Fantasy football is basically a high-stakes exercise in overreacting. We spend six months ranking guys based on spreadsheets and "vibes," then Week 1 happens, and we want to set our entire roster on fire. It’s wild. But honestly, week 2 start em sit em decisions are where seasons are actually won or lost because this is the moment you have to decide if a bad performance was a fluke or a structural disaster.
If your first-round pick put up a dud, you're probably staring at your lineup right now feeling like a total failure. Stop it. One week is a tiny sample size. You've got to look at the usage—the snaps, the targets, the "almost" plays—rather than just the box score.
The Running Back Dead Zone and Week 2 Logic
Look at the backfield in Cincinnati or what's happening with the committee in Chicago. If you're looking for a week 2 start em sit em hero, you have to find the volume. Zack Moss out-snapped Chase Brown significantly in the opener, which tells us the Bengals trust the veteran more in pass protection right now. Does that mean Brown is "dead"? No. But it means for Week 2, you're starting Moss if you need a safe floor.
Then there’s the Jordan Mason situation in San Francisco. With Christian McCaffrey dealing with that nagging Achilles tendinitis, Mason isn't just a "sit em" candidate turned "start em"—he’s a potential league-winner for as long as CMC is sidelined. If you have Mason, you play him. You don't overthink the matchup against Minnesota. The Niners' scheme is so good that a talented one-cut runner like Mason is going to produce regardless of the defensive front.
✨ Don't miss: SEC Sports Football Schedule: What Most People Get Wrong About the 2026 Chaos
On the flip side, what do we do with the "Sit Em" candidates? D’Andre Swift had a rough go behind that Bears offensive line. Caleb Williams looked like a rookie, which he is, and the rushing lanes just weren't there. If you have a viable alternative—maybe a guy like J.K. Dobbins who looked explosive for the Chargers—you might actually consider benching your higher-drafted asset. Dobbins showed he still has the burst, and Jim Harbaugh wants to run the ball until the opponent's spirit breaks.
Wide Receiver Volatility: Who to Trust
Target share is king.
If a receiver got 10 targets but only caught three of them for 40 yards, that’s actually a great sign for week 2 start em sit em outlooks. The production will follow the volume. Look at someone like Malik Nabers in New York. The Giants' offense might be a train wreck, but Daniel Jones is going to force-feed Nabers because he doesn't have many other options he trusts. He’s a "start" even in a bad matchup because 10+ targets are hard to find on the waiver wire.
- Start: Rashee Rice (Chiefs). It’s clear he is Patrick Mahomes’ primary read on underneath routes. He’s basically the new Travis Kelce in terms of reliability, especially while Kelce draws all the double teams.
- Sit: Amari Cooper (Browns). Deshaun Watson looked completely lost out there. Until that passing game shows any sign of life, Cooper is a risky play even though he's a "name" player.
- Start: Jameson Williams (Lions). The breakout is finally happening. He’s not just a deep threat anymore; they are using him on intermediate routes and even end-arounds.
Keenan Allen is another tricky one. He’s dealing with a heel issue and he’s in a crowded room with Rome Odunze and DJ Moore. If you're looking at your week 2 start em sit em options and you see a guy like Ladd McConkey on your bench, you might actually lean toward the rookie. McConkey is the clear favorite for Justin Herbert in high-leverage situations, and that floor is much safer than an injured veteran in a dysfunctional rookie-led offense.
Tight Ends are a Nightmare Right Now
Let's be real: tight end has been a total graveyard. Sam LaPorta, Travis Kelce, Mark Andrews—none of them did anything in Week 1.
Do not bench them.
You didn't spend a high draft pick on Kelce to bench him for Isaiah Likely just because Likely had one massive game. Now, if you have Likely, he’s a "start" because the Ravens are essentially using him as a wide receiver. He's on the field constantly. But don't bench your elite studs. Tight end production is notoriously "touchdown or bust," and the targets for the big names are still there.
The only exception might be Evan Engram if the Jaguars' offense continues to look that disjointed, but even then, the waiver wire is so thin that you're probably better off sticking with the guy who caught 114 passes last year.
📖 Related: What's the score to the Denver game right now? Keeping up with the Nuggets and Broncos
Quarterback Streams and Defensive Schemes
Jayden Daniels is the real deal for fantasy because of his legs. Even if he throws for 160 yards, his rushing floor makes him a top-10 play every single week. For week 2 start em sit em purposes, he’s a locked-in starter against a Giants defense that just got shredded by Sam Darnold.
Speaking of Darnold, he’s actually a viable streamer if you’re a Jordan Love owner who is now scrambling. Kevin O'Connell is a brilliant play-caller, and Justin Jefferson makes every throw easier. Don't be afraid to play the "bad" real-life quarterbacks who are in good fantasy situations.
Why Context Matters More Than Stats
We often forget that coaches spend the first few weeks "feeling out" their roster. A player who played 40% of snaps in Week 1 might play 70% in Week 2 once the coach sees the tape.
Take the rookie running backs. They often start slow because of pass-blocking concerns. If you see a guy like Bucky Irving in Tampa Bay looking way more explosive than Rachaad White, start stashing him. You might not start him in Week 2, but you better be ready to pull the trigger by Week 3 or 4.
🔗 Read more: Chelsea Playing Today: What Time Is the Kick-Off Against Arsenal?
Actionable Steps for Your Week 2 Roster
Don't let "expert" rankings dictate everything. Use your eyes. If you watched a game and saw a player constantly open but the QB just missed him, that's a "buy low" and a "start" for next week.
- Check the Injury Reports Daily: Specifically look for offensive line injuries. A star RB is nothing behind a backup left tackle.
- Verify the Weather: It's early September, so it's usually fine, but heavy wind is the only weather factor that truly kills passing games.
- Aggressive Waiver Usage: If Isaiah Likely or J.K. Dobbins are somehow still available, burn your #1 priority or a huge chunk of your FAAB. These aren't just Week 2 fill-ins; they are season-long starters.
- Ignore "Projection" Points: Those little numbers next to the player's name on your app are just guesses based on averages. They don't account for a backup corner starting or a revenge game narrative.
- Look at the Vegas Totals: Games with an Over/Under of 48+ are where you want your flex players. More points in the game means more chances for your guy to fall into the end zone.
Stop overthinking the "name" on the jersey. Start the players who have the clearest path to 15+ touches or targets. Fantasy football is a game of volume and probability. If you follow the usage, the points will eventually catch up. Stick to your process, don't panic-trade your superstars for pennies on the dollar, and trust that the talent you drafted will rise to the top over a full season.