West Ham vs. Nottingham Forest: What Most People Get Wrong

The London Stadium felt like a pressure cooker on January 6, 2026. You could literally smell the anxiety in the damp air as fans watched the latest chapter of West Ham vs. Nottingham Forest unfold. It wasn't just a game; it was a survivalist’s fever dream.

Honestly, if you missed the reverse fixture back in August where West Ham cruised to a 3-0 win at the City Ground, you’d think these two teams were from different planets. Football is funny like that. One minute Jarrod Bowen is clinical, the next, the Hammers are ten games without a win and staring at the trapdoor.

That Tuesday night was weird. Basically, it was a tale of two VAR decisions and a goalkeeper having a total nightmare.

The Relegation Battle Nobody Wanted

When Nuno Espirito Santo took over West Ham just four months ago, people thought the "new manager bounce" would be a trampoline. Instead, it’s been more of a sinkhole.

The irony? Nuno was facing the very Forest side that sacked him earlier in the 2025/26 season. Talk about a grudge match. Forest, now under Sean Dyche, arrived in East London looking like a team that actually knew how to suffer together.

The game started with a fluke. In the 13th minute, Crysencio Summerville whipped in a corner and Murillo, poor guy, diverted it into his own net. The stadium erupted. For a second, it felt like the old West Ham was back.

But hope is a dangerous thing in a relegation scrap.

Why the Second Half Changed Everything

If you want to understand why West Ham vs. Nottingham Forest has become such a stressful fixture for the locals, look no further than the 52nd minute. Summerville thought he’d doubled the lead with a peach of a strike. The celebrations were massive.

Then came the "silent killer"—the VAR check.

New signing Valentin "Taty" Castellanos, making his debut after arriving from Lazio, was ruled offside by what looked like the thickness of a shoelace. It was a marginal call that sucked the life out of the ground.

Three minutes later? Equalizer.

Elliot Anderson, who has been a revelation for Forest this term, swung in a corner and Nicolas Dominguez rose like he had springs in his boots. His looping header floated over Alphonse Areola and suddenly, the mood shifted from "we're safe" to "here we go again."

The Moment Alphonse Areola Lost His Cool

Let’s talk about the penalty. It’s been the main talking point on every radio phone-in from Stratford to the Trent.

In the 89th minute, a cross came in that Areola really should have claimed or cleared. Instead, he misjudged the flight and basically punched Morgan Gibbs-White right in the face. It looked painful.

Referee Tony Harrington didn't see it at first, but after a quick trip to the VAR monitor, there was no doubt. Gibbs-White, looking a bit dazed, later told Sky Sports he "didn't have a clue what was going on" until he heard the whistle.

📖 Related: Why the 2010 KC Chiefs Roster Still Holds Up as a Total Fluke (and Why We Loved It)

He didn't miss.

Straight down the middle. Cold as ice. That goal put seven points between Forest and the drop zone, while West Ham dropped to the brink of the bottom three.

Breaking Down the History

People forget how deep this rivalry goes. Before these modern Premier League scraps, they were trading blows in the Championship and the old First Division.

• Total Meetings: 124 matches.
• The Split: 49 wins for West Ham, 49 wins for Forest, and 26 draws.
• Recent Trend: Forest has actually won three of the last four meetings in the league.

That "49-49" stat is wild. It shows how little there usually is between these two clubs, even when they aren't fighting for their lives. Historically, home advantage was everything—before 2025, you had to go back to 2012 to find the last time an away team won this fixture. Now? Forest has won at the London Stadium two seasons in a row.

What's Next for the Hammers and the Tricky Trees?

Nuno is under massive pressure. You've got fans leaving early, and the stats don't lie: two wins in sixteen games is sackable form in anyone's book. The "Hammers Chat" circles are already calling for another change before the FA Cup third-round tie against QPR.

For Forest, the "Dyche-ball" era is working. They aren't pretty. They use a low block. They frustrate you. But they win the games that matter.

If you're looking at the remaining fixtures, Forest has a much clearer path to safety. They travel to Tottenham next, which is tough, but the momentum is firmly in their camp. West Ham, meanwhile, looks like a team that has forgotten how to close out a game.

Keep an eye on the injury report for the next few weeks. If Paqueta’s fitness continues to wobble and Castellanos doesn't start finding the net quickly, West Ham's 200th Premier League start for Jarrod Bowen might end in a season they’d rather forget.

Watch the highlights of the Gibbs-White penalty again—pay attention to the defensive positioning of Jean-Clair Todibo before the cross came in. It’s those small lapses in concentration that are currently separating these two historic clubs in the table.

Check the updated Premier League standings after the Burnley vs. Manchester United result to see exactly how thin the ice is for the East London side heading into the spring.