You’re walking down Michigan Avenue, dodging a sea of tourists and locals in puffer jackets, and suddenly you’re hungry. Not "fancy steakhouse" hungry or "sit-down brunch" hungry. You need something fast, reliable, and—honestly—indoors because Chicago wind is no joke. That’s usually when people start looking for the Water Tower Place food court.
But here is the thing. If you haven’t been to the Magnificent Mile in a few years, you might get a little confused. People still call it the "food court," but the days of a dozen different stalls with generic neon signs are mostly gone. Things changed. A lot.
The shopping center at 835 North Michigan Avenue has been a staple since 1975. It’s an icon. But the way we eat while shopping has shifted from those old-school mall trays to something a bit more curated. If you're looking for that massive, sprawling basement cafeteria vibe, you’re actually looking for something specific: Foodlife. Or, well, what replaced it.
The Transformation of Dining at Water Tower Place
For decades, the "Water Tower Place food court" meant one thing: Foodlife. It was a pioneer. Created by Richard Melman’s Lettuce Entertain You Enterprises, it was this massive "urban dining hall" where you got a card at the door, swiped it at different stations—tacos, sushi, burgers, stir-fry—and paid at the end. It was efficient. It was kind of cool.
Then 2020 happened.
Foodlife closed its doors for good, leaving a massive hole in the mall's dining scene. For a while, the options felt a bit thin. You had the Harry Caray’s 7th Inning Stretch on the 7th floor, which is great for a burger and some sports memorabilia, but it didn't quite hit that "quick variety" itch.
Nowadays, the dining landscape is more spread out. You’ve got the Mity Nice Bar & Grill (also a Lettuce Entertain You spot) tucked away behind a retail corridor, offering a more relaxed, sit-down pace. But if you are hunting for that fast-casual, high-variety experience, you have to look at how the mall has pivoted to attract a new generation of shoppers who care more about "Instagrammable" treats and specific brands than a tray of lukewarm mall bourbon chicken.
Where to Actually Eat Right Now
Let’s talk specifics. You aren’t here for a history lesson; you’re here because you’re hungry.
📖 Related: TSA PreCheck Look Up Number: What Most People Get Wrong
If you go to the mezzanine or the lower levels, you’ll find the anchors. Wildberry Pancakes and Cafe is technically right there, and let me tell you, the lines are legendary. It’s not a "food court" spot, but it is the primary reason people are congregating with buzzers in their hands. Their Signature Berry Bliss pancakes are basically a Chicago rite of passage at this point.
Then you have the specialty spots. Do-Rite Donuts & Chicken is a heavy hitter. It’s small, it’s tucked in, but their buttermilk old-fashioned donuts are arguably some of the best in the city. Getting a fried chicken sandwich there while looking out at the vertical mall's atrium is a solid way to spend twenty minutes.
The 7th Floor Hub
This is where the energy is. If you head up the escalators—which, let’s be real, take forever—you hit the entertainment level.
- Harry Caray’s 7th Inning Stretch: This is the closest thing to a "main" restaurant now. It’s loud, it’s fun, and it’s attached to the Chicago Sports Museum.
- Garrett Popcorn Shops: You’ll smell it before you see it. The "Chicago Mix" (Cheese and Caramel) is mandatory. Don't fight it. Just get the bag.
- L’Appetito: This is the unsung hero. It’s an authentic Italian deli. You can grab a sub, some arancini, or a cannoli. It feels way less like "mall food" and more like a neighborhood spot that accidentally ended up in a skyscraper.
Honestly, the vibe has shifted toward these "destination" snacks. You’ve got Holliday’s for sweets or the various coffee kiosks that keep the shoppers caffeinated. It’s less about a centralized court and more about a vertical scavenger hunt for calories.
Why the "Food Court" Concept Died (and Why That’s Okay)
The death of the traditional Water Tower Place food court wasn't an accident. Consumer habits on Michigan Avenue changed. People stopped wanting to eat in a windowless basement under fluorescent lights.
They wanted windows. They wanted "fast-fine" dining.
The Magnificent Mile has struggled lately—we’ve all seen the headlines about vacancies. But the food is what’s keeping these buildings alive. By moving away from a single, crowded food court and toward individual, branded experiences like American Girl Cafe (which is a massive draw for families), the mall is trying to turn eating into an "event."
👉 See also: Historic Sears Building LA: What Really Happened to This Boyle Heights Icon
Is it annoying if you just want a quick $8 slice of Sbarro? Yeah, maybe. But the quality of what’s there now is objectively higher. You’re trading convenience for actual flavor.
Survival Tips for Eating at Water Tower Place
If you’re heading there today, keep a few things in mind.
First, timing is everything. If you try to go to Wildberry on a Saturday morning at 10:00 AM, you are going to be waiting for two hours. Minimum. Go on a Tuesday. Or go at 2:00 PM for a "late-breakfast-early-lunch" situation.
Second, use the back elevators. The glass elevators in the center are fun for the view, but they stop at every single floor and people get in just to go up one level. It’s maddening. The service elevators or the ones tucked near the restrooms are usually faster.
Third, don't forget the surrounding block. If you walk out the doors of Water Tower Place and you’re frustrated by the crowds, remember that 900 North Michigan (the Bloomingdale’s building) is literally across the street. They have Aster Hall.
The Aster Hall Alternative
If you are mourning the old Foodlife, Aster Hall is where you actually want to go. It’s a massive, high-end food hall on the 5th and 6th floors of 900 North Michigan. It has everything:
- Small Cheval (The "accessible" version of the world-famous Au Cheval burger).
- Sushi Dokku.
- Greenwich Village deli sandwiches.
- A really decent taco spot.
It uses the kiosk ordering system, it’s incredibly chic, and the views of the Fourth Presbyterian Church across the street are stunning. It’s basically the "evolved" version of what the Water Tower food court used to be.
✨ Don't miss: Why the Nutty Putty Cave Seal is Permanent: What Most People Get Wrong About the John Jones Site
What Most People Get Wrong
People often think Water Tower Place is just for tourists. That’s a mistake. Even with the changes, it’s one of the few places in the Gold Coast where you can get a decent meal for under $20 without a reservation.
The "hidden" secret is the Mity Nice Bar & Grill. Most people walk right past the entrance because it’s hidden behind a cloakroom near the old Foodlife entrance. It feels like a 1940s lounge. It’s quiet. The pot roast is incredible. It’s the perfect escape from the chaos of Michigan Avenue.
Also, don't sleep on the American Girl Cafe. I know, I know—it sounds like a nightmare if you don't have kids. But their afternoon tea is actually handled quite well, and the service is surprisingly sharp. It’s a specific niche, sure, but it’s a huge part of the building's ecosystem.
Realities of Modern Mall Dining
We have to be honest: Water Tower Place is in a state of flux. With major tenants like Macy's having left a few years ago, the foot traffic isn't what it was in 1995. This affects the food options. You might see a kiosk that was there last month suddenly shuttered.
However, the "destination" spots are sticking around. People will always travel for a Garrett Popcorn tin or a Harry Caray’s burger. The shift toward smaller, high-quality vendors over a massive cafeteria reflects a broader trend in Chicago real estate. We’re seeing it at the Old Post Office and the various "Time Out" style markets.
The Water Tower Place food court as a singular entity is a ghost, but the building as a dining destination is still very much alive. It’s just... different. It's more of a collection of choices now.
Actionable Next Steps
- Check the Hours: Many of the 7th-floor eateries close earlier than the mall’s retail stores, especially on weekdays. If you're planning a late dinner, call ahead.
- Download the Apps: If you’re hitting Do-Rite or Wildberry, check if they have mobile waitlists or ordering. It can save you 45 minutes of standing in a hallway.
- Validate Your Parking: If you park in the Water Tower garage, it is notoriously expensive. Check if your dining spot offers validation; some of the sit-down restaurants will knock a significant chunk off that bill.
- Explore the Mezzanine: Don't just stay on the ground floor. Some of the best quick-grab coffee and snack spots are tucked away on the levels you’d normally skip on the escalator.
- Cross-Shop for Food: If Water Tower is too crowded, walk the 100 feet over to 900 North Michigan. Aster Hall often has more seating and a slightly more "adult" atmosphere if you need to get some work done while you eat.
The reality is that while the "food court" label might be outdated, the building remains a vital pit stop. Whether you're grabbing a quick donut or sitting down for a sports-themed lunch, there's enough variety to keep you from walking back out into the wind on an empty stomach.