The wait is finally over, but honestly, the anxiety is just starting. You spent all summer scrolling through Twitter threads and listening to podcasts, and now you’re staring at a roster that looked like a championship squad on draft night but suddenly feels like a house of cards. Week 1 is a weird beast. We have zero real-time data from this year, just a bunch of "best shape of his life" narratives and preseason snaps that mostly featured guys who will be selling insurance by Tuesday. Navigating a start em sit em week 1 2025 strategy requires a mix of respecting draft capital and acknowledging that some situations are just toxic from the jump.
Stop overthinking the studs. If you drafted a guy in the first three rounds, you’re playing him. Period. Don’t get cute because you’re worried about a shadow corner matchup in September. However, the flex spot and that second RB or WR slot? That’s where the week is won or lost.
✨ Don't miss: Westside High School Football: Why the Wolves are Always the Team to Beat
Quarterbacks: Don't Chase Last Year's Ghosts
Everyone wants to believe the guy they took in the late rounds is the next breakout, but Week 1 is about floor. Caleb Williams, entering his second year in 2025, has a massive ceiling, but the Bears' opener against a disciplined defensive front is a "wait and see" situation. If you’ve got a steady veteran like Jared Goff playing at home in a dome, you take the guaranteed 18 points over the potential 30 (or 8) from a sophomore still finding his rhythm.
Rushing upside is the ultimate cheat code. It's why Anthony Richardson remains a "must start" regardless of the opponent. Even if he completes 50% of his passes, those 60 rushing yards and a goal-line plunge keep your matchup alive. On the flip side, pocket passers facing high-pressure rates—think Kirk Cousins behind a rebuilding offensive line—are risky. If the pocket collapses, the fantasy points evaporate.
The Backfield Grind
Running back usage in Week 1 is notoriously difficult to predict because coaches love to lie. They talk about "hot hands" and "rotations" all August. Then, Sunday comes, and the veteran suddenly gets 22 touches while the shiny new rookie sits on the bench for pass protection reasons.
Breece Hall and Christian McCaffrey are obvious. But what about the murky middle? You should start Kenneth Walker III with confidence. He’s consistently shown that he can create yards when the blocking isn't perfect, and early-season games often lean on the ground game while passing attacks find their timing. On the "sit" side, be very wary of the "split" backfields like the one in Miami or with the Lions. While Jahmyr Gibbs is an explosive play waiting to happen, David Montgomery often eats the "boring" touches that keep a floor high. If you're an underdog, play the ceiling (Gibbs). If you're the favorite, take the steady volume.
Wide Receivers: Targets are Earned, Not Given
Volume is king. In start em sit em week 1 2025 discussions, we often get distracted by "big play" potential. Forget that. Look for the guys who saw double-digit targets in the preseason or have a long-standing rapport with their QB.
Justin Jefferson and CeeDee Lamb? Don't even look at the matchup. Just click start. But let's talk about the guys like Drake London or Chris Olave. These are the players who sit on the fringe of "elite" but often face the opposing team's best cornerback. If the matchup is a lockdown shadow situation, and you have a high-volume "slot machine" like Amon-Ra St. Brown or even a surging Keon Coleman in a favorable matchup, the decision gets tough.
Actually, here's a tip: look at the over/under totals in Vegas. If a game is projected for 52 points, start everyone involved. If it's a 37-point slog in the rain, sit your WR3 for a high-floor flex.
Tight Ends: The Land of Despair
Unless you have Travis Kelce, Sam LaPorta, or Mark Andrews, you’re basically throwing darts at a map while blindfolded. Tight end is a touchdown-dependent wasteland for 80% of fantasy managers. For Week 1, look at the rookie TEs. Generally, they are terrible for fantasy in their first game. Sit them. Start the boring veteran who the QB trusts on third down. Dalton Kincaid is a great start because he functions more like a wide receiver, but for the rest of the pack, if they don't score a TD, you're looking at 4.2 points.
👉 See also: Michigan State Spartans Football Results: What Really Happened This Season
Defensive Streamers and Kicker Luck
Stop drafting defenses early. Seriously. For Week 1, you want whoever is playing a rookie QB or a team with a decimated offensive line. The Jets and Browns remain elite units, but don't be afraid to stream a team like the Bengals if they’re facing a bottom-tier offense.
Kickers? Just pick someone in a dome. Or Brandon Aubrey. Honestly, kickers are chaos, but playing in a controlled environment removes the one variable—wind—that actually ruins a kicker's day.
Handling the Flex Spot
The biggest mistake people make in their start em sit em week 1 2025 lineups is putting a Thursday night player in the flex. Never do this. Keep your flex spot open for the Sunday afternoon or Monday night games. It gives you the "pivot" option if a late-breaking injury occurs during warmups.
Also, the flex should almost always be a Wide Receiver in PPR leagues. The "workhorse" RB is a dying breed, and you're much more likely to get 15 points from a WR3 who catches six passes than an RB3 who needs a goal-line carry to be relevant.
Why Rankings are Often Wrong
Experts (myself included) rely on projections. But projections can't account for a coach's ego or a sudden change in game script. If a team goes down by 14 points early, the "start" RB you liked is suddenly irrelevant as the team shifts to a 2-minute drill passing offense.
Always look for the "in-game" environment. Is it a revenge game? Is there a massive height advantage in the red zone? These nuances matter more than a generic "Ranked #14" tag.
Actionable Strategy for Sunday Morning
- Check the Inactives: Usually released 90 minutes before kickoff. If a starting offensive lineman is out, it downgrades the RB significantly.
- Weather Matters, But Only a Little: Rain isn't a big deal for WRs; wind is. If gusts are over 20 mph, look for a different QB.
- Trust Your Gut on the "Toss-ups": If you’ve spent all week debating between two players, they are likely projected within one point of each other. At that point, pick the guy you'll actually enjoy watching on RedZone. It’s a game. It should be fun.
Trust the players who have the clearest path to 7+ targets or 15+ carries. Don't chase the "fluke" three-touchdown game from a guy who only played 20% of the snaps last year. Week 1 is about survival. Get the win, keep your stars healthy, and work the waiver wire on Monday night.
Log into your platform an hour before the first kickoff. Double-check that your "questionable" players are actually active. Ensure your kicker isn't playing in a literal hurricane. Once the 1:00 PM games start, put the phone down for a bit. You’ve done the work. Now it’s up to the guys on the field.