It was the "shove" heard ‘round the internet. Honestly, if you’ve spent more than five minutes on social media lately, you’ve probably seen the clip: a beaming, wide-eyed Drew Barrymore leaning in close—maybe too close—and the legendary Martha Stewart literally pushing her back into the sofa cushions.
The moment went viral instantly. People were calling it "cringe," "awkward," and even "the moment Martha finally had enough." But as with most things in the celebrity world, the 10-second TikTok snippet doesn't tell the whole story. Martha Stewart rebuffs Drew Barrymore's overly tactile interview style became the headline of the week, but was it a genuine smackdown or just two very different personalities trying to find a middle ground on national television?
Let’s be real: Drew Barrymore is a "hugger." She’s the person who meets you for the first time and acts like you’ve been best friends since kindergarten. Martha Stewart? Well, Martha is Martha. She’s the queen of poise, etiquette, and very clearly defined personal boundaries. When these two worlds collided on The Drew Barrymore Show, things got... interesting.
The Moment the Internet Lost Its Mind
So, what actually happened? Martha was on the show to promote her 100th cookbook—an incredible milestone, by the way. As they sat on that famous green couch, Drew did what Drew does. She scooted closer. She looked Martha in the eye with that intense, "I’m-really-listening-to-your-soul" expression.
Then came the question that triggered the physical contact. Drew asked Martha what makes her feel "soft and gooey" inside.
Martha, looking slightly perplexed, responded with one word: "Treatment."
Drew, leaning in further, began stroking Martha’s arm and back. "Soft and gooey treatment? Like when you're treated like a lady?" she asked. That’s when it happened. Martha gave a playful look to the audience, said, "You're the wrong gender," and gave Drew a firm—but seemingly theatrical—push. Drew tumbled backward onto the couch, laughing, while the audience roared.
Why This Moment Struck a Nerve
The reason this specific interaction exploded online is that it tapped into a long-running conversation about Drew’s "tactile" interviewing style. It wasn't just about Martha.
Over the last few seasons, viewers have noticed Drew’s habit of:
- Sitting on the floor at her guests' feet.
- Holding hands for the entire duration of a segment.
- Cuddling up on the couch like they’re at a slumber party.
For some, it’s endearing. It feels authentic and warm in a world of canned, robotic talk show interviews. But for others, it feels like a violation of professional boundaries. When Martha—a woman whose entire brand is built on "the right way to do things"—literally pushed back, it felt like a validation for the "team personal space" crowd.
Martha Stewart’s Perspective: "I’m Not So Cozy"
In a follow-up appearance on the show nearly a year later (September 2025), Martha and Drew finally addressed the "beef" rumors. Martha didn't sugarcoat it. She told Drew directly, "I just don't like to be petted on television."
She even quipped to the audience, "She's a very cozy girl, don't you think? I'm not so cozy."
It’s a classic East Coast vs. West Coast vibe shift. Martha grew up in a household where, as she noted in her Netflix documentary, there wasn't a lot of overt affection. She values order. Drew, on the other hand, is the quintessential California girl, seeking connection through touch.
The "Wrong Gender" Quip: Teasing or Telling?
One of the most debated parts of the clip was Martha’s comment: "You're the wrong gender."
Some viewers took this as a sharp rebuff, a way of saying, "If you were a man, maybe I’d tolerate this, but you’re not, so get off me." But in the context of the full interview, it felt more like Martha-style humor. It was dry, it was quick, and it was meant to move the segment along.
Drew herself later clarified on Watch What Happens Live with Andy Cohen that she felt Martha was just "teasing." She insisted there was no "beef" and that she actually felt like she had "broken through" with Martha.
"I think the internet just misunderstood the moment and ran with it... I think Martha really does like me." — Drew Barrymore
Is Tactile Interviewing the New Normal?
Whether you love it or hate it, Drew Barrymore's style has changed the talk show landscape. We’re used to the Jimmy Fallons and the Jimmy Kimmels who stay behind a desk, safe in their "host" zone. Drew destroys that zone.
But she’s also faced backlash before. Remember the interview with Oprah? Or the one with Cynthia Erivo? People have been warning Drew to "back off" for a while now. She even admitted in an interview with Entertainment Tonight that the pandemic was "so hard" for her because she was alone in a studio and couldn't be around people.
Why the "Shove" Actually Helped Both Brands
In a weird way, Martha Stewart rebuffs Drew Barrymore's overly tactile interview style was a win for both of them.
- For Martha: It reinforced her image as a strong woman who knows her boundaries and isn't afraid to enforce them, even in a "polite" setting. It made her look relatable to everyone who has ever had a "close talker" in their personal space.
- For Drew: It showed she can take a joke. She played the "fall" perfectly, making it a moment of physical comedy rather than an awkward confrontation. It humanized her and made her seem like someone who is genuinely trying to be affectionate, even if she misses the mark sometimes.
How to Set Boundaries Like Martha (Without Being a Jerk)
If you’re watching that clip and thinking, "I wish I could push people away like that," there are actually some lessons to be learned from how Martha handled it. She used humor to deflect a situation that made her uncomfortable. She didn't scream; she didn't leave the set. She just made it clear that "petting" wasn't her thing.
Honestly, we could all use a little more of that clarity. If someone is in your bubble, you don't have to just sit there and take it. You can say—with a smile—"I’m not a big hugger," or "I need a little more elbow room."
What’s Next for the Duo?
Despite the viral drama, the two are clearly still on good terms. They’ve appeared together since, laughed about the incident, and even "made a public service announcement" that there is no bad blood. Martha continues to promote her books and her documentary, and Drew continues to be the "cozy girl" of daytime TV.
If you find yourself in a situation where someone is getting a bit too "tactile" for your liking, remember the Martha Stewart method:
- Check the Vibe: Is the person being malicious or just overly friendly?
- Use Your Words (and maybe your hands): A gentle redirection or a quick joke can solve the problem without creating a scene.
- Stay True to Yourself: If you aren't "cozy," don't feel obligated to pretend you are.
Next time you see a celebrity "feud" trending, take a second to look at the full clip. Usually, it’s just two people trying to navigate the weird, high-pressure world of live television—one hug (or shove) at a time.
✨ Don't miss: Anna Nicole Smith Lawyer: What Most People Get Wrong
If you're interested in more behind-the-scenes celebrity dynamics, you might want to look into Martha Stewart’s recent documentary on Netflix, where she dives deeper into her upbringing and why she values her personal space so highly.