It was 2014. Dog walkers in Central Park stumbled across something that looked like a scene from a low-budget dark comedy. A dead black bear cub.
Tucked under a bush.
Resting on top of a discarded bicycle.
For a decade, the rfk central park bear mystery was just another "only in New York" urban legend. People theorized about occult rituals or escaped zoo animals. The NYPD animal cruelty squad even opened an investigation. Then, in the middle of a high-stakes presidential run in 2024, Robert F. Kennedy Jr. decided to just... tell the truth.
He didn't do it through a formal press release or a somber news conference. Instead, he posted a video on X (formerly Twitter) of himself sitting in a kitchen, recounting the story to a visibly baffled Roseanne Barr.
Honestly, the reality is weirder than the theories.
The Day the RFK Central Park Bear Went to Dinner
According to Kennedy, the whole thing started with roadkill. He was on his way to go falconing—which is a very RFK Jr. detail—near Goshen in the Hudson Valley. A woman driving a van ahead of him hit a six-month-old female black bear cub.
Kennedy pulled over. He didn't see a tragedy; he saw an opportunity.
✨ Don't miss: Tony Dow Funeral Pictures: What Really Happened Behind the Scenes
"I picked up the bear and put him in the back of my van because I was going to skin the bear," he explained in the video. Apparently, the carcass was in "very good condition." He planned to keep the meat in his refrigerator. It’s worth noting that in New York, you actually can legally harvest roadkill bear if you get a tag from the Department of Environmental Conservation (DEC).
But the falconry trip ran late.
Then came a dinner at Peter Luger Steakhouse in Brooklyn.
By the time the meal ended, Kennedy was in a bind. He had a dead, un-skinned bear cub in his car. It was getting late, and he had to head straight to the airport. He couldn't take the bear home to Westchester, and he definitely didn't want to leave a rotting carcass in a van at the airport.
Staging the Bicycle Prank
So, what does a Kennedy do with a dead bear and a deadline? Naturally, he creates a crime scene.
Kennedy happened to have an old bicycle in his car that someone had asked him to get rid of. "Let's go put the bear in Central Park and we'll make it look like he got hit by a bike," he told his friends. He admitted they had been drinking—though he specified that he was sober at the time.
They thought it would be funny. "Amusing for whoever found it," were his exact words.
They dumped the 44-pound cub near West 69th Street and West Drive, laid the bike on top, and vanished into the night.
The next morning, the city went into a full-blown frenzy. Yellow crime scene tape stretched for a mile. Helicopters circled overhead. The story hit the front page of the New York Times. In a bizarre twist of fate, the original 2014 article in the Times was actually written by Tatiana Schlossberg—RFK Jr.'s own niece and the granddaughter of JFK. She had no idea her uncle was the culprit.
Kennedy watched the news from afar, terrified. He’d left his fingerprints all over that bike. He expected a knock on the door at any moment, but as the days turned into weeks, the investigation went cold. The "mystery of the Central Park bear" became a footnote in NYC history until 2024.
Why the Truth Came Out Now
You might wonder why anyone would volunteer this information while running for President of the United States.
The answer is simple: The media caught him.
The New Yorker was preparing a massive profile on Kennedy, written by Clare Malone. They had found a photograph of Kennedy posing with his fingers in the dead bear’s mouth, mimicking a bite. Knowing the story was about to break, Kennedy tried to "front-run" the news by releasing his own version first.
It was a classic damage control move that backfired into a week-long news cycle about "the bear story."
Key Details of the RFK Central Park Bear Incident:
- Date of discovery: October 6, 2014.
- Location: Near West 69th Street, Central Park.
- The Animal: A 44-pound female black bear cub.
- The Staging: A bicycle was placed on top of the carcass to simulate an accident.
- Legal Status: The statute of limitations for illegal dumping or failing to report the bear had long since expired (it's usually one year in NY).
The Impact on the 2024 Campaign
The rfk central park bear incident wasn't just a quirky anecdote. It became a symbol for critics who argued that Kennedy’s behavior was erratic.
It followed other strange revelations, like his mention of a "brain worm" (which he jokingly suggested he might have caught from the bear) and the controversy over a photo that appeared to show him eating a dog (which he clarified was a goat in South America).
For his supporters, it was just more evidence of his "unfiltered" and "anti-establishment" persona. For everyone else, it was a reminder of how strange American politics had become in 2024.
Actionable Insights and Takeaways
If you find yourself in a situation involving wildlife or bizarre PR crises, here is what we can learn from this saga:
- Check Local Roadkill Laws: If you plan on picking up a bear in New York, you must contact the DEC immediately to get a "possession tag." Don't wait until after a steak dinner.
- The Internet Never Forgets: Even a prank from ten years ago can resurface. If there’s a photo of it, assume it will eventually be public.
- Transparency vs. Timing: Kennedy’s attempt to get ahead of the story shows that in the digital age, owning the narrative is better than being "exposed," even if the narrative itself is objectively weird.
- Statutes of Limitation Matter: One reason Kennedy likely felt comfortable admitting to this was the 10-year gap. Most environmental and littering violations have very short windows for prosecution.
Ultimately, the Central Park bear story remains one of the strangest intersections of wildlife, urban mystery, and political theater in modern history. It serves as a stark reminder that the truth is often much weirder than the conspiracy theories we invent to fill the gaps.