You probably remember the commercials. Bright colors, happy people, and the promise that you could fix your teeth for a fraction of the cost of traditional braces—all without ever stepping foot in a dentist's office. It sounded like a dream. But for millions of people, that dream turned into a messy, expensive nightmare when the company suddenly blinked out of existence.
So, what happened to Smile Direct Club?
In December 2023, the teledentistry giant didn't just stumble; it collapsed. They shut down global operations effectively immediately, leaving patients with half-straightened teeth and a lot of questions. If you were one of those people, or if you're just curious how a company once valued at nearly $9 billion could go belly up so fast, here is the unfiltered story.
The Day the Smiling Stopped
On December 8, 2023, Smile Direct Club posted a notice on its website that felt like a slap in the face to its 2 million customers. They were done. No more aligners. No more customer support.
Even crazier? They told people who were mid-treatment that they still had to keep paying their monthly bills. Imagine being halfway through a 10-month plan, your teeth are currently in "transition," and the company providing the hardware just stops answering the phone. It’s wild.
The "Lifetime Smile Guarantee" that they used as a major selling point? Poof. Gone. Effective immediately. This wasn't a slow wind-down; it was a total blackout.
Why Smile Direct Club Actually Failed
People like to blame the economy, but the truth is way more complicated. It was a perfect storm of massive debt, aggressive lawsuits, and a business model that many experts say was fundamentally flawed from the jump.
A Mountain of Debt
When Smile Direct Club filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy in September 2023, they were carrying nearly $900 million in debt. That is a staggering number for a company that was supposed to be "disrupting" an industry. They tried to find a buyer or a partner to inject fresh cash, but nobody wanted to touch it. By December, the Chapter 11 (reorganization) turned into Chapter 7 (liquidation). Basically, they ran out of oxygen.
The War with "Big Orthodontics"
From day one, Smile Direct Club was at war. The American Association of Orthodontists (AAO) and various state dental boards weren't exactly fans of the "DIY" approach. They filed complaints in dozens of states, arguing that moving teeth without an in-person exam was dangerous.
Then there was the legal drama with Align Technology—the makers of Invisalign. They were originally partners, but the relationship soured into a series of ugly lawsuits over non-compete clauses and supply agreements. Just months before the final collapse, an arbitrator ordered Smile Direct Club to pay Align $63 million. When you’re already drowning in debt, a $63 million hit is a knockout punch.
👉 See also: Why a taxable brokerage account calculator is the only way to see your real returns
The NDA Controversy
This is the part that really rubbed people the wrong way. For years, there were whispers that the company was using aggressive non-disclosure agreements (NDAs) to keep unhappy customers quiet. If your teeth got messed up and you wanted a refund, you often had to sign a "shut up" clause.
In 2023, the District of Columbia’s attorney general actually sued them over this, and the company eventually had to release 17,000 customers from those NDAs. Once people were free to speak, the floodgates opened on social media with stories of cracked teeth, gum issues, and results that didn't look anything like the digital previews.
What Happened to Smile Direct Club Customers?
If you're currently staring at a purple box of aligners and wondering what to do, you aren't alone. The fallout has been chaotic.
- The Payment Trap: Most customers used "SmilePay." Even though the company is gone, the third-party lenders (like HFD) generally still expect payment. If you stop paying, it hits your credit score. It feels unfair, but legally, the loan is often separate from the service.
- The "New" Successor: A new company called SmileSet eventually acquired the technology and assets. They aren't the same company, and they won't honor your old guarantee, but they do have the records. They’ve been offering "discounts" to former SDC customers, which honestly feels a bit like being asked to pay twice for the same smile.
- Medical Limbo: Thousands of people were left mid-treatment. Since the company’s "doctors" were mostly remote, patients had no local office to visit. Local orthodontists are now seeing a surge of "rescue" cases—people who need braces or Invisalign just to fix what the mail-order kits started.
The Lesson Learned
Teledentistry isn't necessarily dead, but the "do it all yourself" era took a massive hit. Competitors like Byte have also faced struggles, showing that the high cost of customer acquisition and the lack of physical oversight is a tough nut to crack.
Honestly, the "disruption" of the dental industry turned out to be much harder than the founders anticipated. Moving bone through a human jaw is a medical procedure, not just a retail transaction.
✨ Don't miss: Why EcoShield Pest Solutions Norristown is the Local Choice for Smart Homeowners
What You Should Do Right Now
If you are a former customer still dealing with the aftermath, here are the actual steps you need to take.
- See a Local Pro: Stop wearing your aligners if they hurt or don't fit. Go to a local orthodontist for a "transfer" or "rescue" consultation. Many are offering free initial exams for former SDC patients because they know how bad the situation is.
- Check Your Debt Status: Contact HFD (Healthcare Finance Direct) if you're on a payment plan. Don't just stop paying without talking to them, or your credit will tank. If you never received your aligners, you have a much stronger case for a refund or cancellation.
- File a Claim: Keep an eye on the bankruptcy proceedings via the Kroll restructuring website. While the "General Bar Date" has passed, there are sometimes updates for consumers regarding residual assets, though—truthfully—don't expect a full refund.
- Download Your Records: If you can still access your portal or if SmileSet offers a way to retrieve your 3D scans, do it. Having your "before" data is helpful for any new dentist you see.
The era of cheap, mail-order braces might be closing, but your oral health is permanent. Don't let a bankrupt company be the reason you stop taking care of your teeth. Reach out to a local professional who actually has a physical office you can visit when things go wrong.