You’ve heard it. Probably used it. Maybe even whispered it to a cop or a spouse while looking for an exit strategy. What had happened was is the universal preamble for a story that’s about to get complicated. It’s the linguistic equivalent of a shrug and a smirk.
But it's not just a filler phrase. Honestly, it’s a masterclass in African American Vernacular English (AAVE) that has permeated global pop culture through decades of comedy, music, and social media. When someone starts a sentence this way, you know two things are true: the situation is messy, and the explanation is going to be creative.
Language evolves. Fast. What started as a specific dialectal nuance has turned into a digital shorthand for "I'm about to tell you a lie that we both know is a lie, but let's just go with it."
The Grammar of the "Double Past"
Most people think it’s just "bad grammar." They’re wrong.
In the world of linguistics, specifically when looking at AAVE, the construction of "what had happened was" serves a distinct purpose. It uses the past perfect tense to set a scene that is already in the past before the main story even begins. It creates a narrative buffer.
Basically, it signals that the speaker is distancing themselves from the immediate consequence. It’s a temporal shift. By saying "had happened," you’re pushing the event further back into history, making it feel less like a choice you just made and more like an act of fate that simply occurred.
Lisa Green, a prominent linguist and author of African American English: A Linguistic Introduction, has spent years breaking down these structures. She notes that these tense markers aren't accidental. They follow rigid internal rules. It's not "broken" English; it's a sophisticated system of aspect and tense that allows for nuance that Standard American English sometimes misses.
From Sitcoms to TikTok: The Cultural Journey
If we’re being real, the phrase exploded into the mainstream through Black comedy in the 80s and 90s. Think about the legendary routines of comedians like Bernie Mac or the character tropes in Martin and The Fresh Prince of Bel-Air.
It became a comedic beat.
A character walks in with a dented car.
"What happened?"
"See, what had happened was..."
✨ Don't miss: Green Emerald Day Massage: Why Your Body Actually Needs This Specific Therapy
The audience laughs immediately because they recognize the dodge. It’s the sound of someone thinking on their feet. This cultural footprint expanded significantly with the rise of Kevin Hart. Hart’s "What Had Happened Was" bit in his stand-up—specifically regarding his experiences with his father and his own brushes with the law—cemented the phrase as a cornerstone of modern storytelling.
Then came the internet.
In the era of Vine and early TikTok, the phrase became a soundbite. It was stripped of its specific narrative context and turned into a meme template. People started using it to describe everything from failed DIY projects to global political scandals. It’s a "vibe" now.
Why We Use It When We’re Guilty
There is a psychological component here.
When we are caught red-handed, the brain goes into overdrive. We need to bridge the gap between "I did something wrong" and "I am a good person." Using "what had happened was" buys us exactly 1.5 seconds of thinking time.
It’s a stalling tactic.
By the time you finish saying those four words, your brain has hopefully cooked up a plausible—or at least entertaining—excuse. It’s also a way to soften the blow. It invites the listener into the storytelling process. It’s disarming. It says, "Look, we’re both humans, and things got weird."
Sociologists often point out that this phrase acts as a "discourse marker." It frames the upcoming information as a narrative rather than a deposition. It’s less about the facts and more about the experience of the situation.
The Problem with "Mainstreaming" AAVE
We have to talk about the elephant in the room: cultural appropriation versus appreciation.
🔗 Read more: The Recipe Marble Pound Cake Secrets Professional Bakers Don't Usually Share
When a phrase like what had happened was goes viral, it often loses its connection to the community that created it. You see it in corporate marketing or on "relatable" brand Twitter accounts. Often, the people using it don't understand the linguistic history or the social weight of the dialect.
This leads to "Digital Blackface," a term popularized by scholars like Lauren Michele Jackson. It’s the idea that non-Black people use Black vernacular, memes, and slang to express exaggerated emotions or "coolness" without having to navigate the actual lived experience of Black people.
It’s a fine line.
Language is fluid, and people share phrases—that’s how English works. But there’s a difference between a natural adoption of a phrase and a caricatured performance of it. Using the phrase to mock someone’s intelligence or to sound "street" is where it gets problematic.
Real World Examples: When the Phrase Went Viral
Let's look at some actual moments where this phrase captured the zeitgeist.
- The 2016 Oscars: While not the exact phrase, the "envelope gate" with La La Land and Moonlight was essentially a giant "what had happened was" moment for the entire world. The immediate scramble for an explanation mirrored the chaotic energy the phrase represents.
- Viral Police Encounters: YouTube is littered with "Dashcam" or "Bodycam" footage where suspects lead with this exact line. There’s a specific brand of honesty in the blatant dishonesty of it.
- Kevin Hart’s "Laugh at My Pain": This is arguably the most influential modern usage. Hart’s ability to take the phrase and turn it into a rhythmic storytelling device influenced an entire generation of content creators.
The Nuance of "Was"
The "was" at the end is the cliffhanger.
It’s a linguistic "to be continued." It leaves the door wide open. In standard English, you might say "This is what happened." That’s a closed statement. It’s definitive. It’s a period.
But "What had happened was..." is a colon. It demands a follow-up. It forces the listener to lean in. You can’t just stop there.
That’s the magic of it. It’s collaborative storytelling.
💡 You might also like: Why the Man Black Hair Blue Eyes Combo is So Rare (and the Genetics Behind It)
Misconceptions and Accuracy
A common misconception is that this phrase is only used by people trying to lie. Actually, it's often used to describe genuinely confusing or multi-layered events.
If you try to explain why you were late to work because a tree fell on a power line which caused a traffic jam which led to you taking a detour that ended in a flat tire... you're probably going to start with what had happened was.
It’s for the "long story short" crowd who realizes the story isn't actually going to be short.
How to Navigate the Use of the Phrase
If you’re going to use it, understand the context.
- Read the Room: It’s a casual, often humorous phrase. Using it in a formal legal deposition or a high-stakes corporate board meeting might backfire unless you have the charisma to pull off the joke.
- Acknowledge the Origin: Know that this is a staple of AAVE. Respect the culture it comes from.
- Don't Overdo It: Like any slang or viral phrase, it loses its punch if used every five minutes.
We live in a world of "What had happened was." From politics to personal lives, the reality is rarely a straight line. We’re all just trying to explain the messiness of our lives to anyone who will listen.
The phrase gives us a way to own our chaos. It’s a verbal wink.
Practical Steps for Better Storytelling
If you find yourself reaching for this phrase, you're likely in the middle of a complex narrative. Here is how to handle that moment effectively:
- Pause Before the Pitch: When you say "what had happened was," use that exact moment to breathe. Don't rush the next sentence. The pause adds to the comedic or narrative effect.
- Focus on the Pivot: The best "what had happened was" stories have a clear turning point. Find the moment where things went off the rails and highlight it.
- Own the Absurdity: If the truth is weird, don't try to make it sound normal. The phrase is an invitation to the strange. Lean into it.
- Check Your Dialect Usage: If you are not a speaker of AAVE, be mindful of "linguistic tourism." Use the phrase because it fits the moment, not to try on a cultural identity that isn't yours.
The next time you hear someone lead with those four words, don't roll your eyes. Get comfortable. You’re about to hear something interesting. Whether it’s the truth, a lie, or something in between, it’s definitely going to be a story.