If you’re driving down the Overseas Highway, past the fishing bridges and the turquoise shallows, you’ll eventually hit a stretch of land that feels a bit more "old Florida" than the rest. That’s Long Key. Most people just breeze through it on their way to Key West, but if you stop at Long Key State Park, you realize the environment here is a delicate balancing act. The weather in Long Key Florida isn't just "sunny with a chance of rain." It is a living, breathing thing that dictates whether you’ll be kayaking through glassy lagoons or hunkered down in a stilted house watching the palms go horizontal.
Most tourists think the Florida Keys have one season: Hot.
Honestly? That’s a total myth.
While the mercury stays relatively high, the nuance between a January afternoon and an August morning is the difference between a crisp mojito and a warm, wet blanket. Long Key sits in the middle of the archipelago, meaning it catches the breeze from both the Atlantic and the Florida Bay. This "middle-of-the-road" geography creates a micro-climate that can be surprisingly different from Miami or even Key West.
The Reality of the "Dry" Season
Winter in the Keys is what everyone dreams of. Between November and April, the humidity—that thick, heavy air that makes your hair quadruple in size—basically vanishes. You get these gorgeous, clear days where the sky is a shade of blue that doesn't even look real.
But here is the catch: cold fronts.
Every few weeks, a front will push down from the north. In Miami, it might just mean a light jacket. In Long Key, it means the wind kicks up. Hard. These "northers" can turn the shallow flats of the bay into a choppy mess. If you're planning on fishing or paddling, a 75-degree day in January sounds perfect, but a 20-knot wind will ruin your plans faster than a flat tire.
- January and February: The coldest months. Highs around 75°F, lows around 64°F.
- Water Temps: Brisk. You’re looking at 70-72°F. Locals won't touch the water without a 3mm wetsuit, but if you're from Michigan, it feels like a heated pool.
- Rainfall: Minimal. This is the "Dry Season" for a reason. You might go weeks without a drop.
According to the National Weather Service in Key West, this period accounts for less than 25% of the annual rainfall. It’s the peak of the "snowbird" season, so expect the State Park to be packed. If you want a campsite here in February, you basically have to book it exactly 11 months in advance at the stroke of midnight.
Summer and the Tropical Humidity Spike
Come May, the atmosphere shifts. The "Bermuda High" moves in, and the wind dies down to a whisper. This is when the weather in Long Key Florida starts to feel truly tropical.
The heat index is the real story here.
While the actual thermometer rarely hits 100°F (the ocean breeze prevents the extreme spikes seen in inland Florida), the dew point is relentless. In July and August, the dew point often sits at 75°F or higher. That’s "oppressive" on the comfort scale. You walk outside and you’re instantly covered in a fine sheen of sweat.
But there’s a trade-off.
The water in the summer is like glass. It is the best time for snorkeling the "Canoe Trail" or exploring the seagrass beds because the visibility is incredible. The water temperature climbs to a balmy 86°F. It’s not refreshing; it’s more like a bathtub. You can stay in for hours without even a shiver.
The Afternoon Thunderstorm Ritual
If you’re visiting in the summer, you need to know about the "3:00 PM Boom."
Like clockwork, the heat builds up on the mainland and the sea breeze pushes clouds toward the Keys. You’ll see them towering on the horizon—massive, white anvil-shaped cumulonimbus clouds. When they hit Long Key, it pours. Not a drizzle. A deluge.
The sky turns purple, the lightning is terrifyingly close, and the temperature drops 10 degrees in three minutes. And then, 45 minutes later? It’s over. The sun comes back out, the ground steams, and the mosquitoes come out to play.
👉 See also: Things to do Middletown Ohio: Why This Rust Belt Town is Actually a Weekend Powerhouse
Hurricane Season: The Elephant in the Room
We have to talk about it. From June 1st to November 30th, the weather in Long Key Florida is under the shadow of the Atlantic Hurricane Season.
Long Key is vulnerable. It’s a narrow strip of land with very little elevation. Historically, the "peak" is mid-August through October. If you look at the history of the Keys, storms like Irma (2017) or the 1935 Labor Day Hurricane (which hit just south of here on Upper Matecumbe) changed the landscape forever.
If you’re booking a trip during this window, get travel insurance. Seriously.
Modern forecasting is amazing, and the National Hurricane Center in Miami gives days of warning, but a tropical storm can still turn a vacation into an evacuation order in 24 hours. Honestly, September is the quietest month in terms of crowds, but it’s the riskiest in terms of weather. It’s a gamble. Sometimes the gamble pays off with the most beautiful, still, and private beach days of your life. Other times, you’re stuck in traffic on US-1 heading north with everyone else.
Seasonal Planning by the Numbers
To give you a better idea of what to pack, here is a rough breakdown of what the weather actually looks like on the ground:
- Spring (March–May): This is the sweet spot. The water is warming up (76-80°F), but the humidity hasn't become a monster yet. Rainfall is still low. It’s the most expensive time to visit, though.
- Summer (June–August): Hot, humid, and still. Great for divers. Average highs are around 89°F. Expect a thunderstorm most afternoons.
- Fall (September–October): The "Transition." It stays hot through September, but by late October, the first cold front usually breaks the humidity. This is the peak of hurricane risk.
- Winter (November–February): Cool and dry. Best for hiking the Golden Orb Trail without melting. Just watch the wind forecasts if you want to be on a boat.
Surprising Details Most People Miss
One thing people don't realize about Long Key is the "tide weather." Because the water is so shallow around the island, the tide significantly affects the local temperature. At low tide, the sun bakes the exposed flats. When the tide rushes back in over that hot sand, the water temperature can actually spike several degrees in an hour.
Also, the sun is a different beast here. Because you’re further south and surrounded by reflective water and white sand, the UV index is off the charts. You can get a blistering sunburn in 15 minutes in June, even if it’s "cloudy."
Actionable Steps for Your Visit
If you're heading to Long Key soon, don't just check the temperature. Check the wind speed and direction. - Check Windfinder or Sailflow: If the wind is coming from the North or Northeast at over 15 knots, the Atlantic side of Long Key (where the state park beach is) will be rough and potentially full of sargassum seaweed.
- Pack for "Layers of Humidity": Even in the summer, carry a light, long-sleeve performance shirt (SPF rated). It keeps the sun off and protects you from the "no-see-ums" (tiny biting gnats) that come out at dusk when the wind drops.
- Download a Lightning Tracker: Florida is the lightning capital of the country. If you hear thunder, the storm is already close enough to hit you. Use an app like My Lightning Tracker to see exactly where the strikes are landing.
- Monitor the "Keys Normal": If the forecast says 80 degrees, it will feel like 88. If it says 65, it will feel like 55 because of the damp ocean air. Always add or subtract 5-10 degrees for "real feel."
The weather in Long Key Florida is the soul of the island. It’s what keeps the mangroves lush and the bonefish biting. Respect the sun, watch the wind, and always have a Plan B for those rainy afternoons. If you do that, you’ll find that even a "bad" weather day in the Keys is better than a perfect day almost anywhere else.