West Virginia fans still feel that Frisco chill. Honestly, if you were watching the West Virginia Mountaineers football vs Memphis Tigers football matchup in December 2024, you know it wasn't just a bowl game. It was a chaotic, high-scoring fever dream that redefined how these two programs view each other.
Most people think of West Virginia as the big-conference bully. They see Memphis as the "Group of Five" underdog. That's the first mistake. Memphis hasn't played like an underdog in years, and their 42-37 victory over the Mountaineers proved that the gap between the Big 12 and the AAC isn't a chasm. It's a crack.
The Frisco Bowl Chaos You Forgot
Let’s talk about that night in Texas. It was the first time these two schools ever met on a football field. First time! You'd think there would be some "feeling out" period.
Nope.
Memphis quarterback Seth Henigan came out like a man possessed. He was playing his final game as a four-year starter, and he looked every bit the veteran. He threw for 294 yards and two touchdowns, tying the American Athletic Conference career record with 104 touchdown passes. He was basically a surgeon out there.
West Virginia, led by interim coach Chad Scott at the time, struggled early. They fell behind 17-0. You could almost hear the collective groan from Morgantown through the TV screen. But then, the Mountaineers did what they always do: they got weird and explosive.
A Tale of Two Halves
Garrett Greene didn't just give up. He started ripping off runs that looked like video game glitches, including a massive 56-yard touchdown sprint that put some life back into the WVU sideline.
- Total Yards: WVU actually outgained Memphis 534 to 474.
- The Difference: Turnovers and situational defense.
- The MVP: Henigan took the offensive honors, but Chandler Martin was the real story for Memphis with 17 tackles.
It was a game of "what ifs." What if WVU hadn't missed that fourth-down conversion early? What if the interception by Elijah Herring in the final seconds hadn't happened? The Mountaineers scored on six consecutive possessions. Six! And they still lost. That tells you everything about how lethal that Memphis offense was.
📖 Related: Heisman Trophy Nominees 2024: The Year the System Almost Broke
Why This Matchup Still Matters in 2026
You’re probably wondering why we’re still talking about a bowl game from 2024.
The answer is simple: identity.
West Virginia spent the 2025 season trying to find its footing under a shifting coaching landscape. They went 5-7, struggling with consistency in the Big 12. Meanwhile, Memphis continued their upward trajectory. They’ve become a model of what a modern college football program should look like—efficient, high-scoring, and aggressive in the transfer portal.
When you look at West Virginia Mountaineers football vs Memphis Tigers football, you aren't just looking at two teams. You're looking at the shifting power dynamics of the sport. West Virginia is trying to reclaim its status as a top-tier national brand. Memphis is trying to prove they belong in the expanded playoff conversation every single year.
The Style Clash
WVU plays a brand of football that feels like a brawl. It’s physical. It’s gritty. It’s "Country Roads" and coal dust.
Memphis is different. They play fast. They want to out-pace you. Ryan Silverfield has built a culture where "finding a way" is the only thing that matters. They’ve now had 40+ consecutive games scoring 20 points or more. That is a level of offensive reliability that most Power Four teams would kill for.
Recruitment and the Portal War
The real battle between these two isn't just on the field anymore. It’s in the living rooms of recruits in the South and the Mid-Atlantic.
👉 See also: When Was the MLS Founded? The Chaotic Truth About American Soccer's Rebirth
West Virginia has traditionally recruited the Florida-to-Pennsylvania corridor. Memphis has tightened its grip on the talent-rich Tennessee and Mississippi areas. However, the transfer portal has blurred those lines. We’re seeing more players choose a "winning" AAC program like Memphis over a "struggling" Big 12 program like WVU.
That's a bitter pill for Mountaineer fans to swallow.
What Most People Get Wrong
The biggest misconception is that Memphis won because WVU was "unmotivated" or "didn't want to be there."
Stop it.
That’s the lazy excuse every big-name school uses when they lose a bowl game to a perceived lesser opponent. WVU fought like hell. They put up over 500 yards of offense. They had the ball with a chance to win at the end. They lost because Memphis was better in the red zone and more disciplined on third down.
Also, people underestimate the coaching stability. Silverfield has been the rock for Memphis. West Virginia has been through the wringer with coaching changes and identity crises. Stability wins games. Period.
Looking Toward the Future
As we head deeper into the 2026 season, the ripples of that 2024 matchup are still felt. WVU is looking for that signature win to prove the program is back on track. Memphis is looking to keep its seat at the big table.
✨ Don't miss: Navy Notre Dame Football: Why This Rivalry Still Hits Different
If these two meet again—and given the bowl tie-ins, it's likely—don't expect a defensive struggle.
Expect fireworks.
What You Should Do Next
If you’re a fan or a bettor looking at these two programs, keep your eyes on these specific metrics:
- Red Zone Efficiency: Memphis consistently ranks higher here, which is why they win the close ones.
- Turnover Margin: WVU’s aggressive style often leads to mistakes that teams like Memphis capitalize on.
- Third-Down Conversion Rates: This was the quiet killer in their last meeting.
Watch the schedule for future non-conference pairings. While there isn't an annual "rivalry," the tension between these two fan bases is real.
Go back and watch the 2024 Frisco Bowl highlights. Look at the way Memphis attacked the WVU secondary. Then, look at how WVU’s run game dominated the middle of the field. This is the blueprint for their next encounter.
The Mountaineers need to find a way to stop the "death by a thousand cuts" passing attack. The Tigers need to find a way to handle the raw physicality of a Big 12 line. Until then, Memphis holds the crown.