It happens fast. One day your new cartilage or lobe piercing is a shiny accessory you're proud of, and the next, it's throbbing. You look in the mirror and see a localized swamp of redness and swelling. Panic sets in. You start wondering if your ear is going to fall off or if you'll have to retire the jewelry forever. Honestly, the internet is full of terrible advice on this. People tell you to rub alcohol on it (don't) or twist the ring to "break the crust" (definitely don't). Knowing exactly what to do with infected piercing issues can be the difference between a quick fix and a permanent scar or a trip to the ER.
Most people confuse a "pissed off" piercing with a truly infected one. A new piercing is a wound. It's going to be a little red. It’s going to leak some clear or pale yellow fluid called serous drainage. That’s just your body doing its job. But when that fluid turns thick and green, or the area feels hot like a stovetop, you’ve crossed the line into infection territory.
How to tell if it's actually an infection
Before you freak out, look at the symptoms objectively. Is the redness spreading away from the hole? Is there a red streak climbing up your skin? That’s a major red flag. If you have a fever or chills, stop reading this and go to a doctor immediately. That’s not a local skin issue anymore; it’s systemic.
True infections usually involve "angry" symptoms. We're talking about throbbing pain that keeps you awake. If the discharge is foul-smelling or opaque yellow/green, those are white blood cells dying in the trenches for you. On the flip side, if it’s just a little bumpy and itchy, you might just be dealing with a granuloma or a metal allergy. Many people think they have an infection when they’re actually just reacting to cheap nickel jewelry. It’s a common mix-up.
According to the Association of Professional Piercers (APP), most "infections" reported by clients are actually just physical irritation. This happens from sleeping on it, using harsh chemicals, or touching it with dirty hands. But if it's warm to the touch and swollen enough that the jewelry is disappearing into your skin, you need to act.
The first rule: Leave the jewelry in
This is the part that feels counterintuitive. Your instinct is to rip the jewelry out to "let it heal." Don't do that. Seriously.
When you remove the jewelry from an infected piercing, the skin can close up almost instantly. If the hole closes while the bacteria are still trapped inside, you've just created an abscess. Now the infection has no way to drain. It’s trapped. That leads to much bigger problems, sometimes requiring surgical drainage. Keep the jewelry in to act as a "wick" so the pus can actually get out of your body.
💡 You might also like: How to Treat Uneven Skin Tone Without Wasting a Fortune on TikTok Trends
The only exception is if a doctor tells you to take it out, or if the jewelry is literally too small for the swelling and is cutting off circulation. In that case, you don't take it out at home; you go to a professional piercer and have them swap it for a longer bar—usually implant-grade titanium.
What to do with infected piercing: The cleaning protocol
Stop using hydrogen peroxide. Stop using rubbing alcohol. Stop using Neosporin.
Those things are way too harsh for a healing piercing. They kill the "good" cells that are trying to knit your skin back together. If you're wondering what to do with infected piercing sites at home, the answer is surprisingly boring: Sterile saline.
Go to the pharmacy and buy a pressurized can of "Wound Wash." It should only have two ingredients: Water and 0.9% Sodium Chloride. No additives. No scents.
- Spray it twice a day. You don't even need to touch it. Just spray.
- Dry it gently. Bacteria love moisture. Use a disposable paper towel or a hairdryer on a cool setting. Don't use a bath towel—they're covered in bacteria and those little loops of fabric love to snag on jewelry.
- The LITHA method. This stands for "Leave It The Hell Alone." Most people over-clean, which causes more irritation.
If you want to do a warm soak, you can. It helps blood flow to the area. But don't mix your own salt water at home. It’s impossible to get the ratio right in a kitchen, and you’ll likely just irritate the wound further with too much salt. Use the store-bought stuff and warm the bottle up in a bowl of warm water if you want that soothing feeling.
When home care isn't enough
There’s a limit to what saline can do. If the infection is caused by Staphylococcus aureus or another aggressive bacterium, you need antibiotics. This is especially true for cartilage piercings (the upper ear or nose).
📖 Related: My eye keeps twitching for days: When to ignore it and when to actually worry
Cartilage is tricky. It doesn't have its own blood supply like a lobe does. This means your immune system has a harder time getting "soldiers" to the site of the infection. If a cartilage infection gets out of hand, it can lead to perichondritis. This can cause the cartilage to collapse, leading to what people call "cauliflower ear." It’s permanent and it’s not pretty.
Go to a walk-in clinic if:
- The redness is spreading.
- The pain is getting worse after 48 hours of saline care.
- You feel sick or feverish.
- The swelling is so bad the jewelry is being swallowed (embedding).
A doctor will usually prescribe a topical antibiotic like Mupirocin or an oral antibiotic. Finish the whole bottle. Even if it looks better after two days, the bacteria are still lurking. If you stop early, they come back stronger and potentially resistant to the meds.
Misconceptions that make it worse
We've all heard the old wives' tales. "Twist the earring so the skin doesn't grow to it." That is a lie. Your skin doesn't grow to metal. When you twist it, you're just tearing the new, fragile tissue forming inside the "fistula" (the tunnel). It’s like picking a scab from the inside out.
Another one is the "crusties." Those little bits of dried fluid on the bar? They're sharp. If you move the jewelry and pull those crusties into the wound, it's like dragging a saw blade through an open sore. This creates micro-tears where bacteria can enter. Leave them alone until they soften up in the shower and fall off naturally.
Jewelry material matters more than you think
Sometimes it's not an infection at all. It's "Contact Dermatitis."
👉 See also: Ingestion of hydrogen peroxide: Why a common household hack is actually dangerous
If you got pierced with "surgical steel," keep in mind that's a marketing term, not a medical one. Most steel contains nickel. A huge percentage of the population is allergic to nickel, and that allergy can develop at any time. A nickel allergy looks exactly like a minor infection: red, itchy, weeping, and swollen.
If you suspect this is the case, go to a reputable piercer—one who belongs to the APP—and have them swap your jewelry for Implant Grade Titanium (ASTM F-136) or Niobium. These metals are biocompatible. Most of the time, the "infection" miraculously clears up within 24 hours of switching the metal.
Practical next steps for healing
If you're staring at a red, angry piercing right now, here is the immediate checklist. No fluff.
- Hands off. Wash your hands like a surgeon before you even get near your face or ear.
- Check the jewelry fit. If the balls of the stud are pressing into your skin, it's too tight. You need a longer post immediately. Go to a professional piercer for this, not a mall kiosk.
- Clean with saline only. Throw away the "ear care solution" that came in a plastic bottle from the mall. Use the pressurized Wound Wash.
- Change your pillowcase. Do it tonight. Or, better yet, get a "donut" or travel pillow and sleep with your ear in the hole so you aren't putting pressure on the piercing all night.
- Monitor for 24 hours. If it doesn't improve with proper saline cleaning and zero touching, or if it gets worse, call a doctor.
The goal is to keep the area clean, dry, and undisturbed. Your body wants to heal; you just have to stop getting in its way. Be patient. Piercings take months, sometimes a year, to fully heal. A little bump in the road doesn't mean it's a failure, it just means you need to adjust your routine.
Avoid the temptation to put tea tree oil on it. While some people swear by it for "piercing bumps," it is incredibly caustic. On a true infection, it will just cause a chemical burn on top of a bacterial problem, and you'll be in twice as much pain. Stick to the basics. Saline, dry air, and professional medical advice when needed. That's the only real way to handle it.