Football in the Big 12 is a chaotic mess of geography and strange rivalries. Honestly, if you look at the map, West Virginia and Kansas State shouldn't be natural enemies. One is tucked into the Appalachian Mountains; the other sits in the middle of the Flint Hills. Yet, every time these two meet, it feels like a physical therapy session gone wrong. Specifically for West Virginia.
If you're a Mountaineer fan, the West Virginia vs Kansas State football matchup has become a recurring nightmare that usually ends with a purple-clad quarterback running wild in Morgantown or Manhattan. It’s not just that K-State wins. It’s how they do it. They out-muscle, out-discipline, and essentially out-Big-12 the Mountaineers.
The 2024 Disaster and the Avery Johnson Era
Let’s talk about what happened in October 2024 because it perfectly encapsulates the frustration in Morgantown.
West Virginia entered that game with high hopes. It was Homecoming. Milan Puskar Stadium was packed with 54,327 fans screaming their lungs out. The Mountaineers actually out-gained the Wildcats on the ground, 152 to 114 yards. Usually, in Neal Brown’s system, if you win the rushing battle, you win the game.
Not this time.
Avery Johnson, the Wildcats' young signal-caller, basically shredded the WVU secondary like it was a high school JV unit. He threw for 298 yards and three touchdowns. He didn't even need to run that much, which is usually his bread and butter. K-State walked out of West Virginia with a 45-18 victory.
✨ Don't miss: The Division 2 National Championship Game: How Ferris State Just Redrew the Record Books
The turning point was brutal. Garrett Greene, the heart and soul of the Mountaineers, went down with an injury in the second half. Watching backup Nicco Marchiol try to navigate a 17th-ranked K-State defense was like watching a guy try to solve a Rubik's cube while being chased by a lawnmower. It just wasn't going to happen.
Why the Series History Favors the Wildcats
When West Virginia first joined the Big 12 in 2012, they famously welcomed K-State to the league by getting absolutely hammered 55-14. Since then, the series has been a see-saw, but K-State has held the upper hand in the most physical stretches.
Historically, Kansas State leads the series slightly, but the recent trend is the real story. Since Chris Klieman took over for the legendary Bill Snyder, the Wildcats have maintained that "blue-collar" identity that seems to give West Virginia fits.
- Discipline: In that 2024 game, WVU had several opportunities to keep it close, but a failure on 4th downs (1-of-6) killed them.
- The Turnover Margin: Marques Sigle’s 43-yard pick-six in the second quarter of the 2024 matchup was the definitive "game over" moment.
- Situational Football: K-State converted 7-of-12 third downs. WVU? Just 5-of-17.
Basically, K-State plays "clean" football. West Virginia under Neal Brown has often been "almost" there. You've seen it—the drives that stall at the 35-yard line, the missed tackles on third-and-long. Against a team like Kansas State, those mistakes are magnified ten times over.
The Quarterback Duel: Greene vs. Johnson
Looking at the West Virginia vs Kansas State football rivalry through the lens of the quarterbacks tells the whole story.
🔗 Read more: Por qué los partidos de Primera B de Chile son más entretenidos que la división de honor
Garrett Greene is a warrior. He’s the type of player who will put his shoulder down and try to run through a linebacker just to get an extra yard. In the 2024 game, he had 89 rushing yards before leaving the game. But he struggled through the air, completing only 9-of-19 passes.
Compare that to Avery Johnson. Johnson represents the "new" K-State. He has the speed of a track star but the poise of a fifth-year senior. While Greene was fighting for his life on every snap, Johnson was finding Jadon Jackson for 60-yard bombs.
Key Stats from the 2024 Matchup
| Statistic | Kansas State | West Virginia |
|---|---|---|
| Final Score | 45 | 18 |
| Passing Yards | 298 | 143 |
| Rushing Yards | 114 | 152 |
| Turnovers | 0 | 2 |
| Time of Possession | 25:38 | 34:22 |
Look at that time of possession. West Virginia had the ball for nearly 10 minutes longer than K-State! Yet they lost by 27 points. That is almost impossible to do unless you are giving up massive plays and turning the ball over in your own territory.
The Coaching Contrast: Klieman vs. Brown
There is a lot of talk among Big 12 experts about the "ceiling" of these two programs. Chris Klieman has a ring. He took K-State to a Big 12 Championship and won it. He’s built a machine that reloads rather than rebuilds. Whether it’s DJ Giddens at running back or a rotating cast of offensive linemen, the "K-State Way" remains the same.
Neal Brown, on the other hand, has been on the hot seat more times than a Thanksgiving turkey. While he’s stabilized the program and made them a bowl-eligible team consistently, the Mountaineers still struggle to win the "big" games against the top tier of the conference.
💡 You might also like: South Carolina women's basketball schedule: What Most People Get Wrong
Winning at West Virginia is hard. The travel is brutal. But K-State seems to handle the trip to Morgantown better than almost anyone else in the conference. They don't get intimidated by the "Country Roads" atmosphere. They just show up, hit you in the mouth, and leave.
What to Watch for in the Next Matchup
If you're betting on the next chapter of this rivalry, keep an eye on the trenches. West Virginia’s offensive line is usually their strength, but K-State’s defensive front—led by guys like Desmond Purnell—has a knack for timing blitzes that negate WVU’s power run game.
Also, watch the health of the QBs. West Virginia is a completely different team when they have a dual-threat starter who is 100% healthy. When they are forced to go to the bench, the talent gap between these two rosters becomes very apparent.
Actionable Insights for Fans and Analysts
- Check the 4th Down Stats: If WVU is going for it on 4th down early, it means they don't trust their defense to stop Avery Johnson. That's usually a bad sign for the Mountaineers.
- Monitor Injuries: Specifically in the secondary. West Virginia’s biggest weakness has been the deep ball, and K-State has shifted from a "run-first" team to a "strike-fast" team under Avery Johnson.
- Home Field Doesn't Matter: Don't assume Morgantown provides a massive edge here. K-State has won three of the last four meetings in West Virginia.
The reality of West Virginia vs Kansas State football is that it has become a barometer for the Big 12. If you can beat K-State, you’re a contender. If you can't, you’re just middle-of-the-pack. Right now, the Mountaineers are still trying to figure out how to climb that mountain.
To get the most out of the next game, look at the turnover margin in the first quarter. In this specific matchup, the team that strikes first usually forces the other into uncomfortable passing situations. For West Virginia to flip the script, they have to force Avery Johnson to play "small ball" and keep their own defense off the field.
Next Steps:
- Track the Big 12 injury reports for the upcoming season, particularly regarding the quarterback rooms in both Manhattan and Morgantown.
- Compare the recruiting rankings for defensive backs in the portal for WVU, as this remains their primary hurdle in stopping the K-State offense.
- Analyze the home/away splits for Chris Klieman’s teams to see if their road dominance in the Eastern time zone continues.