The story feels like a fever dream cooked up in a Hollywood writers' room. A high-school football star turned million-dollar drug dealer gets busted, goes to prison, and then gets a "get out of jail free" card—provided he can charm a confession out of a suspected serial killer.
Honestly, if you've seen the Apple TV+ series Black Bird, you know it’s intense. But what most people get wrong is where the script ends and the real life of James Keene begins.
It wasn't just some TV drama. It was a 1990s operation that actually happened, and the stakes were a lot higher than just a lighter sentence. If Jimmy failed, Larry Hall—a man suspected of killing dozens of young women—might have walked out of prison on appeal.
The Rise and Fall of the "Assassin"
James Keene wasn't a career criminal in the traditional sense. He was a local legend in Kankakee, Illinois. They called him "The Assassin" on the football field because he played like he was trying to put people in the hospital. He had the looks, the talent, and the scholarships.
But he liked money more than he liked school.
By the time he was in his early twenties, Keene was pulling in roughly a million dollars a year running a massive marijuana distribution network. He wasn't just some kid on a corner; he was an independent operator living in a mansion, hosting parties that people still talk about, and helping his dad, "Big Jim," get out of debt.
Then came 1996. The DEA and FBI launched "Operation Snowplow," and suddenly the party was over. Keene thought he could charm his way out of it or take a plea deal for a couple of years. He was wrong. The judge handed him ten years without the possibility of parole.
💡 You might also like: Why Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy Actors Still Define the Modern Spy Thriller
He was essentially buried alive.
The Deal Nobody Would Want
Enter Lawrence Beaumont. He was the federal prosecutor who put Keene away. About ten months into his sentence, Beaumont showed up with a proposal that sounded like suicide.
The FBI was terrified that Larry Hall, who was serving life for the kidnapping and murder of 15-year-old Jessica Roach, was going to win his appeal. Hall was a "serial confessor"—he’d admit to a murder, then claim he was just talking about a dream. Without a solid, detailed confession or the location of more bodies, he might go free.
The plan? Transfer Keene to the Medical Center for Federal Prisoners in Springfield, Missouri. It was a maximum-security mental health facility for the criminally insane.
Keene had to get close to Hall. He had to befriend a man suspected of murdering up to 40 women and get him to talk. If he succeeded, he walked out a free man with a clean record. If he failed or got outed as a snitch, he’d probably leave the prison in a body bag.
The Truth About Those Wooden Falcons
In the show, the tension is thick enough to cut with a knife. In real life, it was worse. Keene spent months playing the part of a "weapons runner" who had been given a 40-year sentence. He even beat up another inmate who tried to change the channel while Hall was watching TV—an act that earned Hall’s trust.
📖 Related: The Entire History of You: What Most People Get Wrong About the Grain
The turning point was the map.
Keene eventually found Hall in the prison workshop, hunched over a map of the Midwest. There were red dots scattered across Indiana, Illinois, and Wisconsin. On the table were these small, hand-carved wooden falcons.
Hall told him the falcons were there to "watch over the dead."
Basically, Keene had hit the jackpot. He had found the burial sites. But this is where the human element took over. Most people assume he just walked away and called his handler. Instead, Keene snapped. After months of pretending to be friends with a monster, he couldn't take it anymore. He unleashed a barrage of insults on Hall, essentially blowing his cover.
"I’m going home tomorrow, and you’re a monster," he told him, or something to that effect.
Because of that outburst, the FBI didn't get the map in time. Hall likely destroyed it before the authorities could seize it. Keene was thrown into solitary confinement, and for a few days, he thought he’d lost his chance at freedom.
👉 See also: Shamea Morton and the Real Housewives of Atlanta: What Really Happened to Her Peach
What Black Bird Gets Right (and Wrong)
The show is remarkably accurate, but some parts were definitely polished for TV.
- The Guard: In the series, a prison guard tries to extort Keene. In reality, that didn't happen. It was added to ramp up the tension of his isolation.
- The FBI Agent: The character of Lauren McCauley is a composite. While Keene worked with female agents, she represents several different people from his handler team.
- The Ending: The TV show makes the confrontation with Hall look like a cinematic masterpiece. While it was dramatic, it was also messy. Keene was acting on pure, raw emotion after hearing the horrific details of what Hall had done to girls like Tricia Reitler.
Hall remains behind bars today at a facility in Butner, North Carolina. He has confessed to more than 20 murders over the years, though he usually recants them later. Because of James Keene, Hall's appeal was denied, and he will never see the outside of a cell.
Life After the Devil
James Keene did eventually walk out. He got to spend five more years with his father before "Big Jim" passed away in 2004. He’s since become a successful businessman and an author, writing In with the Devil (which became Black Bird) and a follow-up called The Chicago Phoenix.
He even had a cameo in the final episode of the show—look for the prison guard in the background. It's a weirdly full-circle moment for a guy who went from being a prisoner to an operative.
If you’re looking to dive deeper into the case, here is how you can actually verify the details for yourself:
- Read the Memoir: Get Black Bird: One Man's Freedom Hides in Another Man's Darkness (the updated version of his first book). It contains the specific transcripts and details the show couldn't fit into six episodes.
- Watch the 2012 Dateline: Search for "The Inside Man" episode. It features the real James Keene talking about the case long before Taron Egerton ever stepped into the role.
- Research the Tricia Reitler Case: This is the missing girl Hall talked about most. Her family is still searching for her remains today, and understanding her story puts the weight of Keene's mission into perspective.
The reality is that James Keene wasn't a hero when he went into that prison. He was a drug dealer looking for a way out. But by the time he left, he had done something that seasoned investigators couldn't do. He stayed in the room with a predator long enough to make sure he never hurt anyone else. That’s not just a TV plot; it’s a heavy, complicated legacy.