If you've been following the Buffalo Bills lately, or just keep a casual eye on NFL headlines, you probably saw the news drop like a lead weight: Von Miller, the future Hall of Famer and pass-rushing extraordinaire, was sidelined by the league. People immediately started scrambling for answers. It wasn't about a dirty hit or a training camp scuffle. This was different. Basically, the NFL handed down a four-game suspension to Miller in October 2024, and the roots of that decision reach back to a messy, high-stakes legal situation in Texas from late 2023.
So, what did Von Miller do to get suspended?
The short answer is a violation of the NFL’s Personal Conduct Policy. But that’s a corporate umbrella term that covers a lot of ground. In Miller’s case, it specifically connects to allegations of a domestic dispute involving his pregnant girlfriend. Even though the legal system didn't end up throwing the book at him with formal charges, the NFL operates in its own universe with its own set of rules.
The 2023 Dallas Incident: Where it All Started
To understand why the league stepped in, you have to look at what happened during the Bills' bye week in November 2023. According to police affidavits and multiple reports from the time, an argument broke out at an apartment in Dallas. Things got heated. Really heated.
The allegations were serious: Miller was accused of physically assaulting his longtime girlfriend, who was six weeks pregnant at the time. The police report detailed a harrowing scene where Miller allegedly pushed her, pulled her hair, and put his hands around her neck. Officers who arrived on the scene noted "minor abrasions" and bruising.
👉 See also: NFL Fantasy Pick Em: Why Most Fans Lose Money and How to Actually Win
He eventually turned himself in to the Glenn Heights Police Department on a warrant for third-degree felony assault of a pregnant woman. He was released on a $5,000 bond.
Honestly, the optics were terrible. For a guy who had built a reputation as the "soul" of a locker room and a massive community figure, seeing those details in a police affidavit was a shock to the system for fans.
Why the NFL Acted Without a Conviction
Here is the thing about the NFL. You don't actually have to be convicted of a crime to get suspended. Roger Goodell and the league office have the power to discipline players if they believe a player's conduct is "detrimental to the integrity of and public confidence in the NFL."
- The League's Investigation: The NFL usually conducts its own parallel investigation. They don't just wait for a jury.
- The Evidence Factor: Even if a victim chooses not to cooperate later—which reportedly happened here as she later called the incident "blown out of proportion"—the league can use police body cam footage, 911 calls, and initial statements.
- The Personal Conduct Policy: This policy is strict. It’s designed to protect the league's image. If the NFL’s internal investigators find "credible evidence" that an assault occurred, they can pull the trigger on a suspension.
Miller has been very vocal in his denial. He called the allegations "100 percent false." He’s maintained that while every couple has problems, he never did the things he was accused of doing. But by October 2024, the NFL decided they had seen enough to warrant a four-game absence without pay.
✨ Don't miss: Inter Miami vs Toronto: What Really Happened in Their Recent Clashes
A History of "Almost" Issues
This wasn't the first time Miller’s name popped up in a police report, which might have influenced how the league viewed the Dallas situation. Back in 2021, while he was still with the Denver Broncos, he was under investigation for another domestic matter in Parker, Colorado. That case was eventually closed without charges being filed.
Then there’s the 2013 suspension.
People often forget that early in his career, Miller sat out six games. That one was for violating the league’s substance-abuse policy. It wasn't a positive test, but rather an attempt to manipulate the testing process. He’s had a complicated relationship with league rules over his 14-year career.
The Fallout in Buffalo
The timing of the 2024 suspension was a gut punch for the Bills. Miller was finally looking like his old self again after a grueling recovery from an ACL tear. He had three sacks in the first four games of the season. He was the veteran presence on a defense that needed every bit of his pass-rush juice.
🔗 Read more: Matthew Berry Positional Rankings: Why They Still Run the Fantasy Industry
Instead of hunting quarterbacks, he spent a month away from the facility. The Bills had to pivot, leaning on younger guys like Greg Rousseau and A.J. Epenesa to pick up the slack.
What You Should Take Away
When you're trying to figure out what did Von Miller do to get suspended, it’s a classic case of the NFL’s "Judge, Jury, and Executioner" dynamic. The league doesn't need a "Guilty" verdict from a Texas judge to decide someone doesn't represent their brand.
If you’re a fan or someone trying to make sense of the NFL’s disciplinary logic, here are the core realities:
- Legal outcomes aren't NFL outcomes. A case being dropped by a DA doesn't mean the NFL investigation stops.
- Affidavits matter. The specific details in the Dallas police report—the hair pulling and the choking allegations—are the kinds of "aggravating factors" that lead to multi-game suspensions under the current policy.
- The Pregnant Victim Clause: The league takes allegations involving pregnant women or children extremely seriously. It’s often an automatic escalation in terms of punishment length.
Miller is back on the field now, but his legacy definitely has a permanent asterisk next to it. Whether you believe his "blown out of proportion" defense or the details in the police report, the league made its stance clear. They felt he crossed a line that required more than just a fine.
Moving forward, keep an eye on how the Bills handle his contract. With a huge price tag and these off-field headaches, his future in Buffalo beyond this season is anything but a lock. If you're tracking his career, watch the "conduct" section as closely as the sack totals—because at this stage of his career, the league isn't going to give him many more chances.
Actionable Insight: If you're following NFL news, always distinguish between "Legal Charges" and "NFL Discipline." To stay ahead of these stories, check the NFL Personal Conduct Policy updates, as the league often adjusts suspension lengths based on public pressure and new CBA (Collective Bargaining Agreement) negotiations. For those looking at the Bills' roster impact, watch the snap counts of backup edge rushers; their performance during Miller's absence often dictates how much the team is willing to tolerate off-field drama in the future.