He was a man of profound sorrow and even deeper silences. When we think of Abraham Lincoln, we usually picture the stovepipe hat, the Gettysburg Address, or the tired eyes of a president carrying a fractured nation on his shoulders. But if you dig into the letters, the early biographies by William Herndon, and the oral histories from New Salem, you find a recurring theme: Abraham Lincoln on mothers wasn’t just a sentimental topic for a greeting card. It was a messy, painful, and foundational part of who he was. Honestly, his relationship with the women he called "mother" is probably the most human thing about him.
He had two of them. One gave him life; the other gave him a reason to live.
Most people know the famous quote attributed to him: "All that I am, or hope to be, I owe to my angel mother." It’s everywhere. You’ve seen it on Pinterest, on Mother's Day cards, and in high school history textbooks. But there is a massive debate among historians about which mother he was actually talking about—or if he even said it exactly that way. Lincoln was complicated. He was a man who lived through the "milk sickness" that killed his biological mother and the crushing poverty of a frontier childhood that his stepmother helped him escape.
The Biological Reality: Nancy Hanks Lincoln
Nancy Hanks Lincoln is a ghost in the American narrative. We don't have a single photograph of her. No drawings made from life exist. She died in 1818 when Abe was only nine years old. Imagine a nine-year-old boy in the middle of the Indiana woods, watching his mother succumb to "milk sickness"—a horrific poisoning caused by drinking milk from cows that had eaten the white snakeroot plant. It wasn't a peaceful passing. It was agonizing.
Lincoln’s biological mother was reportedly a woman of "superior instincts" and a "keen mind," according to neighbors. She was illiterate, yet she possessed a spiritual depth that clearly rubbed off on her son. When she died, Abraham helped his father, Thomas, carve the wooden pegs for her coffin. He buried her on a knoll near their cabin. That kind of trauma doesn't just go away; it stays in the marrow. It’s why Lincoln’s melancholy—what they called "hypochondriasis" back then—was so pervasive.
He rarely spoke of Nancy in public. Why would he? In the 19th century, men didn't exactly sit around discussing their childhood trauma. But when we look at Abraham Lincoln on mothers, we have to recognize that Nancy was the source of his physical being and his initial spark of curiosity. She was the one who first told him stories in the dark of a log cabin.
👉 See also: Why People That Died on Their Birthday Are More Common Than You Think
The Woman Who Saved Him: Sarah Bush Johnston
A year after Nancy died, Thomas Lincoln went back to Kentucky and married Sarah Bush Johnston. She was a widow with three kids of her own. She arrived at the Lincoln cabin with a wagon full of furniture—a bureau, a table, chairs—and, most importantly, books.
Sarah was the "angel" many historians believe he was referring to. She saw something in Abraham that his father didn't. Thomas Lincoln thought Abe was lazy because the boy preferred reading to chopping wood. Sarah, however, recognized that his "laziness" was actually intellectual hunger. She protected his time. She made sure he had space to study by the fire.
Sarah once said of him, "Abe was a good boy... He was the best boy I ever saw." He loved her back with a fierce, quiet loyalty. He didn't call her "stepmother" in a cold, clinical way. She was "mother" to him for the rest of his life. Even when he was a successful lawyer in Springfield, he went back to visit her. Even when he was headed to Washington D.C. to be inaugurated as the 16th President, he made a detour to Coles County to say goodbye to her. He knew he might never see her again. He was right.
That "Angel Mother" Quote: Fact or Fiction?
We have to be careful here. As a content creator who values accuracy, it’s important to point out that the "Angel Mother" quote primarily comes to us via William Herndon, Lincoln’s law partner. Herndon was a bit of a dramatist. He claimed Lincoln told him this while they were traveling on the legal circuit in the 1850s.
Some scholars, like Joshua Wolf Shenk, author of Lincoln's Melancholy, suggest that the "angel mother" was Nancy, because she was literally in heaven—an angel. Others argue it was Sarah, because she was his living guardian angel.
✨ Don't miss: Marie Kondo The Life Changing Magic of Tidying Up: What Most People Get Wrong
The nuance matters. Lincoln’s view on mothers wasn't about a Hallmark moment. It was about survival. He understood that a mother's influence was the difference between a life of backbreaking, illiterate labor and a life of the mind. He saw his mother as the gatekeeper of his destiny.
The Complicated Relationship with Mary Todd Lincoln
You can't talk about Abraham Lincoln on mothers without looking at the mother of his own children. Mary Todd Lincoln is often villainized. People call her "crazy" or "difficult." But she was a mother who lost three of her four sons before they reached adulthood. That kind of grief is unspeakable.
Lincoln watched Mary struggle with the duties of motherhood while under the microscope of the White House. He was often a detached father because of the Civil War, but his empathy for her suffering was profound. He saw in Mary the same kind of fragile strength he remembered in Nancy. When their son Willie died in the White House in 1862, the Lincolns were bonded by a shared, agonizing parenthood that most people today couldn't survive.
Why This Matters for Us Today
So, what’s the takeaway? Why are we still talking about a man's feelings toward his mothers 160 years later?
Because Lincoln’s life proves that where you come from isn't nearly as important as who nurtures you. He was a "scrub" from the backwoods. He had no pedigree. But he had the influence of two women who, in their own ways, signaled to him that he was worth more than the dirt he was farming.
🔗 Read more: Why Transparent Plus Size Models Are Changing How We Actually Shop
Lincoln’s perspective on motherhood was rooted in the idea of debt. He felt he owed his existence and his success to these women. In a world that often ignores the "quiet work" of raising children, Lincoln’s elevation of his mothers is a radical act of gratitude.
Key Insights from Lincoln's Experience
- Grief is a teacher. Lincoln's early loss of Nancy Hanks created a depth of character and empathy that allowed him to lead a nation through its own "death" and rebirth.
- Chosen family is real. Sarah Bush Johnston proves that the biological bond isn't the only one that defines a "mother." Her impact on history—simply by letting a boy read—is immeasurable.
- Acknowledge the influence. Lincoln didn't become a "self-made man" in a vacuum. He was made by the books Sarah brought and the stories Nancy told.
Actionable Steps for Exploring Lincoln’s Legacy
If you want to truly understand the man behind the myth, don't just look at his speeches. Look at the people who shaped his heart.
- Visit the Lincoln Boyhood National Memorial in Indiana. You can stand near the spot where Nancy Hanks Lincoln is buried. It’s a somber, quiet place that puts his early life into perspective.
- Read "Lincoln" by David Herbert Donald. It is widely considered the gold-standard biography and handles his relationship with his stepmother with great care and historical rigor.
- Examine the correspondence. Look up the letters Lincoln wrote to his stepmother later in life. They are short, but they show a man who never forgot his roots, even when he was the most powerful person in the country.
- Support local literacy. If you want to honor the spirit of Sarah Bush Johnston, donate books to children in rural or underserved areas. She changed the world with a few volumes in a wagon; you can do the same.
The story of Abraham Lincoln on mothers is ultimately a story about the power of belief. One mother gave him his soul, the other gave him his tools. Without both, the United States might look very different today.
Next Steps for Deepening Your Knowledge
To further your understanding of the Lincoln family dynamic, research the "Lincoln-Herndon" letters. These documents provide the most direct, albeit sometimes biased, look into his private thoughts. Additionally, visiting the Lincoln Home National Historic Site in Springfield, Illinois, offers a physical look at how he and Mary raised their boys, bridging the gap between his childhood as a son and his adulthood as a father. This context makes his eventual presidency feel less like a series of political moves and more like the culmination of a deeply personal journey.