You’ve probably seen the grainy night-vision footage. Some guy in a tight t-shirt is screaming at a shadow in a hallway, or a "ghost hunting" crew is losing their minds over a door creaking shut. It’s easy to roll your eyes at the TV dramatizations of Rolling Hills Asylum in Bethany New York, but the real history of this place is actually way heavier—and honestly, more interesting—than the jump scares suggest.
It wasn't always an asylum. Not in the way we think of them, anyway.
The building started its life in 1827 as the Genesee County Poor House. Back then, if you were poor, elderly, orphaned, or struggling with what they called "lunacy," you didn't have a safety net. You had the county farm. It was basically a catch-all for anyone the rest of society didn't know what to do with. You weren't just a resident; you were an "inmate." That’s the word they used in the ledgers. They expected you to work the 200-plus acres of farmland to earn your keep, assuming you were physically able to stand.
The Grim Reality of the Genesee County Poor House
Walking through those halls today, you can still feel that heavy, institutional weight. It's not just "spooky vibes." It's the physical remains of a system that treated poverty like a moral failing. Over 1,700 documented deaths happened on these grounds. Probably more, honestly, since record-keeping in the 19th century wasn't exactly what we’d call "high fidelity."
👉 See also: New Years Events North Carolina: The Weird, The Wild, and What Actually Matters
The property saw it all.
There was a school for the orphans. A infirmary for the sick. A morgue. A "psycho wing." Because it served so many different functions over its 150-year run, the energy of the building is fragmented. You go from a room that feels like a lonely old hotel to a basement that feels like, well, a place where people were sent to be forgotten.
Why the "Shadow People" are the Main Attraction
If you talk to the current owner, Sharon Coyle, or any of the long-time investigators who frequent the site, they’ll tell you about Roy. He’s the "star" of the show, if you want to call it that. Roy Crouse was a giant of a man, standing over seven feet tall due to gigantism. He lived at Rolling Hills for decades and eventually died there in the 1940s.
People claim to see his seven-foot shadow looming in the hallways of the second floor. It’s a specific kind of claim that pops up way too often to be a coincidence. Whether you believe in the paranormal or not, Roy was a real person. He was a son. He had a life. His story is one of the many that makes Rolling Hills Asylum in Bethany New York feel more like a memorial than a tourist trap.
Most people come for the scares, but they leave thinking about the people.
Scrutinizing the "Haunted" Claims
Let's get real for a second. Is it actually haunted?
Skeptics will tell you that the building is old. Incredibly old. It has shifting foundations, drafty windows, and a massive layout that creates natural echoes. If you're in a dark basement and a bird hits a window three floors up, your brain is going to tell you it was a ghost. That’s just how humans work. We’re wired to find patterns in the chaos.
But then you have the EVP (Electronic Voice Phenomena) recordings.
✨ Don't miss: Home2 Suites Johnson City TN: Why This Particular Spot Hits Different
Some of the audio pulled out of that building is genuinely hard to explain away as "wind." There are recordings of voices answering specific questions, calling out names, or telling people to get out. Investigators like the Ghost Hunters crew or the Ghost Adventures guys have all put this place through the ringer. They usually come away with something.
- The Second Floor: This is where the "Shadow People" are most commonly reported. It’s a long, straight corridor—perfect for visual tricks, but also the most unsettling part of the tour.
- The Morgue: It still has the original cooling lockers. It’s cold. It’s cramped. It’s exactly what you’d expect a 19th-century morgue to feel like.
- The Solarium: Once a place for patients to get "sun therapy," it now feels like one of the most active spots for light anomalies.
Life as an Inmate: More Than Just a Ghost Story
The history of the "Wood Chipper" incident is something people often get wrong or exaggerate. No, people weren't being tossed into wood chippers for fun. But the labor was hard. The conditions were often cold. If you were an orphan living there, you were surrounded by the dying and the mentally ill.
It was a chaotic environment.
By the time the 1950s rolled around, the facility transitioned into a nursing home called the Genesee County County Home. It stayed that way until 1974. After that, it went through various lives—an antique mall, a craft shop—before finally becoming the paranormal destination it is today.
The antique mall era is actually pretty funny to think about. Imagine browsing for vintage teacups while a shadow giant watches you from the hallway. Apparently, the vendors used to complain about items moving on their own or hearing footsteps when the building was empty. Eventually, the "haunted" reputation became more profitable than the antiques.
How to Actually Visit Rolling Hills Asylum
You can't just show up and start wandering around. The property is strictly monitored, and for good reason—it’s old, it’s potentially dangerous if you’re stupid, and it’s private property.
📖 Related: Germany In What Continent? Why the Answer Is More Than Just A Map
They offer a few different ways to experience the place:
- Historical Tours: If you don't care about ghosts and just want to see the architecture and learn about 1800s social services, do this. It’s fascinating.
- Public Ghost Hunts: These are usually 4-to-8-hour sessions. They provide some basic equipment, or you can bring your own. You’ll be in a group, so don't expect total silence.
- Private Investigations: This is for the hardcore folks. You rent the whole building for the night. It's expensive, but if you want to sit in the dark and wait for Roy to show up, this is the way to do it.
Rolling Hills Asylum in Bethany New York is located at 11001 Bethany Center Road. It’s about midway between Rochester and Buffalo. If you’re driving out there, expect backroads and plenty of farmland. It sets the mood before you even pull into the gravel lot.
Common Misconceptions and Legal Realities
Don't be the person who tries to break in. The local police don't find it "adventurous," and the owners have a zero-tolerance policy for trespassing. Also, despite what some sensationalist blogs say, this wasn't a "torture center."
Was there neglect? Probably.
Was the medical care primitive? Absolutely.
But it wasn't a movie set designed for suffering. It was a government-funded attempt to house the "unhouseable." The tragedy of Rolling Hills isn't that people were evil; it's that the system was inadequate. People died because of old age, pneumonia, and poverty. That’s a much more grounded, human kind of horror.
Expert Advice for Your Visit
If you’re planning a trip, bring a high-quality flashlight and wear closed-toe shoes. The floors are uneven. Also, bring a digital voice recorder—the kind reporters use. You don't need fancy "ghost gear" to capture audio.
Most importantly, be respectful.
Whether or not you believe in spirits, real people lived and died here. They weren't characters in a horror movie. They were residents of Genesee County who hit hard times. Approaching the building with a bit of empathy usually results in a much more meaningful experience than just running around trying to get scared.
Practical Steps for Your Trip
To make the most of a visit to this part of New York, you should plan ahead. The asylum is the main draw, but the surrounding area is peak Rust Belt/Rural New York.
- Book Months in Advance: The popular Saturday night slots fill up fast, especially around October. If you want a private hunt, you might need to look six months out.
- Check the Weather: The building is not climate-controlled. If it's 10 degrees outside, it’s 10 degrees inside. If it’s a humid New York summer, the air in the basement will be thick enough to chew.
- Read the Rules: They have very specific rules about "cleansing" the space or using Ouija boards (usually a big no-no). Follow them.
- Review Your Evidence: If you record audio, don't listen to it while you're there. Wait until you get home. Your brain needs distance to distinguish between a "ghostly whisper" and your friend’s stomach growling.
Rolling Hills remains one of the most significant historical and paranormal sites in the United States. It’s a preserved slice of a time we’d often rather forget, standing tall in the middle of a quiet New York town. Whether you're there for the history or the haunts, it’s a place that stays with you long after you leave the parking lot.