too dry" or "too sweet" at your location.
- Use the Loyalty Program: If you're buying a 4-pack or a 6-pack for a Valentine's date, make sure you're scanning your loyalty QR code. The "Crumbs" add up fast, and you’ll basically get a free cookie for every $50 or so you spend.
- Storage is Key: Most of these cookies, especially the ones with cream cheese, need to be refrigerated if you aren't eating them immediately. But—and this is important—bring them back to room temp (or microwave them) before eating, unless they are specifically labeled as "Chilled."
- The "Mini" Hack: If the giant cookies are too intimidating, keep an eye out for the Mini Monday's. Some locations offer smaller versions, which is the only sane way to try all six flavors without entering a sugar-induced coma.
The Crumbl menu February 2025 is a masterclass in seasonal marketing. It’s heavy on the pink, unapologetic about the sugar, and perfectly designed for a 15-second TikTok review. Whether you're a hater of the "cake-fication" of Crumbl or a loyalist who treats Sunday night like a holiday, there's no denying the brand has a grip on the American dessert landscape.
To get the most out of your visit this month, prioritize the specialty chilled desserts that are unique to the 2025 season. Stick to the Red Velvet classics if you want a guaranteed win, but don't sleep on the Churro or the molten-center varieties if they pop up in your rotation. Always check your local store's "Mystery Cookie" via the map feature in the app—sometimes the best flavor of the month isn't even on the main menu.