If you’ve been following sports media for the last decade, you know things between Michelle Beadle and Stephen A. Smith aren't just "tense"—they're radioactive. Most professional rivalries involve a bit of petty Twitter shade or a competitive grab for ratings. This is different. It’s a multi-year, multi-platform collision that recently exploded all over again.
Honestly, it’s the kind of bridge-burning that makes modern HR departments sweat. We aren't just talking about two people who don't want to grab a beer. We’re talking about Michelle Beadle publicly stating she “prays for the downfall” of the biggest face at ESPN.
The 2014 Incident That Sparked the Fire
To understand why Michelle Beadle and Stephen A. Smith are currently at each other’s throats, you have to go back to 2014. Specifically, the Ray Rice domestic violence case. During a segment on First Take, Stephen A. made comments suggesting that women should look at "the provocative nature" of their own actions to avoid physical domestic abuse.
Beadle didn't just disagree; she went for the jugular on social media. She tweeted that she was "forced" to watch the segment and felt like she could never "feel clean again."
Smith was suspended for a week.
That was the "beginning of the end," according to Beadle. It wasn't just a difference of opinion. It was a fundamental lack of respect that has lingered like a bad smell for twelve years.
Why It Still Matters in 2026
Fast forward to late 2025 and early 2026, and the beef has reached a fever pitch. In June 2025, Beadle was hosting her show Beadle & Decker on SiriusXM. Out of nowhere, news broke that she was being replaced.
🔗 Read more: Liverpool FC Chelsea FC: Why This Grudge Match Still Hits Different
The person taking her time slot? Stephen A. Smith.
Beadle claimed she was "blindsided." She didn't find out from her bosses; she found out by reading a headline in The Hollywood Reporter. Imagine waking up and seeing the guy you’ve loathed for a decade standing in your old office.
The Solitaire Scandal and the "Downfall" Quote
Things got weirdly specific in November 2025. Stephen A. Smith had been caught on camera playing solitaire on his phone during the NBA Finals. Most people laughed it off as "Stephen A. being Stephen A."
But then he turned it into a business deal.
He signed an endorsement deal with an app called Solitaire Cash (owned by Papaya Gaming). This really ticked Beadle off. On her podcast, she slammed him for having "no principles," pointing out that the company was facing lawsuits over alleged fraudulent bot activity.
"Honestly, I’m not a religious person, but I pray for the downfall," Beadle said on the Beadle & Decker podcast. "It’s gross, man."
💡 You might also like: NFL Football Teams in Order: Why Most Fans Get the Hierarchy Wrong
That’s a heavy sentiment. Usually, media people keep it "professional." Not here. She’s basically saying the quiet part out loud—that she wants to see his empire crumble.
Stephen A. Strikes Back
Smith isn't exactly known for staying quiet. On his Straight Shooter podcast, he fired back at Beadle and another former colleague, Cari Champion. He called Beadle’s attitude "stink" and "evil."
His argument? He doesn't even know her. He claims they’ve never had a real conversation and that she’s just bitter because her career hasn't stayed on the same trajectory as his. He basically hit her with the "I don't think about you at all" move, even though he spent a significant amount of time yelling about her on his show.
Breaking Down the "Gatekeeper" Theory
There’s a deeper layer here that most people miss. During her time at ESPN, especially when she was hosting Get Up, Beadle reportedly refused to work with Smith. She admitted as much to Michael McCarthy at Front Office Sports, saying she would never share a set with him again because "life’s too short."
Smith uses this as proof that she was unprofessional.
He argues that while he was out there building a "gazillion dollar" brand (Beadle's words), she was busy being "disrespectful" to the people who actually run the network. It’s a classic power struggle. One person sees themselves as a principled rebel against a "monster" created by corporate greed; the other sees a "trifling" former coworker who couldn't cut it.
📖 Related: Why Your 1 Arm Pull Up Progression Isn't Working (And How to Fix It)
Why fans are torn
The reaction online is messy. Some fans think Beadle is the only one brave enough to call out Smith’s "yelling for dollars" style. Others think she’s just "salty" about her SiriusXM slot.
- The Beadle Camp: Argues that Smith has ruined the NBA Finals with his lack of focus and that his constant "shilling" for apps like Papaya Gaming is a bad look for a journalist.
- The Smith Camp: Points to the ratings. Like him or hate him, people watch. They argue Beadle "failed her way" out of major networks while Smith remains the king of the hill.
What Happens Now?
As we move through 2026, don't expect a reconciliation. There will be no "sit down" on First Take. There will be no joint podcast.
Stephen A. Smith is currently expanding his empire into cable news and acting (look for him on General Hospital and potentially more Law & Order). Beadle is carving out a niche in the independent podcasting space with Cody Decker.
The reality is that Michelle Beadle and Stephen A. Smith represent two different eras of sports media. One is the era of the "unfiltered" host who cares about the soul of the game. The other is the era of the "personality" who is the game.
Actionable Insights for Following the Feud:
- Watch the Platforms: If you want the rawest takes, listen to Beadle’s independent podcast. She no longer has the Disney/ESPN filter, which is why her comments have become so much more aggressive.
- Check the Lawsuits: The Papaya Gaming lawsuit is the real-world factor here. If that legal battle goes south, Beadle’s "ethics" argument against Smith’s endorsements will carry a lot more weight in the industry.
- Monitor SiriusXM Ratings: If Smith’s new show significantly outperforms Beadle’s old numbers, the "bitterness" narrative will likely stick to her. If it flops, she gets the last laugh.
At the end of the day, this isn't just a beef. It’s a case study in how burning a bridge at a major network can follow you for decades. Whether you think Smith is a "monster" or Beadle is "bitter," one thing is for sure: neither one is backing down.