You can’t really talk about college football in the mountains without talking about the guys under center. It’s a different breed of pressure in Morgantown. Honestly, if you've ever stood in the lot at Milan Puskar Stadium three hours before kickoff, you know. The expectations aren’t just about winning; they’re about a specific kind of "it" factor.
For decades, the west virginia quarterback history has been a wild ride of dual-threat pioneers and Air Raid gunslingers. It’s not just a list of names. It’s a lineage. From the leather-helmet days to the high-octane schemes of the 2020s, the signal-caller for the Old Gold and Blue carries the weight of an entire state on his shoulders.
🔗 Read more: Super Bowl Start Time CST: What Most People Get Wrong
Some fans will argue until they’re blue in the face about who the "GOAT" is. Is it the raw, unbridled speed of Pat White? Or maybe the surgical precision of Geno Smith? You’ve got the old-school grit of Jeff Hostetler and the playground magic of Major Harris. Every era brings a new flavor, but the DNA remains the same: tough, slightly overlooked, and ready to ruin a top-five team's season on a random Thursday night.
The Pioneers and the Nehlen Revolution
Before the spread offense became the gospel in Morgantown, things were a bit more traditional. But even then, West Virginia was finding gems.
Fred Wyant back in the mid-50s was the first real "star" of the modern era, leading the Mountaineers to three straight Top 20 finishes and a Sugar Bowl berth. People forget how good those teams were. Then came the Don Nehlen era in 1980, which basically changed everything. Nehlen didn't just win games; he recruited the kind of athletes that made big-city schools nervous.
Oliver Luck and the Birth of the Modern Era
Before he was an executive or "Andrew Luck's dad," Oliver Luck was the prototype. He wasn't just a smart player—though he was brilliant—he was the engine that restarted WVU football. Luck threw for nearly 6,000 yards at a time when teams still loved the cloud of dust. He set the foundation.
Jeff Hostetler: The Transfer that Changed History
You can't write about this program without mentioning "Hoss." After transferring from Penn State (which still feels good to mention for WVU fans), Hostetler walked into Norman, Oklahoma in 1982 and absolutely dismantled the Sooners. 321 yards and four touchdowns later, the nation realized something was happening in West Virginia. He ended his college career with an 18-6 record before going on to win two Super Bowls with the Giants. He was the pro-style peak of the 80s.
When "The Run" Defined a Generation
If you ask a Mountaineer fan of a certain age about 1988, they’ll probably start smiling and then maybe get a little misty-eyed. That was the year of Major Harris.
Major Harris wasn't just a quarterback; he was a human highlight reel. He was a "dual-threat" before that was even a common term. The play everyone remembers—the one "forever embedded in the memories," as the record books say—is the 26-yard touchdown run against Penn State.
The play clock was winding down. Major forgot the play. The entire offense went left; Major went right. He faked out roughly seven Nittany Lions, leaving them grabbing at thin air. It was pure, unadulterated instinct. Harris finished his career as the first player in NCAA history to pass for over 5,000 yards and rush for over 2,000. He wasn't just good; he was a cultural phenomenon. He even got write-in votes for the West Virginia gubernatorial election.
The Pat White Era: Four Years of Perfection
Then came the mid-2000s. If Major Harris laid the groundwork, Pat White built the skyscraper.
Rich Rodriguez’s spread option was the most terrifying thing in college football for a four-year stretch, and Pat White was the reason why. He didn't just play; he dominated. White is still the only quarterback in NCAA history to start and win four consecutive bowl games. Think about that. The consistency required to do that is staggering.
He was a nightmare for defensive coordinators. You’d key on Steve Slaton, and Pat would keep it and go 60 yards. You’d key on Pat, and he’d dump it to Owen Schmitt or Darius Reynaud. By the time he left, he had 4,480 rushing yards—a record for QBs at the time—and 103 total touchdowns. The 2006 Sugar Bowl win over Georgia and the 2008 Fiesta Bowl demolition of Oklahoma are the crown jewels of the west virginia quarterback history.
The Air Raid and the Stat-Stuffers
When Dana Holgorsen arrived, the ground-and-pound (or run-and-run) era died. It was time to fly.
📖 Related: Aaron Hernandez: The Truth Behind the NFL’s Most Tragic Downfall
Geno Smith took the keys to the Ferrari and didn't look back. The numbers he put up were honestly offensive.
- 11,662 career passing yards.
- 98 passing touchdowns.
- A 70-33 Orange Bowl win where he accounted for seven touchdowns.
Geno's performance against Baylor in 2012 remains one of the most absurd things ever seen on a football field. 45 completions. 656 yards. Eight touchdowns. No interceptions. It looked like a video game on the "Rookie" setting.
Will Grier: The Last Great Gunslinger?
After a few transition years, Will Grier showed up and reminded everyone why Morgantown is a great place for QBs. Grier had that "swagger." The 2018 game against Texas—where he ran in the two-point conversion and gave the "horns down" to the crowd—is legendary. Grier threw for 71 touchdowns in just two seasons. He had that rare ability to make a 50-yard back-shoulder throw look like he was just playing catch in the backyard.
The Modern Scramble: Garrett Greene and Beyond
Lately, the program has leaned back into that dual-threat identity with Garrett Greene. It’s a bit of a throwback to the Pat White days, albeit in a different system. Greene represents the "blue-collar" vibe that fans love—he’s a "run through your face" kind of runner rather than a "make you miss" guy like Major Harris.
In 2024, Greene put up solid numbers, throwing for 2,300 yards and rushing for hundreds more. He's the bridge to the next era. As the Big 12 evolves, the WVU quarterback remains the most important piece of the puzzle.
✨ Don't miss: Why the Question of What Number is Allen Iverson Still Matters to Fans
What Really Matters in Mountaineer History
Looking back, the "best" quarterback isn't just about who has the most yards. If it were, Geno Smith wins by a mile. If it’s about wins, Pat White is the king. If it’s about pure impact on the program's soul, it’s probably Major Harris or Jeff Hostetler.
The reality is that West Virginia has been incredibly spoiled at this position. Most programs would kill for one "legendary" QB every twenty years. WVU has had a legitimate star in almost every decade since the 50s.
Actionable Insights for Fans and Historians
If you want to truly appreciate the depth of this history, don't just look at the box scores.
- Watch the 1988 Penn State highlights. You need to see Major Harris move to understand how ahead of his time he was.
- Dive into the 2006 Sugar Bowl. It was the moment the world realized the spread option wasn't a gimmick.
- Compare the eras. The transition from Nehlen's toughness to Rodriguez's speed to Holgorsen's volume is a masterclass in how college football evolved.
- Keep an eye on the portal. Modern west virginia quarterback history is increasingly written by transfers like Grier and Hostetler, making the recruiting trail more complex than ever.
The next great Mountaineer quarterback is out there somewhere, probably being told he's too small or his arm isn't quite "elite" enough. That’s usually how the best ones start out in Morgantown anyway.