What is the Best Thing for Sunburn? Why Your Go-To Remedy Might Be Making It Worse

You know that specific, sinking feeling. You’re in the shower after a long day at the lake, and suddenly, the lukewarm water feels like needles. Your shoulders are glowing a shade of neon pink that definitely wasn't there two hours ago. Now, you’re standing in the pharmacy aisle, staring at a wall of neon blue gels and smelling like a coconut-scented mistake. You’re desperately wondering, what is the best thing for sunburn?

Honestly, most people get this wrong. They reach for the "extra strength" lidocaine sprays or the heavy, oil-based creams that actually trap heat inside the skin like a thermal blanket. It’s counterintuitive.

A sunburn isn’t just "red skin." It’s a radiation burn. Specifically, it’s DNA damage caused by ultraviolet (UV) rays that triggers an inflammatory cascade. Your body is basically panicking. If you want to fix it—or at least stop the pulsing—you have to treat it like an inflammatory injury, not just a dry skin problem.

The Immediate Fix: Cool It Down, But Don't Freeze It

The absolute first thing you need to do is get the heat out. But here is the kicker: do not use ice. Putting ice directly on a sunburn can cause a secondary cold burn (cryodestruction) on top of the radiation burn. It's a mess.

Instead, use a cool compress. Not cold. Cool.

Dr. Debra Jaliman, a world-renowned dermatologist based in New York and author of Skin Rules, often suggests taking frequent, short, cool baths or showers. The moment you get out, pat yourself dry very gently. Leave a little bit of water on the skin. This is the "damp skin" trick. While your skin is still slightly wet, apply a moisturizer to trap that water in.

💡 You might also like: Can I overdose on vitamin d? The reality of supplement toxicity

But what moisturizer? This is where people trip up.

The Aloe Vera Myth vs. Reality

Everyone says aloe is the best thing for sunburn. It’s the gold standard, right? Sort of. Pure aloe vera—literally squeezed from the leaf—is incredible because it contains aloin, which has anti-inflammatory properties. However, if you buy that translucent green goo from a plastic bottle at the grocery store, check the ingredients. If "Alcohol Denat" or "Isopropyl Alcohol" is near the top of the list, put it back. Alcohol evaporates quickly, which feels cooling for five seconds but then dries out the skin and irritates the burn further.

If you can’t get a real plant, look for a brand like Seven Minerals or Amara Beauty that lists 99% pure aloe. If it’s bright neon green, it’s dyed. Real aloe is clear or slightly yellowish.

Stop the Internal Fire

While everyone focuses on what to rub on the skin, the real MVP of sunburn treatment is what you put in your body.

Inflammation is the enemy. According to the Skin Cancer Foundation, Non-Steroidal Anti-Inflammatory Drugs (NSAIDs) like ibuprofen (Advil, Motrin) or naproxen (Aleve) are game-changers if taken within the first few hours of realizing you’re burnt. They don't just dull the pain; they actually work to reduce the swelling and redness at a molecular level.

📖 Related: What Does DM Mean in a Cough Syrup: The Truth About Dextromethorphan

1. Hydrate like your life depends on it. A sunburn draws fluid to the skin's surface and away from the rest of your body. You aren't just burnt; you’re likely dehydrated. Drink water. Drink electrolytes. Skip the margarita—alcohol is a diuretic and will make the recovery twice as long.
2. Wear "stupid" clothes. This is not the time for skinny jeans or polyester. Wear the biggest, ugliest, most oversized 100% cotton T-shirt you own. You need airflow. Silk is also great if you’re feeling fancy.

What to Avoid (The "Never" List)

Sometimes the best thing for sunburn is actually knowing what to stay away from.

• Benzocaine and Lidocaine: These are tempting because they numb the pain. But many dermatologists warn that these can cause allergic reactions on sun-damaged skin, leading to a nasty rash on top of a burn.
• Petroleum Jelly: Don't put Vaseline on a fresh burn. It creates a waterproof seal. That sounds good, right? Wrong. It traps the heat against your skin. It’s like putting a lid on a pot of boiling water. Save the heavy ointments for the peeling stage, not the "hot to the touch" stage.
• Vinegar: I know, your grandma swears by a vinegar soak. While the acetic acid might help with itching later on, putting acid on a fresh radiation burn is a bold (and usually painful) move. Just don't.

The Mystery of the "Hell Itch"

If you’ve ever had a truly deep burn, you might encounter what the internet calls "Hell Itch" or Suicide Itch. It’s a deep, neurological itch that feels like fire ants are crawling under your skin. If this happens, your "best thing" isn't aloe—it's usually a combination of a high-dose antihistamine (like Benadryl) and a prescription-strength steroid cream. If you get to this point, stop reading blogs and call a doctor.

When the Peeling Starts

Once the heat dies down, you’ll likely start peeling. This is your body’s way of getting rid of damaged cells that could potentially become cancerous. It’s a defense mechanism.

Do not peel the skin. I know it’s satisfying. It’s tempting. But you are exposing "baby skin" that isn't ready for the world yet. This increases your risk of infection and permanent scarring or "mottling" (uneven pigment).

Instead, switch to a cream with ceramides or soy. Brands like CeraVe or Aveeno are great here because they help rebuild the skin barrier that the sun just nuked. If you see blisters, leave them alone. They are biological Band-Aids. If a blister pops on its own, clean it with mild soap and water and apply an antibiotic ointment like Bacitracin.

👉 See also: Creatine Explained: What Most People Get Wrong About the World's Most Popular Supplement

Beyond the Surface: Long-term Repair

Let’s be real: the damage is done. One blistering sunburn in childhood or adolescence more than doubles your chances of developing melanoma later in life.

After the pain stops, start loading up on antioxidants. Vitamin C and E can help stabilize the skin. Some studies suggest that taking a high dose of Vitamin D (under medical supervision) shortly after a burn can significantly reduce redness and inflammation, though the window for this is very short.

Is there a "Best" Product?

If you forced a dermatologist to pick one thing, they’d likely say a 1% hydrocortisone cream. It’s a low-dose topical steroid that tells your immune system to calm down. Apply it thinly to the worst areas. Just don't use it for more than a few days, as it can thin the skin over time.

Practical Next Steps for Recovery

To get through the next 48 hours without losing your mind, follow this rhythm:

• The 3-Hour Window: Take 400mg of ibuprofen (if your stomach and health status allow) and get into a cool, 10-minute bath.
• The Moisture Lock: While skin is damp, apply a soy-based or pure aloe moisturizer.
• The Hydration Goal: Drink 8 ounces of water every hour you’re awake for the first day.
• The Shadow Rule: Stay out of the sun entirely until the redness is gone. Your skin is currently compromised; even five minutes of "extra" sun will feel like a blowtorch.

If you start feeling feverish, nauseous, or get chills, you’ve moved past a "burn" and into sun poisoning (heat exhaustion). That’s an ER visit, not a pharmacy trip.

The best thing for sunburn is ultimately patience and a gentle touch. Your skin is an organ, and right now, it’s an injured one. Treat it like a wound, not an inconvenience. Wear your loose clothes, keep the lights low, and let the inflammation run its course while you support your body from the inside out. Next time? Buy the UPF 50+ shirt. It’s cheaper than the medical bills and a lot less painful than the "Hell Itch."