It was Christmas night in 1996 when the world shifted for the Ramsey family in Boulder, Colorado. Most people remember the pageant photos—the feathers, the makeup, the big hair—but the actual crime scene was a chaotic, freezing basement that complicated the investigation from the very first hour. If you've ever found yourself spiraling down a late-night internet rabbit hole asking how was JonBenét Ramsey murdered, you’ve likely encountered a thousand different theories ranging from the plausible to the outright absurd.
Honestly, the "how" is often buried under the "who." But to understand why this case remains unsolved thirty years later, you have to look at the cold, hard physical evidence found in that cellar. It wasn't just one thing that killed her. It was a combination of brutal forces that still has forensic experts arguing today.
The Physical Evidence in the Basement
When John Ramsey found his daughter’s body at 1:05 PM on December 26, the scene was already compromised. He carried her upstairs, shifting the body and potentially destroying trace evidence. But the autopsy, performed by Dr. John Meyer, provided the grim specifics of the cause of death.
JonBenét died from asphyxiation due to strangulation associated with a craniocerebral trauma.
That’s the medical jargon. In plain English? She was hit over the head with immense force and strangled with a homemade garrot. The order of these events is a huge point of contention. Some experts, like legendary forensic pathologist Dr. Cyril Wecht, have suggested the head injury came first. The blow was so massive it caused an 8.5-inch fracture to her skull. It was a "displaced" fracture, meaning the bone actually moved.
Wait.
Think about the force required for that. We aren't talking about a slip and fall. We are talking about a strike that most experts believe came from a heavy, blunt object. A flashlight? A baseball bat? The police took a heavy Maglite from the kitchen counter that night, but DNA testing on it has never been conclusive.
The Garrote and the Knot
Then there’s the garrote. This wasn't just a piece of string. It was a length of white nylon cord tied around a broken piece of a paintbrush. The paintbrush actually belonged to Patsy Ramsey; it was kept in a tray near the basement door. The killer—or whoever was there—took the time to craft a specialized tool for strangulation.
The knot was a "Prusik" knot, or something very similar to it. It’s a complex hitch used in climbing and rescue operations. This is where the case gets weird. Why would an intruder take the time to make a garrote inside the house? Or, if it wasn't an intruder, why would a panicked family member go to such lengths?
The ligatures were found around her neck and her right wrist. The neck ligature was tightened with the wooden handle, creating a mechanical advantage that made the strangling much more "efficient," for lack of a better, less horrific word.
The Mystery of the Stun Gun Marks
If you look at the crime scene photos, you'll see two small, red abrasions on JonBenét’s lower back and neck. For years, Lou Smit, a legendary detective brought in to consult on the case, insisted these were stun gun marks. He believed an intruder used a device like an Air Taser to incapacitate the six-year-old before moving her to the basement.
But not everyone buys it.
The Boulder Police Department and several forensic pathologists argued those marks didn't match the standard distance of stun gun electrodes. Some suggested they were "pokes" from a piece of a toy—specifically a K'NEX set found in the basement. It sounds like a small detail, but it changes the entire narrative. A stun gun implies a calculated, high-tech predator. A toy part implies a much more domestic, accidental, or chaotic struggle.
The Ransom Note: Three Pages of Confusion
You can't talk about how was JonBenét Ramsey murdered without talking about that bizarre ransom note. It’s three pages long. That is unheard of in kidnapping cases. Most ransom notes are a single sentence: "We have your kid, give us the money."
This note was written on paper from a pad found inside the house, using a pen from the house. It demanded $118,000—the exact amount of John Ramsey’s recent work bonus.
Kinda specific, right?
💡 You might also like: The Texas Army National Guard Patch: Why That Little T-Patch Is So Iconic
The FBI’s former lead profiler, John Douglas, who was actually hired by the Ramseys, noted that the long-winded nature of the letter suggested someone "staging" a kidnapping. It felt like a movie script. It referenced "S.B.T.C" and claimed to be from a "small foreign faction." Linguists have spent decades analyzing the handwriting. While Patsy Ramsey was never "identified" as the writer, she was never fully "excluded" either, whereas John and other suspects were cleared of the handwriting much more definitively.
The DNA "Umbrella"
In 2008, District Attorney Mary Lacy took the unusual step of "clearing" the Ramsey family based on "touch DNA" found on JonBenét’s leggings and underwear. This DNA belonged to an unknown male, often referred to as "Unidentified Male 1."
Case closed? Not quite.
Many forensic experts, including those interviewed in more recent years by outlets like The Denver Post, argue that touch DNA is incredibly fickle. It can be transferred by laundry, by the person who packaged the clothing, or even by a factory worker who touched the garment before it was sold. Is it the killer's DNA? Maybe. Is it a "DNA ghost"? Also maybe.
In 2023 and 2024, renewed pressure from the Ramsey family and cold case advocates led to the Boulder Police partnering with the Colorado Bureau of Investigation to utilize new genetic genealogy techniques. This is the same tech that caught the Golden State Killer. We are currently waiting for those results to filter through the system.
The Most Common Misconceptions
People love to say "the doors were locked." They weren't. There was a broken window in the basement that John Ramsey admitted to breaking months earlier because he forgot his keys. There was also an unlocked door.
People also say "there were no footprints in the snow." Also not true. The ground was partially clear in several areas around the house due to the way the heat escaped the foundation.
- The Pineapple: There was undigested pineapple in JonBenét’s stomach. A bowl of pineapple was on the kitchen table with Burke Ramsey’s (her brother) fingerprints on it. Patsy and John claimed she didn't eat any pineapple before bed. This suggests she was awake and eating in the kitchen at a time when the parents said she was asleep.
- The 911 Call: Some claim you can hear whispering at the end of the 911 call after Patsy thought she hung up. Modern audio enhancement has yielded conflicting results—some hear "What did you do?" while others hear nothing but static.
Where the Case Stands Today
If you're looking for a simple answer to how was JonBenét Ramsey murdered, the medical reality is a blunt force trauma to the head followed by (or simultaneous with) ligature strangulation. The "why" and "who" remain the pieces of the puzzle that won't fit.
Was it an intruder who entered through the basement window, waited for the house to go quiet, and then botched a kidnapping? Or was it a tragic accident inside the home followed by a panicked, elaborate cover-up designed to look like a "foreign faction" did it?
The Boulder Police Department has faced massive criticism for how they handled the first 24 hours. They didn't cordone off the house. They let friends walk through the crime scene. They didn't separate John and Patsy for immediate, individual interviews. Because of those early mistakes, the "how" of this murder might be the only thing we ever truly know for sure.
Steps for Deeper Research
If you want to look past the tabloid headlines and see the evidence for yourself, there are a few specific places to go.
- Read the Autopsy Report: It is publicly available and provides the most objective look at the injuries without the filter of police or family bias.
- Study the Ransom Note: Look at the "Practice Note" found in the same pad. It shows that someone started writing the note, messed up, and then started over.
- Follow the Cold Case Review Team: The Boulder Police Department recently moved the evidence to a new lab for advanced DNA testing. Monitoring the official press releases from the City of Boulder is the only way to get facts rather than rumors.
The tragedy of the JonBenét Ramsey case isn't just the loss of a child, but the way the investigation became a circus that obscured the truth. Understanding the forensic "how" is the first step in stripping away the myths and looking at what actually happened in that basement.