Fantasy football is basically a game of psychological warfare against your own brain. After one week of data, everyone panics. Your first-round pick put up a dud, some random waiver wire tight end caught two touchdowns, and now you’re staring at your lineup for three hours wondering if you’re actually bad at this. Week 2 fantasy start em sit em decisions are where seasons are actually won or lost because this is the week you have to separate "real signal" from "opening day noise."
Last year, we saw Puka Nacua explode in Week 1 and people thought it was a fluke. It wasn't. Conversely, we see guys like Sammy Watkins or Jonas Gray have legendary single games that never happen again. This week, we’re looking at matchups, volume, and the dreaded injury reports that are already piling up.
The Running Back Minefield
If you have Kyren Williams, you’re playing him. Period. I don’t care if the matchup looks "middle of the pack" on some colorful spreadsheet. The volume is there. But things get murky when we talk about the mid-tier guys.
Take someone like J.K. Dobbins. He looked electric in his debut with the Chargers, outshining Gus Edwards by a mile. You’re probably tempted to chase those points. Honestly? You should. The Chargers under Jim Harbaugh and Greg Roman want to run the ball until the opponent's defensive line literally begs for mercy. Even if Edwards gets the "goal line" touches, Dobbins has shown the burst that made him a prospect we all loved before the injuries. He’s a "start em" because the offensive line in LA is actually creating lanes you could drive a truck through.
✨ Don't miss: When Was the MLS Founded? The Chaotic Truth About American Soccer's Rebirth
On the flip side, sit Zamir White. I know, you drafted him to be a volume king in Las Vegas. But the Raiders' offense looks disjointed, and Alexander Mattison is eating into the passing game work more than anyone expected. Until that team proves they can move the chains consistently, White is a touchdown-dependent RB3 at best. You can’t trust a guy who needs 20 carries to get to 60 yards if he’s only getting 12.
Week 2 Fantasy Start Em Sit Em: Quarterback Quandaries
Jayden Daniels is a fantasy cheat code. We saw it in his debut. If a quarterback is going to run the ball 10+ times, his floor is so high it’s basically in the attic. Even if he misses a few throws or looks like a rookie in the pocket, those rushing yards are gold. Start him against almost anyone right now, especially a Giants defense that looked like they were stuck in slow motion last week.
Is it time to bench Jared Goff? Maybe. Goff is a dome god. We know this. When he’s at home in Detroit, he’s a fringe top-5 play. On the road, or against a ferocious pass rush, he gets "scared feet." If your alternative is someone like Baker Mayfield—who is playing out of his mind right now with Mike Evans and Chris Godwin—don’t be afraid to make the switch. Fantasy football isn't about "respecting" the draft capital you spent in August. It’s about who is going to put up 20 points on Sunday.
🔗 Read more: Navy Notre Dame Football: Why This Rivalry Still Hits Different
Wide Receiver Matchups That Actually Matter
Malik Nabers is going to be a superstar, but Daniel Jones is the one throwing him the ball. That’s the tragedy of our times. However, in Week 2, the volume for Nabers is just too high to ignore. He’s the entire passing offense. If you’re in a PPR league, he’s a locked-in start. He's going to get double-digit targets because the Giants literally have no other choice.
- Start: Zay Flowers. He is the clear alpha in Baltimore. With Isaiah Likely drawing all the defensive attention after his massive Week 1, Flowers should find plenty of room in the intermediate parts of the field.
- Sit: George Pickens. This hurts because his talent is immense. But the Steelers' quarterback situation is... let's call it "conservative." If Arthur Smith is calling the plays and the goal is to hide the QB, Pickens is going to have games where he only sees four targets. Against a top-tier secondary, that’s a recipe for a 3-catch, 40-yard afternoon.
Tight Ends are a Nightmare
The tight end position is currently a wasteland of broken dreams. Sam LaPorta and Travis Kelce are the only ones you truly feel "safe" with, and even then, Kelce is getting older and the Chiefs are spreading it around.
If you’re looking for a sleeper, look at Colby Parkinson for the Rams. With Puka Nacua on IR, Matthew Stafford needs someone he can trust over the middle. Cooper Kupp is going to get 20 targets (not an exaggeration), but Parkinson is the big-bodied safety valve. He played nearly every snap in Week 1. In the world of tight ends, "being on the field" is 80% of the battle.
💡 You might also like: LeBron James Without Beard: Why the King Rarely Goes Clean Shaven Anymore
Defensive Streams and Kickers
Don't hold onto a "name brand" defense if they have a bad matchup. The Jets defense is great, but if they’re playing a high-powered offense and you can grab a scrappy unit playing against a rookie QB making his first road start, you take the rookie QB matchup every time.
Check the weather. Seriously. It sounds like something your dad would say, but early-season wind or heavy rain ruins kickers and deep passing games.
Moving Forward With Your Roster
The biggest mistake people make in week 2 fantasy start em sit em is "chasing" last week's points. You have to look at usage, not just the final score. Did a receiver get 10 targets but only 2 catches? Start him. The regression is coming in a good way. Did a running back score two touchdowns on only four carries? Sit him. That’s a fluke that will ruin your week when it doesn't happen again.
Actionable Next Steps:
- Check the Injury Report on Friday Afternoon: This is when the "Doubtful" and "Out" tags actually mean something. If a lead RB is limited all week, his backup becomes a viable Flex play.
- Monitor Target Shares: Go to a site like Pro Football Reference or a specialized fantasy tracker. Look for players with a 25% or higher target share. Those are your weekly starters regardless of the "Sit" labels.
- Trust Your Gut Over the Projections: ESPN and Yahoo projections are just math models. They don't know that a specific cornerback is nursing a hamstring injury or that a coach said he wants to "get the ball to his playmaker more."
- Clear the Dead Weight: If you have a bench player who didn't even see the field in Week 1, drop them for a high-upside backup. Roster spots are too valuable to waste on "maybe" players who aren't getting snaps.
Ultimately, Week 2 is about staying calm. Don't trade your first-round pick for a bag of chips just because he had a bad Sunday. Stay the course, play the volume, and exploit the matchups where the defensive secondary is thin.