You’re staring at your screen. It’s 11:30 PM on a Tuesday. You’ve got three different tabs open with "expert" advice, yet you still don't know if you should trust Trey Benson to save your season or if Caleb Williams is actually a starter now.
Fantasy football is a cruel mistress. Honestly, by the time we hit Week 4, the "draft day" vibes have evaporated. You’re either 3-0 and feeling like a genius or 0-3 and ready to delete the app. But here’s the thing: Week 4 is where the real season starts. The noise of Week 1 is gone. Patterns are actually forming.
The Chaos of Week 4 Fantasy Rankings
Everyone is overreacting. That’s the problem.
People see Tre Tucker drop 40 points and suddenly think he’s the next Randy Moss. He isn't. But you also can’t ignore eight catches and three touchdowns. It’s a tightrope. This week, the week 4 fantasy rankings are being dictated by a massive wave of injuries that have essentially nuked the top of the draft board.
The RB Dead Zone is Real
If you drafted James Conner or Najee Harris, I’m sorry. Truly. Both are officially out for the year, and that leaves a massive hole in thousands of lineups.
Trey Benson is the name on everyone’s lips. The Cardinals rookie finally has the keys to the car. Is he a top-12 play? Probably not quite yet because Emari Demercado is going to annoyingly steal third-down snaps, but Benson is a volume king in the making. He looked explosive against the Lions, and now he gets a Seattle defense that is—let’s be real—a bit of a "bend but don't break" unit.
🔗 Read more: New Orleans Pelicans Dallas Mavericks: Why This Matchup Still Matters in 2026
Then there’s the Omarion Hampton situation in New York. The Giants are a mess, but Hampton is the only thing moving the chains. If you’re ranking him outside the top 20, you’re playing it too safe. Volume is a hell of a drug in fantasy.
Wide Receiver Gridlock
CeeDee Lamb being out changes everything for Dallas. You might think Dak Prescott is a "sit," but where else are those targets going? Jalen Tolbert and KaVontae Turpin are basically the last men standing.
If you’re looking at the top of the board, Justin Jefferson remains the gold standard even with Carson Wentz under center. It’s wild to say, but Wentz is actually feeding him. 75 yards on one play last week? Yeah, he's fine.
- Amon-Ra St. Brown: Still a PPR god. Lions vs. Browns is going to be a slugfest, but Goff lives in the short-to-intermediate range.
- Ja'Marr Chase: Finally showed signs of life. The Denver matchup is tough with Pat Surtain II looming, but you don't bench Chase. Ever.
- Malik Nabers: He’s dealing with a shoulder thing, but he’s playing. The kid is a target monster.
Why Most Rankings Are Wrong About Quarterbacks
Most people look at the jersey, not the matchup.
Jordan Love is the prime example this week. He hasn't been a top-12 guy yet this year, but look at who he’s playing. The Cowboys defense is hemorrhaging points to QBs. They gave up nearly 30 to a rookie last week. Love is going into a dome, with a healthy roster, against a zone-heavy scheme he can carve up. He’s my "hill to die on" for Week 4.
On the flip side, Kyler Murray is a trap. People see the rushing floor and think he’s safe. But Seattle’s pass rush is ranked fourth in pressure rate. Kyler hates pressure. If he’s running for his life, he’s not throwing TDs. I’d actually rank Drake Maye—the Patriots' new savior—ahead of him this week. Maye is playing his hometown team (Carolina) and their defense is... well, it's the Panthers.
📖 Related: Bill Simmons and The Book of Basketball: Why It Still Rules the Sports Debate
The Tight End Wasteland
Is Mark Andrews back? Sorta. Two touchdowns last week felt like 2022 again. But Isaiah Likely is making his season debut against the Chiefs. That’s going to complicate things. If you have Hunter Henry, you’re probably starting him. Drake Maye clearly loves him in the red zone, and in this economy, "four targets inside the ten" is basically a TE1 ceiling.
Matchups You Need to Exploit
Vikings at Steelers (in Dublin)
This is the "Jet Lag Bowl." The Vikings are playing international games back-to-back. Historically, weird things happen in these games. Jordan Mason has been a revelation for Minnesota, but the Steelers' front seven is no joke. I’m leaning towards sitting most secondary options here and sticking to the studs.
Bears at Raiders
Caleb Williams finally had the breakout we’ve been waiting for. 298 yards and four scores. Was it just because it was Dallas? Maybe. But the Raiders' secondary isn't exactly the '85 Bears. Luther Burden III is becoming a legitimate threat, and if you need a flex, he’s the guy.
Falcons vs. Commanders
Washington is a committee nightmare. Chris Rodriguez gets the carries, but Jeremy McNichols gets the "wow" plays. Honestly? I’m staying away from this backfield until one guy actually takes 60% of the snaps. Marcus Mariota is a sneaky start if Jayden Daniels remains out, though. His rushing floor is legit.
Actionable Steps for Your Roster
Stop holding onto "draft capital." If a guy hasn't produced in three weeks and his snaps are trending down, he’s a clog.
- Check the Waiver Wire for Elic Ayomanor. The Titans rookie is outperforming Calvin Ridley. That’s not a fluke; it’s a changing of the guard.
- Sell High on Tre Tucker. If someone in your league thinks he’s a weekly WR2 after that 40-point explosion, let them have him. His target share is too volatile.
- Prioritize Trey Benson. Even if you have to trade a mid-tier WR for him, do it. Lead backs are disappearing faster than my paycheck on rent day.
- Watch the Baker Mayfield Injury. His biceps issue is real. If he’s limited, it’s a huge downgrade for Chris Godwin and Sterling Shepard.
The week 4 fantasy rankings aren't just a list of names. They’re a snapshot of a league that’s currently in survival mode. Trust the volume, ignore the jersey names from three years ago, and don't be afraid to bench a "star" if the matchup is a nightmare.
Get your lineups set before the Thursday night game. Nothing ruins a weekend like leaving a breakout performance on your bench because you forgot to check the injury report.