It’s the kind of story that feels like it was written in a Nashville writers' room, but the dirt and the sweat were very real. For decades, country music icon Toby Keith didn’t just sing about "Beer for My Horses"—il lived it. He was obsessed with the track. Pedigrees, bloodlines, the way a colt carries itself in the paddock; he knew it all. But for thirty years, one specific goal stayed just out of reach: having a horse run in the Kentucky Derby.
Most folks know Toby passed away in early 2024. What they might not know is that just one year later, his dream finally crossed the finish line at Churchill Downs. If you're looking for the quick answer to what place did toby keith horse come in, here it is: His horse, Render Judgment, finished in 17th place in the 2025 Kentucky Derby.
He didn't win. He wasn't even close to the front when they turned for home. But in the world of horse racing, sometimes just being in the gate is the victory.
The Long Shot That Made It: Render Judgment
Render Judgment was a bit of a "skin of the teeth" entry. Honestly, he almost didn't make the cut at all. Coming into the 151st Run for the Roses, the horse sat at 21st on the points leaderboard. In the Derby, only the top 20 get to run. It looked like another year of "almost" for the Keith family and Dream Walkin' Farms.
Then, the luck changed.
Another horse dropped out due to an injury, and Render Judgment was bumped up from the "also-eligible" list. He drew post position No. 15. The odds were long—30-1 on the morning line—and the pressure was high. Toby’s widow, Tricia Lucas, and his daughter Krystal were there to see it through. They knew this was exactly where Toby wanted to be.
🔗 Read more: Why Carlos Vives - Robarte un Beso HQ Audio Still Hits Different Today
Why 17th Place Felt Like a Win
You’ve gotta understand the scale here. There are roughly 20,000 thoroughbreds born every year. Only 20 make it to that starting gate on the first Saturday in May. To get there a year after the man who spent thirty years chasing it passed away? That’s some cinematic timing.
The race itself was a grind. Render Judgment, trained by the legendary Kenny McPeek, dealt with a quarter crack in his hoof leading up to the race. That’s basically like a runner trying to do a marathon with a split toenail. He fought hard, but the pace was blistering. By the time they hit the stretch, he just didn't have the gears to catch the leaders. He finished 17th out of 20.
Toby Keith’s Lifelong Obsession with the Track
Toby wasn't some celebrity who just threw money at a stable for the tax write-off. He was a "hands-on" owner. He founded Dream Walkin' Farms in Oklahoma and grew it into a massive operation with hundreds of horses.
He’d spend his nights on the tour bus—sometimes until 3 or 4 in the morning—scouring an iPad for bloodline data. He was a student of "nicks" (specific breeding crosses) and was deeply respected by old-school horsemen. His first horse, Jack Branch, won its very first race back in 1997. From that moment, Toby was hooked.
Over the years, he had some serious talent in his barn:
- Cactus Ridge: An undefeated two-year-old who was a favorite for the Breeders' Cup before an injury ended his career.
- Smack Smack: A Grade 3 winner and a personal favorite of Toby’s who earned nearly a million dollars.
- Three Chords: A homebred filly who dominated the Oklahoma Classics.
But the Derby? That was the white whale. He used to say that winning the Kentucky Derby was the one thing everyone in the business wanted to hang on their wall. He didn't care about the celebrity of it; he cared about the sport.
The Emotional Scene at Churchill Downs
When Render Judgment loaded into the gate in 2025, the jockey, Julien Leparoux, wasn't just wearing any silks. He was wearing Toby's colors. It was a tribute arranged by his partners and family.
Krystal Keith shared on social media how much it meant to the family. She mentioned that her dad probably had "the best seat in the house" watching from above. Even though the horse didn't hit the board, the fact that a Dream Walkin' Farms horse finally stood under the twin spires was the fulfillment of a thirty-year mission.
What’s Next for Dream Walkin' Farms?
The horse racing world moves fast. Even though Render Judgment didn't take home the roses, the stable is still very much active. Tricia and the rest of the family have continued the legacy Toby built.
If you're a fan of the sport or just a fan of Toby, keep an eye on the entries at Remington Park and Oaklawn. That’s where the heart of the operation lives. They’re still breeding, still racing, and still looking for that next "freak" like Cactus Ridge.
Next Steps for Fans and Bettors:
- Track the Stable: Check Equibase for "Dream Walkin' Farms" to see when their next runners are hitting the track.
- Visit the Home Turf: If you're ever in Oklahoma City, head to Remington Park. Toby was a fixture there, and you can still feel his influence in the paddock.
- Watch the Replays: Go back and look at the 151st Kentucky Derby. Watch the No. 15 horse. He might have come in 17th, but for a family honoring a late legend, it was a championship run.
The story of Toby Keith and his horses isn't really about what place they came in. It's about a guy who worked as hard at his "hobby" as he did at his music, and a family that made sure he finally got his invitation to the biggest party in sports.