January 20, 2025. Washington D.C. was buzzing. Donald Trump had just been inaugurated for his second term, and the air at the Capital One Arena was thick with that high-voltage MAGA energy. Then Elon Musk stepped onto the stage. He did a little dance—the kind of awkward, stiff-armed shuffling we’ve seen at his rallies before—and then he did it. He slapped his hand to his chest and flung his right arm out, palm down, toward the crowd. He did it once to the front, then turned and did it again to the back.
Social media didn't just break; it detonated.
Within minutes, the term "Elon Musk Nazi salute" was trending globally. To one half of the internet, it was a blatant "Sieg Heil" performed in the heart of American power. To the other half, it was just a socially awkward billionaire being, well, socially awkward. Honestly, the gap between those two interpretations is where the real story lives.
The Gesture Heard ‘Round the World
Let's look at the tape. Musk was wrapping up a short speech where he thanked the voters for "making it happen." As he finished, he made a straight-arm gesture that, to many historians, looked exactly like the salute used in Nazi Germany and Fascist Italy.
Ruth Ben-Ghiat, a history professor at New York University and an expert on fascism, didn't mince words. She called it a "Nazi salute—and a very belligerent one too." On the flip side, the Anti-Defamation League (ADL), which has had a rocky relationship with Musk to say the least, actually came to his defense. They posted on X that it looked like an "awkward gesture in a moment of enthusiasm" rather than a deliberate hate symbol.
✨ Don't miss: Will Palestine Ever Be Free: What Most People Get Wrong
It's a weird spot to be in when the ADL is the one telling everyone to "take a breath" while Holocaust survivors like Masha Pearl are calling it an "unmistakable symbol of hate."
Roman Salute or Just a "Heart" Gesture?
Pretty quickly, a defense started circulating among Musk’s inner circle. Andrea Stroppa, an advisor to Musk, initially tweeted that the "Roman empire is back," hinting at the "Roman salute." For those who aren't history nerds, the Roman salute is that same arm-extended motion. The problem? Historians generally agree that the "Roman salute" is a bit of a myth—there's almost no evidence the ancient Romans actually used it. It was mostly popularized by 19th-century plays and later adopted by Mussolini and Hitler.
Later, the narrative shifted. The new line was that Musk was simply moving his hand from his heart to the crowd to say "my heart goes out to you."
Texas Senator Ted Cruz backed this up, pointing out that Musk literally said those words as he made the move. If you watch the video, the timing does align with the speech. But in the world of optics, intent often gets buried by impact. In Germany, where that specific gesture is a literal crime, the headlines were brutal. Der Spiegel and other major outlets weren't buying the "awkward wave" excuse.
🔗 Read more: JD Vance River Raised Controversy: What Really Happened in Ohio
A Pattern of "Edgelord" Behavior
You can't really talk about this salute without talking about what led up to it. Context is everything. Musk hasn't exactly been playing it safe with his rhetoric over the last couple of years.
- The "Actual Truth" Incident: Back in late 2023, Musk replied "You have said the actual truth" to a post on X that pushed the "Great Replacement" conspiracy theory—a staple of white supremacist ideology.
- The Ad Exodus: That single reply caused Disney, Apple, and IBM to yank their ads. Musk's response? He told the CEOs to "go f*** themselves" during a live interview.
- The Puns: Just days after the 2025 salute controversy, Musk leaned into the "edgelord" persona. He posted a string of Nazi-themed puns on X, like "Some people will Goebbels anything down" and "His pronouns would’ve been He/Himmler."
Basically, if you're trying to convince the world you aren't flirting with far-right imagery, making Goebbels jokes 72 hours after a controversial salute is... a choice.
What the Data Says
Interestingly, the public is as split as you’d expect. A YouGov survey taken shortly after the inauguration found that 42% of Americans viewed it as a Nazi or Roman salute. Meanwhile, another 42% saw it as a "gesture from the heart."
The divide was almost perfectly partisan. If you liked Trump, you saw a guy being nice to a crowd. If you didn't, you saw a fascist. It’s a classic Rorschach test for 2026 politics.
💡 You might also like: Who's the Next Pope: Why Most Predictions Are Basically Guesswork
Why This Still Matters
Whether you think it was a "Sieg Heil" or a "from the heart" wave, the fallout was real. It wasn't just a Twitter spat. Major European politicians expressed genuine alarm. German Health Minister Karl Lauterbach was among those who chimed in, reflecting a deep-seated European anxiety about American leaders normalizing symbols that are banned in their own countries.
Musk himself has dismissed the whole thing as "dirty tricks" and part of a "tired" attack. He’s basically saying the media is crying wolf. But when you’re the richest man in the world and you hold a massive amount of government influence through the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE), people are going to scrutinize every finger twitch.
How to Navigate the Noise
If you’re trying to make sense of this, here’s the reality: there is no "smoking gun" where Musk says, "Yes, I am doing a Nazi salute." But there is a long, documented trail of Musk using provocative, far-right-adjacent language to trigger his critics.
To stay informed without falling for the rage-bait:
- Watch the raw footage: Don't rely on a still screenshot. Watch the 10 seconds before and after the gesture.
- Check the source: Look at who is defending him and who is accusing him. Most of the time, the "expert" opinion matches their political leaning.
- Recognize the "Edgelord" Strategy: Musk often uses ambiguity as a shield. If a gesture can be interpreted two ways, he gets to keep his base happy while calling his critics "crazy" for seeing the darker version.
The 2025 inauguration gesture will likely go down as one of those "did he or didn't he" moments that defines the current era of political polarization. It’s less about the arm and more about what the arm represents in a fractured society.
To understand the full scope of this, you should look into the history of the "Bellamy salute" in the United States—it's a fascinating look at how a gesture that was once patriotic became completely untouchable because of its resemblance to fascism. It puts the whole Musk controversy into a much wider historical frame.