You’ve spent fourteen weeks grinding for this. Now you’re in the fantasy playoffs, and suddenly, the defense you’ve ridden all year looks like a liability. Or maybe you're staring at the waiver wire, sweating over a bunch of names that usually belong in the "do not start" bin. Week 15 is brutal. It’s the first round of the playoffs for most, and the pressure makes people do stupid things, like starting a "good" real-life defense in a nightmare matchup.
Forget the names for a second. In fantasy, a defense is only as good as the quarterback it's playing against. Honestly, if you aren't hunting for interceptions and sacks against backup QBs or turnover-prone rookies right now, you’re doing it wrong. Let’s look at the week 15 fantasy football defense rankings through a lens that actually matters: who is going to ruin their opponent's Sunday?
The Heavy Hitters You Can Trust
The Philadelphia Eagles are the gold standard this week. They get the Las Vegas Raiders at home. Whether it’s Kenny Pickett or a banged-up Geno Smith under center for Vegas, it doesn't really matter. The Raiders have been a fantasy goldmine for opposing D/STs, leading the league in sacks allowed. Philly is a much better real-life unit, but this week, the ceiling is massive. If you have them, you aren't overthinking it. You play them.
Then there are the Seattle Seahawks. They’ve been arguably the most consistent fantasy defense over the last two months, ranking first in EPA per play allowed. Hosting the Indianapolis Colts at Lumen Field is a dream. Sam Darnold has been better than expected, but the "12th Man" factor usually leads to at least one or two "what was he thinking?" throws. Seattle's pressure rate is elite right now. They’re a top-three play, period.
🔗 Read more: Who Won the Golf Tournament This Weekend: Richard T. Lee and the 2026 Season Kickoff
The Houston Texans are another "set it and forget it" group. They face the Arizona Cardinals. While Kyler Murray can be a headache, the Texans have been a force multiplier lately, shutting down the Bills and Chiefs in consecutive weeks. They lead the NFL in pressure rate since their bye. Even if Arizona scores some points, the sack floor for Houston is incredibly high.
Streaming Your Way to a Win
If you didn’t luck into a top-tier unit, don't panic. The waiver wire actually has some gems if you’re willing to be a little brave.
Take the Jacksonville Jaguars. Most people ignore them because the Jags' season has been... well, a mess. But they’re playing the New York Jets. The Jets are likely starting undrafted rookie Brady Cook with Tyrod Taylor and Justin Fields both dealing with injuries. Cook looked completely lost against Miami, throwing two picks and taking six sacks. Jacksonville has been elite against the run and generates pressure at a 38% clip recently. They are the ultimate "plug and play" streamer for the first round of the playoffs.
💡 You might also like: The Truth About the Memphis Grizzlies Record 2025: Why the Standings Don't Tell the Whole Story
The Deep League Gambles
- San Francisco 49ers: They’ve been frustratingly inconsistent and banged up. But they’re coming off a bye to host the Tennessee Titans. The Titans allow the second-most fantasy points to opposing defenses. Cam Ward has improved, but he still takes sacks at the fourth-highest rate in the league.
- Dallas Cowboys: This is a "vibes" play. They host the Minnesota Vikings and J.J. McCarthy. McCarthy is talented, but he leads the NFL in the percentage of dropbacks that end in a sack (11%). Dallas still has the pass-rushing chops to make a young QB see ghosts on Sunday Night Football.
- Chicago Bears: They face the Cleveland Browns. Any time you can bet against the Browns’ offensive line, you do it. Myles Garrett might be on the other side, but the Bears' defense is the healthiest it has been all year. They are 7.5-point favorites for a reason.
Who Should You Actually Sit?
This is where people get hurt. They see the name "Buffalo Bills" or "New England Patriots" and think they have to start them.
Stop.
The Bills are playing the Patriots in what looks like a high-scoring shootout between Josh Allen and Drake Maye. New England’s offense has been surprisingly careful with the football, and Buffalo’s defense, while opportunistic, allows way too many yards to be a "safe" play in a playoff week.
📖 Related: The Division 2 National Championship Game: How Ferris State Just Redrew the Record Books
Similarly, the Los Angeles Rams are a great fantasy unit, but they’re hosting the Detroit Lions. Jared Goff knows SoFi Stadium like the back of his hand. The Lions allow the fewest fantasy points to opposing defenses. You’re basically hoping for a defensive touchdown to save your week if you start a D/ST in this game. Don't chase the past; look at the matchup.
Making the Final Call
Defense wins championships, but in fantasy, "bad" offenses win championships. You want the unit playing the team with the lowest implied point total.
Right now, the Jets, Titans, and Raiders are the teams to target. If a defense is playing one of them, they should probably be in your lineup over a "better" defense playing a top-ten offense.
Look at the Jacksonville Jaguars specifically. They’re available in over 60% of leagues and have a matchup that could legitimately score 15+ points. That’s the kind of edge that moves you into the second round.
Next Steps for Your Roster:
Check your waiver wire immediately for the Jacksonville Jaguars or Chicago Bears. If both are gone, look for the San Francisco 49ers, who are likely sitting there because of their recent bye week. Prioritize the Jags if Brady Cook is confirmed as the Jets' starter, as that matchup has the highest turnover ceiling of the week.