You’ve probably seen the footage. It looks like a grainy filter from a horror movie, but it's terrifyingly real. On December 9, 2019, a group of tourists was walking right inside the crater of New Zealand’s most active cone volcano. Then, it happened. A phreatic eruption—basically a massive, pressurized explosion of steam and rock—blasted through the crater floor. No warning. No lava. Just a wall of searing, acidic debris. Whakaari White Island changed forever that day, and honestly, the way we look at adventure tourism changed with it.
Whakaari isn't your typical mountain. It’s actually the summit of a massive submarine volcano, with about 70% of its bulk sitting underwater. Imagine a giant iceberg, but instead of ice, it’s a venting, hissing pressure cooker of sulfur and boiling mud. It sits about 48 kilometers off the coast of Whakatāne in the Bay of Plenty. For decades, it was a bucket-list destination. You’d hop on a boat or a helicopter, put on a gas mask, and walk around a landscape that felt like another planet. It was beautiful. It was also a ticking time bomb.
The Science of Why It Blew
Scientists at GNS Science had been monitoring the island for years. They use something called the Volcanic Alert Level (VAL). In the weeks leading up to the 2019 disaster, the level had been raised to 2. That sounds high, right? But on a scale of 0 to 5, Level 2 basically just means "moderate to heightened volcanic unrest." It happens all the time there. In fact, Whakaari has been in a near-constant state of unrest since the late 70s.
The problem with phreatic eruptions is that they are notoriously hard to predict. Unlike magmatic eruptions, where molten rock moving toward the surface shakes the ground and gives off distinct gas signals, phreatic events are hydrothermal. Water gets trapped in the rock, heats up instantly, and turns into steam. Think of it like a pressure cooker with a blocked valve. One minute everything is fine; the next, the "lid" blows off. When that happened in 2019, the surge was moving at speeds that made escape impossible.
Geologist Geoff Kilgour and his team have spent years analyzing the data from that day. The reality is that the hydrothermal system at Whakaari is incredibly shallow and sensitive. Even minor changes in the sealing of the vents can lead to a massive buildup of pressure. This isn't a volcano you can ever truly "tame."
A History Painted in Sulfur
People have been obsessed with this island for a long time. The name Whakaari roughly translates from Māori as "to make visible." Captain Cook named it White Island in 1769, likely because of the constant plume of white steam rising from it. But the island has a dark history that predates the recent tragedy.
Back in the early 1900s, there was a sulfur mining operation on the island. Sulfur is great for fertilizer, and companies thought they could make a fortune. In 1914, a massive debris flow (basically a volcanic landslide) wiped out the entire mining camp. Everyone died. Well, everyone except the camp cat, Peter the Great. You’d think that would have been the end of it. But people went back. They kept mining until the 1930s. Eventually, the economic reality of working on a literal volcano set in, and the miners left, leaving behind rusted machinery and crumbling stone walls that look like ancient ruins.
By the 1980s and 90s, the island had shifted from industry to tourism. It was a private scenic reserve. Tours became a staple of the New Zealand "100% Pure" experience. It was "adventure" in its purest form. But the line between adventure and negligence is often thinner than we'd like to admit.
The Legal Fallout and the "Safety" Myth
The 2019 eruption killed 22 people and left dozens more with life-altering burns. The aftermath wasn't just about grief; it was about accountability. New Zealand's workplace safety regulator, WorkSafe, ended up filing charges against 13 parties. This included tour operators, the owners of the island (the Buttle family), and even the scientific agency GNS Science.
The court cases pulled back the curtain on how risk was communicated. Or, more accurately, how it wasn't.
- Tourists were often told the volcano was "active" but weren't necessarily briefed on what a Level 2 alert actually meant for their survival.
- The proximity to the vents was a huge selling point, but it was also the greatest danger.
- Evacuation plans were basically "run to the boat," which doesn't work when the air turns into a 200°C cloud of acidic ash.
In 2023, the owners of the island, Whakaari Management Ltd, were found guilty of health and safety failings. The judge noted that they didn't do enough to assess the risk. It’s a landmark case for the global tourism industry. It asks a hard question: Can you ever truly offer a "safe" tour of an active volcano? Probably not.
What It's Like on the Island Now
You can't go there anymore. At least, not on foot. The island is currently closed to landings, and it’s likely to stay that way for a long time. The Māori iwi (tribe), Ngāti Awa, who hold mana whenua (guardianship) over the area, have placed a rāhui (temporary ritual prohibition) on the island. It’s a place of mourning and a place that needs to heal.
🔗 Read more: Christmas in the Park San Jose: What Most People Get Wrong About This Bay Area Tradition
If you take a scenic flight over the island today, it looks peaceful from 5,000 feet. You can see the yellow sulfur deposits, the vibrant green of the acidic crater lake, and the steam gently drifting toward the horizon. But look closer. The landscape is scarred. The old mining ruins are further buried. The boat jetty is gone. The sensors used by volcanologists are often caked in ash or destroyed, making remote monitoring a constant battle.
Understanding the Geology of the Bay of Plenty
Whakaari is just one part of the Taupō Volcanic Zone. This is one of the most active volcanic areas on Earth. It stretches from Mount Ruapehu in the center of the North Island all the way out into the Pacific. The reason New Zealand has so many hot springs, geysers, and volcanoes is that the Pacific Plate is sliding under the Australian Plate. It's a geological meat grinder.
This subduction zone creates magma that rises up through the crust. At Whakaari, that magma stays relatively close to the surface, heating up the groundwater. This creates a "hydrothermal envelope." It’s basically a layer of superheated water and gas that sits right under the crater floor. This is why the island is so green and yellow—the chemical reactions are intense. It’s also why the island is so loud. It’s not a quiet place. It roars.
Is It Worth the Risk?
This is where things get personal. Some people argue that we should be allowed to take risks. We climb Everest. We skydive. Why not walk on a volcano? The difference, as the court cases highlighted, is informed consent. Most people who stepped onto Whakaari White Island on that December morning thought they were going on a controlled, professional tour. They didn't realize they were stepping into a game of geological Russian roulette.
If you’re planning a trip to New Zealand, you can still experience the volcanic power of the region without the same level of risk.
- Rotorua: This is the heart of the geothermal action. You've got Te Puia, where the Pōhutu geyser erupts regularly. It’s monitored, it’s safe, and you still get that "earth is alive" feeling.
- Mount Tarawera: This volcano erupted in 1886, destroying the famous Pink and White Terraces. Today, you can take a guided tour to the summit. It’s dormant, so the risk of a sudden steam explosion is exponentially lower.
- Scenic Flights: Honestly, this is the best way to see Whakaari now. You get the scale of the volcano and the beauty of the Bay of Plenty without having to breathe in sulfur or worry about the ground under your feet exploding.
Lessons for the Future
The story of Whakaari isn't over. It’s a lesson in humility. We like to think we can predict nature, that we can quantify risk into neat little levels from 1 to 5. But the Earth doesn't care about our scales. Whakaari is a reminder that some places are meant to be respected from a distance.
The legal precedents being set in New Zealand right now will likely change how adventure tourism works in Iceland, Italy, and Japan. It's moving toward a model of "radical transparency." If you're going somewhere dangerous, the operator needs to tell you—in plain English—exactly how you might die. It sounds grim, but it’s the only way to avoid another December 9th.
✨ Don't miss: Flights from Hong Kong to LAX: What Most People Get Wrong
Actionable Insights for Travelers:
- Check the VAL: If you are visiting any volcanic site (like Tongariro or Yellowstone), always check the official monitoring site (like GeoNet in NZ). If the level is anything above 1, ask serious questions about the safety protocols.
- Understand Your Insurance: Most standard travel insurance policies have "high-risk activity" exclusions. Many victims of the 2019 eruption had to crowdfund for medical costs because their insurance didn't cover "acts of God" or volcanic eruptions.
- Respect Local Rahui: If an area is closed for cultural or safety reasons by local indigenous groups, respect it. These closures are often based on centuries of observation that Western science is only just catching up to.
- Support the Community: The town of Whakatāne was devastated by the tragedy. If you're in the area, visit the local shops and museums. They have incredible exhibits on the island’s history that provide context you won't get from a headline.
Whakaari is still venting. It’s still growing. It’s still one of the most fascinating places on the planet. But for now, the best way to appreciate its power is from the safety of the mainland, looking out over the water at that persistent plume of white steam on the horizon. It’s a beautiful sight, as long as you know what’s happening underneath.