Everyone does it. You spent all summer drafting the "perfect" roster, only to watch your first-round pick put up a dud while some random waiver wire addition scores 20 points on your bench. Week 1 is a liar, but Week 2 is where the real season starts. Making sense of week 2 fantasy rankings isn't about looking at who scored the most points last Sunday. It’s about figuring out whose usage was real and who just got lucky with a couple of touchdowns.
If you’re panicking because your studs looked slow, take a breath.
✨ Don't miss: Rickey Henderson Cause of Death: What Really Happened to the Man of Steal
The Running Back Trap: Efficiency vs. Volume
The biggest mistake I see every year is chasing points at the running back position. In Week 1, we saw Derrick Henry go nuclear for 169 yards and two scores, but if you look at the underlying data, he only had one reception. In a PPR world, that’s a red flag. Meanwhile, guys like Bijan Robinson and Christian McCaffrey are seeing massive target shares that make their floors much safer.
For this week's rankings, you've gotta prioritize the "bellcow" roles.
- Bijan Robinson (ATL): He's basically the entire offense. Even if the Falcons struggle, he’s getting 20+ touches.
- Breece Hall (NYJ): He looked explosive again. The Jets' offensive line is actually holding up, which is a miracle in itself.
- Dylan Sampson (CLE): Honestly, the rookie is the real deal. He caught eight targets in his debut. That kind of involvement for a rookie back is rare and suggests he’s a must-start in Week 2.
On the flip side, be careful with Zach Charbonnet. He got a lot of buzz after Week 1, but Kenneth Walker III is still the lead dog when healthy. If Walker is out, Charbonnet is a top-15 play, but otherwise, he’s just a high-end handcuff.
Wide Receiver Volatility: Don't Sell Low
Wide receivers are the most frustrating part of fantasy football. One week they're catching 10 passes, the next they're a ghost.
✨ Don't miss: Kevin Grow: The Truth About That Down Syndrome Basketball Player Video and What Happened Next
Zay Flowers looked like a superstar in the opener, racking up 140+ yards. He’s a lock in the top 10 for Week 2. But what about Puka Nacua or Garrett Wilson? They had "fine" weeks, but nothing spectacular. The key is targets. If a guy is getting 8 to 10 targets, the big games are coming.
Kayshon Boutte is the name everyone is clicking on the waiver wire right now. He had 103 yards with Drake Maye looking his way constantly. Against a Miami secondary that just got torched, he’s a legit sleeper. Just don't expect 100 yards every week.
Week 2 Fantasy Rankings: Quarterback Tiers
The QB landscape changed fast. Josh Allen is still the king after a four-TD performance, but the emergence of the young guys is the story.
- Josh Allen (BUF): High floor, astronomical ceiling.
- Lamar Jackson (BAL): The rushing yards are back.
- Caleb Williams (CHI): He showed flashes of why he was the #1 pick.
- Bo Nix (DEN): He’s a "start of the week" for many experts because of his rushing floor and a soft matchup against a rebuilding defense.
Brock Purdy is the one to watch. He’s dealing with a turf toe injury that could limit his mobility. If he’s out, the 49ers' offense takes a massive hit, which affects everyone from Deebo Samuel to George Kittle (who is already on IR).
The Injury Bug is Already Biting
You can't talk about rankings without mentioning the training room. It feels like half the league is already "questionable."
- George Kittle (SF): Out. He’s on IR, so find a replacement like Juwan Johnson or Brock Bowers immediately.
- Jayden Reed (GB): Out 6-8 weeks with a collarbone fracture. This opens up a huge opportunity for Christian Watson and Romeo Doubs.
- Drake London (ATL): He’s dealing with an AC joint sprain but is expected to play. He might be a bit limited, so maybe lower your expectations for his YAC (yards after catch) ability this week.
Tight End Wasteland
Tight end is a mess. It always is. Sam LaPorta and Dalton Kincaid are still your best bets, but don't sleep on Harold Fannin Jr. or Tyler Warren. These guys are seeing consistent targets in offenses that lack a true #2 wide receiver.
If you're desperate, Evan Engram is usually a safe bet for 5-6 catches, even if he doesn't score. In PPR, that's gold.
Defensive Matchups to Exploit
The Steelers D/ST is a smash play against a Seattle offensive line that is currently ranked 25th by PFF. T.J. Watt and Alex Highsmith are going to live in the backfield.
I’d also look at the Rams D/ST. They generate pressure on 42% of dropbacks, and they’re facing a Titans line that is missing JC Latham. That’s a recipe for sacks and turnovers.
Actionable Strategy for Your Lineup
Stop looking at the total points from last week. Look at the snap counts.
If a player played 80% of the snaps but didn't score, they are a prime "buy low" candidate. If a player played 30% of the snaps but scored two touchdowns, they are a "sell high" candidate.
Trust the process, check the late-week injury reports, and don't bench your studs for a one-week wonder unless the matchup is truly horrific. Focus on players with guaranteed volume—targets for receivers and touches for backs—as that is the only way to sustain success over a full season. Check the weather reports for any East Coast games, as early September storms can turn a passing clinic into a ground-and-pound slog.
Lock in your starters by Thursday night, but keep a flexible "flex" spot for the Monday night game in case of late scratches. Priority should be given to players in high-total Vegas games, like the expected shootout between the Bills and Ravens.