You’ve probably seen them on your social media feed. They have the perfect teeth, the private jet background, and a "proven system" that promises to fix your bank account, your gut health, or your failing marriage in exactly thirty days. They sound like experts. They look like winners. But under the hood, there is absolutely nothing there. This isn't just a modern influencer problem, though. The concept of a charlatan is as old as civilization itself, and honestly, we keep falling for the same tricks because human psychology hasn't changed much since the days of traveling medicine shows.
So, what is a charlatan?
In the simplest terms, a charlatan is someone who pretends to have knowledge or skills they don’t actually possess. They are professional pretenders. The word itself comes from the Italian ciarlatano, which likely grew out of ciarlare—to babble or chatter. That is the core of the grift: they talk so much and so fast that you don't notice the lack of substance. They aren't just "wrong." They are deceptive.
The Anatomy of a Modern Grift
Back in the 17th century, a charlatan would stand on a wooden crate in a town square selling "miracle" elastics or colored water. Today, the crate is a high-production YouTube ad. But the bones of the scam remain identical. A charlatan survives on three things: charisma, a desperate audience, and a total lack of verifiable evidence.
They thrive in "gray areas." Think about fields like nutrition, wealth coaching, or spiritual healing. These are areas where results are often subjective or take a long time to manifest. If a plumber says they fixed your leak and water is still spraying everywhere, you know they’re a fraud immediately. If a "wealth mindset coach" tells you that your lack of money is due to your "vibration," and you’re still broke six months later, they just tell you that you aren't vibrating high enough yet.
It’s a perfect loop.
Why We Fall For It
We aren't stupid. That’s the first thing you have to understand. Most people who get taken by a charlatan are actually quite intelligent; they are just in a state of high emotional need. When you are desperate—whether for health, love, or money—your brain’s "critical thinking" department takes a back seat to the "hope" department.
A charlatan is essentially a predator who hunts for that hope. They use specific linguistic triggers. They’ll use "we" to make you feel like part of an elite tribe. They use "they" to create a common enemy (Big Pharma, the "system," the 1%). By the time you realize the product is garbage, you've already integrated the charlatan’s worldview into your own identity.
✨ Don't miss: Am I Gay Buzzfeed Quizzes and the Quest for Identity Online
The Historical Hall of Fame
You can’t really understand what is a charlatan without looking at the greats. History is littered with people who managed to convince entire nations of their brilliance while holding a handful of nothing.
Take John R. Brinkley. In the 1920s, this man became one of the wealthiest people in America by claiming he could cure impotence by surgically implanting goat testicles into human men. It sounds insane now. It was insane then. But he owned a massive radio station, he spoke with authority, and he had thousands of "satisfied" customers (mostly due to the placebo effect and the fact that people were embarrassed to admit they’d been mutilated for no reason).
Then there is the case of Anna Anderson. She spent decades claiming she was the Grand Duchess Anastasia of Russia. She had the mannerisms. She had the stories. She convinced members of the royal diaspora. It wasn't until DNA testing became available long after her death that the world finally proved she was actually a Polish factory worker named Franziska Schanzkowska.
These aren't just "liars." A liar hides the truth. A charlatan builds a whole new reality and invites you to live in it with them.
Spotting the Red Flags
If you're worried that the person you're following or the "expert" you're about to hire might be a charlatan, you need to look past the aesthetics. They spend a lot of money on aesthetics. Instead, look for these specific behaviors that almost every professional fraudster exhibits.
1. The "Secret Knowledge" Trap
Real experts love to cite their sources. They want you to see the data. They want you to understand the why. A charlatan, however, will claim they have discovered a "secret" or a "hidden trick" that the mainstream media or the "establishment" is trying to suppress. If the knowledge is "exclusive" and only available for $997, be careful.
2. Constant Deflection
Try asking a charlatan a highly technical, specific question. A real scientist or professional will say, "I don’t know, let me look into that" or give you a nuanced, boring answer. A charlatan will pivot. They will turn the question back on you or use "word salad"—a string of high-level buzzwords that sound impressive but mean nothing—to confuse the listener into silence.
🔗 Read more: Easy recipes dinner for two: Why you are probably overcomplicating date night
3. The Lifestyle Sell
In the world of business and "success" coaching, the biggest red flag is when the product is the lifestyle. If a guy is selling a course on how to make money, but his only source of income is selling that course, you are looking at a classic charlatan loop.
4. Extreme Certainty
The world is messy. Science is slow. Real life is full of "maybes" and "it depends." Charlatans hate "it depends." They offer 100% guarantees. They promise "total transformation." In an uncertain world, that level of confidence is incredibly attractive, which is exactly why they use it as bait.
The Health Industry: A Charlatan’s Playground
Perhaps nowhere is the "what is a charlatan" question more vital than in the wellness space. People are literally betting their lives on these folks.
We see it with "detox" teas that are actually just laxatives. We see it with "energy healers" who claim they can shrink tumors with their thoughts. The danger here isn't just the money lost; it's the "opportunity cost." If someone spends six months trying to cure a serious illness with alkaline water and prayer because a charismatic charlatan told them to, they are losing the window of time where actual medicine could have saved them.
The Belle Gibson story is a haunting example. She was a massive Instagram influencer who claimed she cured her terminal brain cancer through diet and lifestyle. She sold books and apps. She was a hero to the wellness community. The problem? She never had cancer. She made the whole thing up to sell a brand.
How to Protect Yourself
Knowing what is a charlatan is only half the battle. You have to build a mental defense system.
- Check the Credentials: Don't just look for "Dr." in front of a name. Is it a PhD in the field they are talking about? Is the "university" a real accredited institution or a diploma mill in the Caribbean?
- Follow the Money: Who benefits from you believing this? If the person telling you that "all fruit is toxic" happens to sell a $150 supplement that replaces those nutrients, you have a conflict of interest.
- The Boring Test: Real experts are often kind of boring. They talk about incremental gains, hard work, and long-term studies. If someone makes a complex topic sound like an action movie, they are probably performing.
Actionable Steps for the Skeptical Mind
If you find yourself being pulled in by a charismatic figure, stop. Breathe. Do these three things before you hit "buy" or "subscribe."
💡 You might also like: How is gum made? The sticky truth about what you are actually chewing
First, search for their name plus the word "criticism" or "scam." Don't just read their own testimonials. Those are curated. Look for the people who left the program or the scientists who have debunked their specific claims.
Second, look for peer-reviewed evidence. If they claim a "breakthrough," there should be a paper on PubMed or a trial registered somewhere. If the only evidence is "personal testimony," it's not evidence; it's an anecdote.
Third, wait 24 hours. Charlatans rely on "urgency." They want you to act while your emotions are high. If you wait a day and the "miracle" seems a little less miraculous, your logic is finally kicking back in.
A Final Reality Check
The world will always have charlatans because we will always have desires that exceed our patience. We want the shortcut. We want the magic pill. We want the person who tells us everything is going to be okay without us having to do the actual, boring work.
A charlatan is simply a person who sells that shortcut. But the shortcut usually leads to a cliff. Stay curious, stay skeptical, and remember that if something feels too good to be true, it’s because it's a script.
Your Next Steps:
- Audit your feed: Unfollow one "expert" who provides zero citations for their wild claims.
- Verify one "fact": Take a piece of advice you’ve been following lately and look up the actual scientific consensus on it via a reputable source like the Mayo Clinic or a university database.
- Practice saying "I don't know": The more comfortable you are with uncertainty, the less likely you are to be seduced by someone who pretends to have all the answers.