:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/3398863-56a04c2d3df78cafdaa0f6eb-5c5b4da3c9e77c0001d9299a.jpg)
The 1900s were, frankly, a mess. You had two world wars, the rise and fall of the Iron Curtain, and the birth of the internet. Right in the middle of all that chaos sat a succession of men in white robes who had to figure out how an ancient institution could survive a modern, often violent, world. When we look back at popes in the 20th century, it’s not just a list of names; it’s a story of how the papacy shifted from being a "prisoner of the Vatican" to a global political powerhouse.
Leo XIII kicked off the century, though he died in 1903. He was actually the first pope to be filmed and the first to have his voice recorded. Think about that. Before him, the Pope was basically a ghost to anyone who didn't live in Rome. By the time John Paul II was traveling the world in the 90s, the Pope was a bona fide celebrity. That’s a massive leap in just a hundred years.
The Men Who Saw the World Burn
The early part of the century was dominated by the "Roman Question." The Italian government had seized Rome in 1870, and for decades, the popes basically sulked inside the Vatican walls, refusing to recognize the Italian state. Pius X, who followed Leo, was a bit of a hardliner. He was obsessed with "Modernism," which he saw as a poison. He even made priests take an anti-modernist oath. He died just as World War I was breaking out. People say he died of a broken heart because of the war, but that's probably a bit of a stretch—he was 79 and had health issues.
Then came Benedict XV. He’s the guy history books usually skip over, which is a shame. He spent his entire papacy trying to stop "the suicide of civilized Europe." He stayed neutral during World War I, which made everyone hate him. The Allies thought he was pro-German; the Central Powers thought he was pro-Allies. He actually went broke because he spent so much Vatican money on food and clothing for war refugees. He was basically a humanitarian hero whom nobody thanked.
Then you have Pius XI. He’s the one who finally fixed the "prisoner" situation. In 1929, he signed the Lateran Treaty with Mussolini. Yes, that Mussolini. It was a deal with the devil in many ways, but it created Vatican City as a sovereign state. It gave the Church its own zip code and its own rules. But Pius XI wasn't a fan of the fascists for long. Before he died, he was preparing a massive encyclical against racism and anti-Semitism. He died before he could publish it.
📖 Related: Trump Approval Rating State Map: Why the Red-Blue Divide is Moving
The Controversy of Silence: Pius XII
If you want to start a heated debate among historians, just mention Pius XII. He reigned from 1939 to 1958, right through World War II and the start of the Cold War. Some people call him "Hitler’s Pope," a term popularized by author John Cornwell. Others argue he was a silent hero who worked behind the scenes to save thousands of Jews.
The reality? It's complicated. Honestly, Pius XII was a career diplomat. He spoke in "Vaticanese"—that dense, flowery language where you say a lot without saying anything specific. He didn't want to provoke the Nazis because he feared it would lead to more deaths, specifically of Catholics in occupied territories. But we also know he hid Jews in the basement of Castel Gandolfo. The debate usually boils down to whether his silence was a moral failure or a strategic necessity. There is no middle ground here, and even with the Vatican opening its archives recently, the jury is still out.
A Sudden Change of Pace
After the stiff, aristocratic Pius XII died, the cardinals picked Angelo Roncalli, who became John XXIII. Everyone thought he was a "caretaker pope." He was old, he was portly, and he was supposed to just keep the seat warm. Instead, he threw a metaphorical grenade into the Church by calling the Second Vatican Council (Vatican II).
"I want to throw open the windows of the Church so that we can see out and the people can see in," he reportedly said.
👉 See also: Ukraine War Map May 2025: Why the Frontlines Aren't Moving Like You Think
Vatican II changed everything. The Mass stopped being in Latin. The priest turned around to face the people. It was a seismic shift. John XXIII didn't live to see the end of it; he died in 1963. Paul VI had to finish the job. Paul VI is the guy who had to deal with the 60s—the sexual revolution, the Vietnam War, and the fallout from Humanae Vitae, the document that reaffirmed the ban on artificial birth control. That one document probably did more to alienate lay Catholics in the West than anything else in the century.
The Year of Three Popes
1978 was a wild year for the Vatican. Paul VI died in August. John Paul I was elected, smiled a lot for 33 days, and then died of a heart attack in his bed. The conspiracy theories went nuts. People thought he was murdered by the Mafia or poisoned by corrupt bankers. There’s no actual evidence for that, but it makes for a great movie plot.
Because they had to have a second conclave in two months, the cardinals got bold. They went outside of Italy for the first time in 455 years and picked a Pole: Karol Wojtyła.
The Superstar Era: John Paul II
Karol Wojtyła, or John Paul II, was a force of nature. He was young (for a pope), he was an athlete, and he knew how to work a crowd. If the earlier popes in the 20th century were distant monarchs, John Paul II was a global politician. He is widely credited—along with Reagan and Thatcher—for helping topple Communism in Eastern Europe. His 1979 trip to Poland was a turning point in history. He didn't tell people to revolt; he just told them "Be not afraid."
✨ Don't miss: Percentage of Women That Voted for Trump: What Really Happened
He survived an assassination attempt in 1981, visited his shooter in prison, and then spent the next two decades traveling to every corner of the earth. He was the first pope to visit a mosque. He was the first to visit a synagogue. But he was also a staunch conservative who held the line on women priests and celibacy. By the time the century ended, he was the face of the Catholic Church for an entire generation.
The Darker Side of the 90s
We can't talk about the papacy at the end of the 20th century without mentioning the shadows. The clerical sex abuse scandal began to bubble up in a way that couldn't be ignored anymore. While it would explode in the early 2000s, the failures of the 80s and 90s to properly address the crisis remain a massive stain on the legacy of the late-century Church leadership. The Vatican's bureaucracy, the Curia, was often more interested in protecting the "prestige" of the institution than the safety of children. It’s a harsh truth that balances out the "heroic" narrative of the Cold War.
Key Takeaways of the Papal Century
To understand the 1900s through the lens of the Vatican, you have to see the progression. It’s a move from isolation to total immersion in the world.
- Political Sovereignty: The Lateran Treaty of 1929 gave the Pope a state, which gave him a "seat at the table" in international law.
- Media Evolution: The papacy moved from grainy black-and-white photos to satellite broadcasts and world tours.
- Theology: Vatican II (1962-1965) is the most significant religious event of the century, moving the Church from a "fortress" mentality to an "outward-facing" one.
- The Cold War: The papacy played a pivotal role in the collapse of the Soviet bloc, particularly through the influence of John Paul II in Poland.
What to do with this information
If you want to dig deeper into this, don't just read the official Vatican biographies. They’re sanitized. Instead, look into the specific works of historians like Eamon Duffy (Saints and Sinners) or David Kertzer (The Pope and Mussolini). Kertzer’s work, in particular, uses the recently opened archives to show a much more "human" and flawed side of Pius XI and Pius XII.
Another great step is to look at the primary documents of Vatican II, specifically Gaudium et Spes. It’s surprisingly readable for a church document and explains exactly why the Church decided it needed to stop hiding from the modern world. Understanding the 20th-century popes is basically a cheat code for understanding why the world looks the way it does today. It’s about power, diplomacy, and the messy intersection of ancient faith and modern politics.
Go watch some of the original footage of John XXIII opening the council; the sheer scale of thousands of bishops from every continent descending on Rome is a visual reminder of how much the world changed between 1900 and 1999.