It was 3 a.m. on May 22, 1981, when a loud splash echoed off the murky waters of the Chattahoochee River. That single sound changed everything for a city on the brink of a nervous breakdown. Atlanta was terrified. For two years, Black children had been disappearing and turning up dead in woods and creeks.
When police stopped a white-over-blue Cadillac on the James Jackson Parkway bridge seconds after that splash, they found a 23-year-old freelance photographer named Wayne Williams. He told them he was going to audition a singer.
He didn't have a body in the car.
They let him go.
Two days later, the naked body of 27-year-old Nathaniel Cater floated to the surface downstream. Suddenly, the man who wanted to be a music mogul was the prime suspect in the most notorious killing spree in Georgia history. Honestly, it's a case that still feels unfinished even decades later.
The Conviction of Wayne Williams in Atlanta Georgia
Most people assume Wayne Williams was convicted of killing children.
He wasn't.
In February 1982, a jury found him guilty of murdering two adults: Nathaniel Cater and 21-year-old Jimmy Ray Payne. That's it. He has never been tried for the murders of the roughly 29 children and adolescents whose deaths are collectively known as the Atlanta Child Murders.
👉 See also: Who Is Actually in Charge of Homeland Security? The Messy Truth About Leadership and Power
The prosecution’s case was basically a massive jigsaw puzzle of microscopic evidence. They used "meticulous hair and fiber analysis," which was high-tech for the time. They found rare yellowish-green carpet fibers on the victims that matched the carpet in Williams' bedroom. Experts testified that the probability of someone else having that specific fiber was 1 in 8,000.
Why the trial was so controversial
Williams didn't exactly help himself on the stand. He got angry. He snapped at the prosecutor. The jury saw a side of him that felt "combative," which didn't sit well with folks looking for a monster.
Once the guilty verdict for the two adults came in, the police just... closed the other cases. They attributed 22 other deaths to him without ever filing charges.
- The killings stopped once he was behind bars.
- FBI profilers like John Douglas were convinced he was the guy for many of them.
- But several parents of the victims never believed he did it.
The Evidence That Doesn't Quite Fit
You've got to look at the other side of the coin to understand why this is still a "thing" in 2026. Williams has always maintained his innocence. He claims he's a scapegoat used to prevent a race war in a city that was a "powder keg" in the early '80s.
There's the KKK theory. Secretly recorded conversations from 1981 revealed a white supremacist named Charles Sanders talking about "wiping out" generations. Sanders was a suspect. He even owned a dog and lived in a house with similar carpet. But he passed a lie detector test, and the lead went cold.
👉 See also: Charlie Kirk, What Is a Woman, and the Cultural Firestorm That Won't Quit
Many people, including the late author James Baldwin, argued that the city was too eager to pin everything on a young Black man to keep the peace.
The Reopening of the Cases
In 2019, former Atlanta Mayor Keisha Lance Bottoms ordered a re-examination of the evidence. She wanted the families to have real closure, especially with modern DNA technology.
In October 2021, investigators hand-delivered evidence to a specialized lab in Salt Lake City, Utah. We’re talking about deteriorated DNA that couldn’t be tested in the '80s. The Atlanta Police Department has been pretty quiet about the results, but they’ve been looking at everything with a "blank slate."
Wayne Williams is currently serving his consecutive life sentences at Telfair State Prison. He was denied parole in 2019 because of the "nature and circumstances" of his crimes. His next shot at a parole hearing isn't until November 2027.
What Most People Get Wrong
People often think the "Atlanta Child Murders" is a solved, open-and-shut case. It's really more of a legal grey area.
If you look at the facts, the evidence against Williams for the adult murders was strong, but the "pattern" used to link him to the kids was circumstantial. Some victims were strangled. Others were shot. One was even tied to a tree with an electrical cord. That's a lot of different methods for one killer.
Even John Douglas, the famous FBI profiler, once said there was "no strong evidence" linking Williams to all of the deaths. It's possible Atlanta had more than one predator at the same time.
🔗 Read more: How Many Kids Died in 9/11: The Figures and the Families Behind the Statistics
Key facts to remember:
- Convictions: Only two adult murders (Cater and Payne).
- Fiber Evidence: The core of the 1982 trial.
- DNA: Retesting began in 2019; results are largely pending or not yet public in a way that changes the verdict.
- Parole: Williams remains incarcerated with his next eligibility in 2027.
If you’re looking to understand the full scope of the case, you should check out the FBI Vault records or the 1985 essay The Evidence of Things Not Seen by James Baldwin. They provide a much deeper look at the social tension in Georgia at the time.
To stay updated on the legal status, you can monitor the Georgia Department of Corrections inmate database or follow the official Atlanta Police Department news portal for updates on the DNA re-testing.