You've probably seen the movies. Nicolas Cage hunting for Templar gold or some shadowy group in floor-length robes deciding the fate of the world over candlelight. It's great cinema. But when people ask what are the masonic secrets, they’re usually looking for something far more scandalous than the reality. Honestly, the biggest secret about Freemasonry is that it isn’t really a secret society at all. It’s a "society with secrets."
There's a difference.
If you walk down any main street in a decent-sized American town, you’ll see the Square and Compasses on a building. It's right there. They have websites. They post on Facebook about their pancake breakfasts. Yet, the mystique persists because of the "modes of recognition." That's the fancy way Masons describe the grips and passwords.
Most people think the secrets involve world domination or lizard people. They don't. The real secrets—the ones they actually protect—are surprisingly mundane to an outsider but deeply symbolic to the guy wearing the apron.
The Secret Handshakes and Why They Matter
Let’s get the big one out of the way. Yes, there are secret handshakes. They call them "grips."
Each degree in Masonry—Entered Apprentice, Fellowcraft, and Master Mason—has its own specific grip and word. If you’re a Master Mason, you’re taught the "Grand Master’s Grip" or the "Lion’s Paw." Why? Back in the day, stone masons were actual laborers. They traveled from cathedral to cathedral looking for work. Since there weren't LinkedIn profiles in the 14th century, you needed a way to prove your skill level.
If you showed up at a job site in York and claimed to be a Master, the foreman would shake your hand. If you didn't know where to put your thumb, you weren't getting paid Master’s wages.
Today, it’s mostly just tradition. It’s a way for one Mason to recognize another in the dark or in a crowded room. Is it "secret"? Kinda. You can find them all on Wikipedia in five seconds. But to a Mason, the secret isn't the physical act of the handshake; it's the fact that you’ve been vetted by your peers to know it. It’s a badge of trust.
📖 Related: Hairstyles for women over 50 with round faces: What your stylist isn't telling you
The "Hoodwink" and the Rituals of the Blue Lodge
If you’ve ever gone through an initiation, you know it’s supposed to be a bit jarring. In Masonry, the candidate is often "hoodwinked" (blindfolded) and led into the lodge room with a cable-tow (a rope) around their neck.
It looks terrifying in grainy 1920s photos.
But the symbolism is what matters here. The hoodwink represents the candidate being in "darkness" regarding the teachings of the craft. When the blindfold is removed, they are said to be brought to "light." It’s a theatrical metaphor for education and self-improvement.
- The Cable-Tow: Represents the bond to the fraternity.
- The Apron: A symbol of innocence and the "badge of a Mason."
- The Tools: They take actual builder’s tools—like the plumb, the level, and the square—and turn them into moral lessons.
Basically, they use the level to teach that all men are equal. They use the square to teach them to "square their actions" with all mankind. It's essentially a very elaborate, very old-fashioned self-help club.
The Penalty of the Obligation: Gore or Metaphor?
This is where the conspiracy theorists usually lose their minds. In the older rituals, a candidate would swear an oath (an obligation) and agree that if they ever revealed what are the masonic secrets, they would have their throat cut across or their heart plucked out.
Sounds pretty metal, right?
In reality, no one is getting their heart plucked out in the basement of a Masonic temple. These are "traditional penalties." Even back in the 1700s, these were understood as symbolic. It was a way of saying, "I’d rather die than be a man who breaks his word."
👉 See also: How to Sign Someone Up for Scientology: What Actually Happens and What You Need to Know
In 1986, the United Grand Lodge of England—the "Mother Lodge" of the world—actually moved to make these penalties optional or purely metaphorical because they were scaring people off. Most modern lodges have softened the language significantly. The "secret" here is that Masons value their word above almost anything else. The ritual is designed to make that promise feel heavy and permanent.
What About the "Great Architect"?
You’ll often hear that Masons worship a weird god called the "Great Architect of the Universe" or "GAOTU."
This isn't a secret deity. It’s a neutral term.
To join, you have to believe in a Supreme Being. It doesn't matter if you're Christian, Jewish, Muslim, or Sikh. Because a lodge might have members of all those faiths, they use the term "Great Architect" so everyone can pray together without arguing over specific theology. They aren't hiding a secret god; they're trying to avoid a holy war during the business meeting where they discuss who’s buying the coffee and donuts.
Why the Secrecy Exists at All
If you can find all the secrets online, why do they bother keeping them?
It’s about the experience. Think of it like a movie spoiler. If I tell you the ending of The Sixth Sense, the movie still exists, but your experience of watching it is ruined.
Freemasonry is an "experiential" society. The rituals are designed to be a surprise to the candidate to create a psychological impact. When a group of men all go through the same "secret" ceremony, it creates a bond. You’ve all been through the same weird, slightly embarrassing, very solemn night. That shared experience is the actual "secret" of the brotherhood.
✨ Don't miss: Wire brush for cleaning: What most people get wrong about choosing the right bristles
Margaret Jacob, a historian who has written extensively on the Enlightenment, notes that these secret societies were actually the birthplaces of modern democracy. They were places where a baker and a Duke could sit at the same table and vote on things. In the 1700s, that was the dangerous secret. The idea that people could govern themselves without a King or a Pope telling them what to do.
Misconceptions That Just Won't Die
We have to talk about the Leo Taxil hoax. In the late 1800s, a guy named Leo Taxil started writing books claiming Masons worshipped Baphomet and did all sorts of wild stuff. He eventually admitted he made it all up to mock the Catholic Church for being so gullible, but the damage was done.
Most of the "secrets" you see on YouTube today are just leftovers from the Taxil hoax or 1920s anti-Masonic propaganda.
The real "secrets" are boring. They’re minutes from meetings in 1954. They’re lists of who owes dues. They're instructions on how to properly perform a funeral service for a fallen brother.
Actionable Insights for the Curious
If you’re genuinely interested in the "secrets," don't look for them in Dan Brown novels. Start with real history.
- Visit a Local Lodge: Most lodges have "Open Houses." You can literally walk in, look at the room, and ask the guys questions. They’ll usually give you a tour and show you the chairs where the officers sit.
- Read "Freemasons for Dummies": Honestly. It was written by Christopher Hodapp, a high-ranking Mason. It’s widely considered one of the most accurate and transparent looks at the organization.
- Check the Grand Lodge Records: Most state Grand Lodges have libraries open to the public. You can read the history of every lodge in your state.
- Understand the "Secret" is Internal: The real secret of Masonry is the change that happens inside the person. It sounds cheesy, but it’s the truth. The rituals are supposed to make you think about your mortality and how you treat your neighbors. You can't "reveal" that secret because it's a personal feeling, not a password.
The allure of the unknown is powerful. We want there to be a secret room with a golden map. But in the case of Freemasonry, the "secret" is just a group of people trying to be slightly better versions of themselves through 300-year-old plays and some weird handshakes. It’s less National Treasure and more Dead Poets Society for grown-ups.
If you’re looking to join or just want to understand your grandfather's ring, realize that the mystery is part of the fun, but the reality is much more human. It's about community, charity, and keeping a tradition alive in a world that’s becoming increasingly digital and disconnected. That, in itself, is a secret worth keeping.
Stop looking for the treasure map. Start looking at the philosophy. The "secrets" are all hiding in plain sight in the symbols they wear on their lapels every day. Just ask one. They’ll probably talk your ear off about it.
To explore the historical impact of these groups further, you can look into the works of historians like Dr. Brent Morris or the archives of the George Washington Masonic National Memorial. They hold the actual documents that strip away the fantasy and reveal the real, albeit less "magical," history of the craft.