You’ve seen the video. A suburban mom or a retired teacher is standing in their driveway, blindsided by a camera crew and a giant check. They scream. They cry. Maybe they fall to their knees. It’s the ultimate American lottery: winning a multi-million dollar, custom-built mansion in a location like Aspen, Key West, or Newport. But winning is just the start of a very complicated, very expensive story.
The truth is, being one of the HGTV Dream Home winners is kinda like inheriting a small, very beautiful country that you can't actually afford to run.
Most people think winning a house means you just pack your bags and move in. Not even close. Since the sweepstakes began in 1997, a massive majority of winners—over 90% by some estimates—never actually live in the home for more than a year. Most sell it back to the developer or put it on the market within months. It isn’t because they don’t like the decor. It’s because the IRS doesn't care about your "dream" aesthetics; they just want their cut of the $2 million valuation.
The Tax Man Cometh (And He Wants $700k)
Let’s get real about the math. When you win a prize that includes a house, a new car, and a pile of cash, the federal government views that entire package as income. If the 2024 HGTV Dream Home in Florida was valued at roughly $2.2 million, the winner is looking at a federal tax bill that could easily clear $700,000.
Then comes the state.
If you win a home in a state with high income tax, you're tacking on another six figures. You haven't even paid the property taxes yet. For a waterfront mansion, those can run $20,000 to $50,000 annually. Most HGTV Dream Home winners are regular people—teachers, retirees, small business owners. They don't have $800,000 sitting in a savings account to pay for a "free" house.
Honestly, it’s a bit of a trap. A beautiful, gold-plated trap.
Take Don Cruz, the 2005 winner of the Tyler, Texas home. He’s one of the few winners who actually tried to make it work. He moved his family into the 6,000-square-foot mansion, hoping to turn it into a bed and breakfast. But the local zoning laws were a nightmare, and the maintenance costs were astronomical. He eventually had to sell. He later told reporters that the experience was a whirlwind that almost ruined him financially. It’s a cautionary tale that every hopeful entrant should probably read twice.
👉 See also: How is gum made? The sticky truth about what you are actually chewing
Why Most Winners Take the Cash Option
HGTV isn't stupid. They know most people can't afford the taxes. That's why, in recent years, the prize package almost always includes a "cash option."
Basically, instead of taking the $2.5 million home, the car, and the $100k in cash, you can choose to take a smaller lump sum of cash—usually around $600,000 to $750,000—and walk away without the deed to the house.
- The House Route: You get a $2M asset but owe $800k immediately.
- The Cash Route: You get $700k, pay about 30-37% in taxes, and keep a clean $450,000.
Most winners take the cash. It’s the smarter move. It pays off the mortgage on their actual house, puts the kids through college, and buys a nice dinner. It just doesn't make for a very good TV special. Nobody wants to watch a show called HGTV: I Took the Cash Option and Paid Off My Student Loans. We want the fantasy.
The Reality of Living in a Showroom
Even if you can afford the taxes, living in these houses is weird.
Every single piece of furniture, every towel, and every "artistic" bowl of lemons is chosen by a designer like Brian Patrick Flynn to look good on camera. It’s a set. It’s not necessarily a home.
Imagine living in a house where everything is white and there are literal trees growing in the living room because it looked "organic" for the 4K cameras. David Glickman, who won the 2014 home in Lake Tahoe, famously pointed out that the logistics of these wins are staggering. You have to fly out there. You have to deal with the local press. You have to figure out if you even want to live in a tourist town where fans of the show might drive by your house to take pictures of your mailbox.
It’s a loss of privacy that many HGTV Dream Home winners aren't prepared for. Your name and face are everywhere. People know exactly how much your "assets" are worth.
✨ Don't miss: Curtain Bangs on Fine Hair: Why Yours Probably Look Flat and How to Fix It
A Look Back at the Winners Who Kept It (Briefly)
- 1998: Belinda Brown (Lowcountry, SC). She actually stayed for a while! She enjoyed the home but eventually sold it because the taxes and the sheer size of the property were too much for a primary residence.
- 2008: Stephanie Caba (Islamorada, FL). She took the house but sold it quickly. The Florida Keys are stunning, but the insurance on a luxury waterfront property in a hurricane zone is enough to make anyone’s head spin.
- Recent Years: Most winners now quietly take the cash or sell the home back to the developer before they even move a box of clothes.
The Logistics of the "Surprise"
Is the surprise real? Mostly.
The producers go to great lengths to "ambush" the winner. They coordinate with family members to make sure the winner is home and hasn't just hopped into the shower. But there’s a lot of paperwork signed beforehand. You have to agree to be filmed. You have to agree to the rules of the sweepstakes. By the time the cameras show up, the winner knows something is up, but the actual moment of "You just won a $2 million house" is still a massive shock.
It’s a massive production.
There are lighting rigs, sound guys, and producers directing the "natural" reaction. It’s entertainment. And HGTV is very, very good at it. They sell the dream of a fresh start, a beautiful view, and a kitchen with two dishwashers.
What You Should Do if You Actually Win
So, you’ve entered the sweepstakes. You used both your daily entries. You’re dreaming of that mountain retreat in Colorado. What happens if you actually get the call?
First, don't sign anything until you hire a tax attorney. Not a regular accountant—a tax attorney who specializes in high-value windfalls. You need to understand the "basis" of the prize.
Second, check the local real estate market. If you take the house and try to sell it, how long will it sit? Luxury homes in remote "dream" locations can sometimes take a year to sell. Can you afford to pay the utilities, security, and property taxes for twelve months while you wait for a buyer? Most people can’t.
🔗 Read more: Bates Nut Farm Woods Valley Road Valley Center CA: Why Everyone Still Goes After 100 Years
Third, consider the "Cash Option" seriously. It’s less "dreamy," but it’s real money. Real money buys real freedom.
The Evolution of the Prize
The program has changed over the decades. In the early days, the homes were often smaller, more "livable." Now, they are massive architectural statements. They are designed to showcase sponsors—Wayfair, Kohler, Trex decking. The house is essentially a 5,000-square-foot 3D advertisement.
That’s not a knock on the quality; the construction is usually top-tier. But it means the house is built to be a showpiece, not necessarily a place where you want to kick off your shoes and eat pizza on the sofa.
The locations have also shifted toward high-end vacation destinations. This makes the "rental" potential high, but many HOAs in these exclusive communities have strict rules against short-term rentals like Airbnb. You might think you can just rent the house out to pay the taxes, only to find out the neighborhood association will sue you if you try.
Actionable Steps for Future Entrants
If you're serious about being one of the next HGTV Dream Home winners, you need to play the game with your eyes open. It’s a fun hobby, but it’s also a potential financial "event."
- Max out your entries. You can usually enter once a day on the HGTV website and once a day on the Food Network website. Consistency is the only way to beat the astronomical odds.
- Read the official rules. Every year, the rules change slightly regarding the cash option and the "prizes" included. Sometimes the car is a lease; sometimes it’s a purchase. Know what you're signing up for.
- Have a plan for the "Ambush." If you win, the media will descend. Decide now how much of your life you want to be public. You can decline some of the publicity, though it’s hard once the cameras are in your face.
- Do the "Mental Math" now. Look at the home’s estimated value. Multiply it by .37. If you can't imagine where that money would come from, you’re taking the cash option. Accepting that reality now makes the win much less stressful later.
The HGTV Dream Home is a beautiful piece of Americana. It represents the idea that anyone can be plucked from their ordinary life and dropped into a world of luxury. Just remember that in the real world, luxury has a monthly bill, and the most successful winners are the ones who treat the prize like a business decision rather than a fairytale.