The gates at 36 Essex Street are officially shut. It’s quiet now. For anyone who drove past that massive, 50-acre stone estate in Wenham over the last decade, the sight of the Academy at Penguin Hall was a landmark of the North Shore. But by June 2025, the dream of a premier all-girls preparatory school in the Catholic tradition had effectively evaporated into a mess of legal filings and unpaid bills.
It wasn't just a quiet exit. Honestly, it was a total collapse.
When the news broke that the Wenham school Penguin Hall closes, families were left scrambling. Some had already paid tuition for a 2025-2026 school year that will never happen. Teachers, the people who actually built the "joyful community" the school bragged about, were left with bounced paychecks and no health insurance. If you're looking for a simple "enrollment was down" story, you aren't going to find it here. This is about millions in debt, a federal tax lien, and a bankruptcy filing that came just in time to stop an auction block.
Why Penguin Hall reached a breaking point
Basically, the school was bleeding money for years. While the estate looked like something out of a movie—it was built in 1929 for a Detroit socialite and once housed a legendary ad agency—it was a financial black hole.
By the time the board sent that final "effective immediately" email on June 13, 2025, the numbers were staggering. We’re talking about a $6.5 million negative fund balance back in 2022. It didn't get better. By 2024, liabilities had ballooned toward the $25 million mark.
💡 You might also like: Brian Walshe Trial Date: What Really Happened with the Verdict
You can't run a school on vibes alone. Enrollment had plummeted from a pre-pandemic high of over 150 students to just about 70. When your main source of income is tuition, and you lose half your "customers," the math just stops working. The school tried a "Hail Mary" by hiking tuition 40%—up to $42,800 a year. Unsurprisingly, that didn't exactly bring in a flood of new families.
The legal drama you might have missed
The closure wasn't the first red flag. Not even close.
The IRS had already put a lien on the property for nearly $188,000 in unpaid payroll taxes. That’s a huge deal. It means the money that was supposed to go toward Social Security and Medicare for the staff was being used elsewhere—or just wasn't there.
Then there’s the water bill. The Town of Wenham actually threatened to shut off the water in 2023 because the school owed $18,000. It’s hard to run a chemistry lab or a cafeteria when the town is ready to dry up the pipes. Even now, the school still reportedly owes thousands to the town for basic utilities and fire details.
The bankruptcy and the 2026 auction
On June 11, 2025, the school filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy. This was a strategic move. A public auction was literally scheduled for that same week, and the filing put a "stay" on it, giving the leadership a moment to breathe.
📖 Related: How Old is CHRR? What People Get Wrong About the Ohio State Research Giant
But breathing room doesn't pay the bills.
As of early 2026, the court records show the situation is still being untangled. There have been expedited motions to sell the property at 36 Essex Street "free and clear of liens." Hearings in January 2026 have been focused on a "break-up fee" and finalizing the sale. The goal is simple: sell the historic manor and the land to pay back a fraction of what is owed to creditors.
- The Creditors: It’s a long list. It includes local vendors, the IRS, the Town of Wenham, and—most heartbreakingly—the teachers.
- The Investigation: The Massachusetts Attorney General’s Office had already been looking into the school following complaints. Whether that turns into something more serious remains the big question hanging over Wenham.
What happened to the families?
This is where it gets messy. Some parents claim they were encouraged to pay for the next year just weeks before the school folded. They’re now listed as "unsecured creditors" in the bankruptcy. In plain English? They are at the back of the line to get their money back.
Most of these girls had to find new schools in a matter of weeks. Some went to Pingree, others to local publics or Bishop Fenwick. It wasn't just a change of scenery; it was the loss of a specific culture that many felt couldn't be replicated elsewhere.
👉 See also: The Yogurt Shop Murders Location: What Actually Stands There Today
What we can learn from the Penguin Hall closure
Private schools aren't invincible. The "niche" school model—all-girls, North Shore, high tuition—is incredibly fragile. When a school like this fails, it usually happens in three stages:
- The Enrollment Slide: Once you dip below a certain "critical mass," the social experience for the kids suffers, leading to more transfers.
- The Debt Trap: Using payroll taxes or utility money to cover operations is a "canary in the coal mine."
- The Trust Gap: Once the community realizes the finances are shaky, the donations stop, and the spiral accelerates.
If you’re a former parent or a creditor, your best bet is staying tuned to the U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Massachusetts (Case No. 25-11191). That is where the final remains of the school are being carved up.
Next Steps for Impacted Families:
Keep all records of tuition payments made for the 2025-2026 year. If you haven't already, ensure you have officially filed a proof of claim with the bankruptcy court. While the "unsecured" status is tough, it is your only legal avenue for recovery. For teachers, check with the Department of Labor regarding unpaid wages, as these claims sometimes take priority in certain liquidation scenarios. The 48-acre estate will likely transition to a new owner by the end of 2026, potentially ending the "Penguin Hall" chapter for good.