Relationships aren't supposed to be a scripted drama, yet for so many, the cycle of we fight we break up we kiss we make up becomes the literal rhythm of their lives. It's exhausting. It’s also incredibly common. You’ve probably seen it on your social feed—the couple that posts a "it's over" black-square status on Tuesday only to share a selfie at dinner on Friday with the caption "my soulmate."
Kinda makes you dizzy, right?
Pop culture loves this stuff. Katy Perry basically turned the phrase into a global anthem with her 2008 hit Hot N Cold. She sang about the "PDA" and the "B-O-Y" who changes his mind like a girl changes clothes. It was catchy because it tapped into a universal truth: the high of reconciliation is often more addictive than the stability of a healthy relationship.
But there's a real-world cost to living in a loop of high-octane conflict and passionate reunions. It isn't just "passion." Sometimes, it’s a symptom of deeper psychological patterns that, if left unchecked, can wreak havoc on your nervous system and your self-esteem.
Why We Get Stuck in the "We Fight We Break Up We Kiss We Make Up" Loop
Why do we do this to ourselves? Honestly, it’s rarely about the actual fight. Most couples aren't screaming over who left the milk out. They're screaming because they don't know how to regulate their emotions or because they’re chasing the "makeup high."
When you fight and break up, your body is flooded with cortisol and adrenaline. It’s the fight-or-flight response in full gear. Then comes the "kiss" and the "make up" phase. Suddenly, your brain is doused in dopamine and oxytocin—the "cuddle hormone." This massive chemical shift creates an intermittent reinforcement schedule. It’s the same psychological mechanism that keeps people pulling the lever on a slot machine. You endure the losses because the "win" feels so intensely good.
Psychologist Dr. Stan Tatkin, founder of the PACT (Psychobiological Approach to Couple Therapy), often discusses how partners become "pro-social" or "anti-social" based on their perceived safety. When you're in the we fight we break up we kiss we make up cycle, you’re constantly toggling between extreme threat and extreme safety. This isn't intimacy; it’s a biological roller coaster. It creates an insecure attachment style where you never quite feel the ground beneath your feet.
👉 See also: Images of Thanksgiving Holiday: What Most People Get Wrong
The Katy Perry Effect and Modern Romance
When Katy Perry sang "We fight, we break up / We kiss, we make up," she wasn't just writing a pop hook. She was describing "relationship churning." This is a term researchers use to describe on-again, off-again relationships. According to studies from the University of Missouri, roughly 60% of adults have been involved in a relationship that followed this pattern at some point.
It’s easy to romanticize. We see it in movies like The Notebook where Noah and Allie "didn't agree on anything" and "fought all the time," yet they were "crazy about each other." This narrative teaches us that if there isn't a massive explosion, there isn't true love.
That’s a lie.
True intimacy is actually quite quiet. It’s consistent. It’s boring in the best way possible. When you’re constantly breaking up to make up, you’re substituting drama for depth. You’re too busy putting out fires to ever build a foundation.
The Psychological Toll of Relationship Churning
Living like this isn't just annoying for your friends who have to hear about your "final" breakup for the tenth time. It’s actually bad for your health. Research published in the journal Family Relations suggests that people in on-again, off-again relationships report higher rates of depression and anxiety.
The uncertainty is the killer.
✨ Don't miss: Why Everyone Is Still Obsessing Over Maybelline SuperStay Skin Tint
Think about it. If you never know if a disagreement will lead to the end of your relationship, you can never truly be vulnerable. You’re always on guard. This leads to "kitchen-sinking"—where every past grievance is thrown into a single argument because you’re terrified this is your last chance to speak.
Then comes the "make up."
The makeup sex might be great, but it’s often a band-aid. It bypasses the hard work of conflict resolution. You haven't actually solved the problem; you’ve just drowned it in oxytocin. The problem is still there, waiting in the corner, ready to trigger the next "we fight" phase in two weeks.
Is It Passion or Is It Trauma Bonding?
We need to talk about trauma bonding. This is a phrase that gets tossed around a lot on TikTok, but it has a specific meaning. A trauma bond occurs when a person develops a strong sense of loyalty to someone who is intermittently abusive or toxic.
I’m not saying every couple that fights is in an abusive relationship.
However, the we fight we break up we kiss we make up cycle is the framework for a trauma bond. The "break up" is the punishment; the "kiss and make up" is the reward. This creates a powerful emotional tether that is incredibly hard to break. You start to feel like you need the other person to regulate your emotions, even though they are the ones who dysregulated you in the first place.
🔗 Read more: Coach Bag Animal Print: Why These Wild Patterns Actually Work as Neutrals
How to Break the Cycle for Good
So, how do you stop? How do you move from the chaos of "Hot N Cold" to something that actually feels like home?
It starts with recognizing that the cycle is the problem, not the person. If you both want to make it work, you have to agree to take "breaking up" off the table as a negotiation tactic. Using the threat of leaving to get your way is emotional manipulation. It kills trust.
- Implement a 24-hour Rule: If a fight gets too heated, agree to a "cool-down" period. You aren't breaking up; you’re just stepping into separate rooms to let your nervous systems calm down.
- Identify the Triggers: What actually starts the "we fight" phase? Is it money? Insecurity? Household chores? If you keep having the same fight, you aren't fighting about the chores. You’re fighting about a perceived lack of respect or support.
- Stop the Public Blasts: When you're in the "break up" phase, don't go to social media. Don't tell your mom. When you involve an audience, you make the "make up" phase much harder because you now have to manage everyone else’s opinion of your partner.
- Seek "Boring" Stability: Practice being okay with peace. Some people find stability terrifying because they grew up in chaotic households. They mistake peace for a lack of chemistry. It’s not. It’s just health.
When to Actually Walk Away
There is a difference between a couple that needs better communication skills and a relationship that is fundamentally broken. If the "we fight" part involves physical violence, verbal abuse, or systematic gaslighting, the "make up" part doesn't matter.
You can’t kiss your way out of toxicity.
If you find that the breakups are getting longer and the makeups are getting shorter, the cycle is decaying. Eventually, the "kiss" won't be enough to bridge the gap created by the "fight." Honestly, sometimes the most loving thing you can do is stay broken up.
Actionable Steps for Emotional Stability
If you’re currently in the middle of a we fight we break up we kiss we make up loop, take a breath. You can get off the ride.
- Track the Pattern: Write down the last three fights. What started them? How long did the "breakup" last? You’ll likely see a pattern that has nothing to do with the external world and everything to do with internal triggers.
- Define Your Boundaries: Decide what is "fight-worthy" and what is "deal-breaker" territory. If "breaking up" is used as a weapon during a minor argument, call it out.
- Prioritize Self-Regulation: Learn to soothe yourself without needing the "kiss and make up" validation from your partner. This breaks the addictive nature of the cycle.
- Consult a Professional: If you can't stop the loop on your own, a therapist trained in Gottman Method or PACT can help you identify the "attachment cries" hidden inside your anger.
The goal isn't to never fight. Every couple fights. The goal is to fight in a way that leads to understanding rather than a breakup. Real love doesn't require a revolving door. It requires the courage to stay in the room when things get uncomfortable and the wisdom to know when the door should stay locked for good.