If you walk through Nationals Park in D.C. today, you’ll see the statues. Walter Johnson is there, mid-windup, looking like he’s about to blow a fastball past a hitter from 1924. It’s a great tribute. But honestly? It’s also a little confusing for the casual fan. The current Washington Nationals aren't actually the same franchise as the old Senators. In fact, Washington senators baseball history is a messy, three-part saga defined by legendary losing, one miraculous championship, and two heartbreaking relocations.
Basically, there wasn't just one "Senators" team. There were three distinct eras, and if you don't keep them straight, the stats make zero sense.
The First Senators: A 19th-Century Disaster
Before the American League even existed, D.C. had a team in the National League from 1891 to 1899. They were technically called the Statesmen first, then the Senators. They were bad. Like, historically bad.
They never had a winning season. Not one. They went through 12 managers in nine years. Eventually, the National League got tired of the losing and the tiny crowds and just folded the team entirely. It was a bleak start for baseball in the capital, setting a tone of "lovable losers" that would stick for decades.
The "Big Train" and the 1924 Miracle
The team most people think of when they talk about Washington senators baseball history is the American League charter franchise that started in 1901. This is the team of Walter Johnson.
For the first decade, they lived up to the famous joke by columnist Charley Dryden: "Washington: First in war, first in peace, and last in the American League." They were an absolute punchline. Then, a lanky kid from Kansas named Walter Johnson showed up.
Johnson, nicknamed "The Big Train," was the first true power pitcher. He won 417 games. He threw so hard that hitters of the era were genuinely terrified. But even with the greatest pitcher on earth, the team usually finished in the cellar.
Everything changed in 1924. Clark Griffith, the team's owner and a former pitching star himself, took a massive gamble. He appointed 27-year-old second baseman Bucky Harris as the player-manager. They called him the "Boy Wonder."
- The 1924 World Series: It went seven games against the New York Giants.
- The Pebble: In the bottom of the 12th inning of Game 7, a ground ball hit a pebble and hopped over the Giants' third baseman's head.
- The Result: Muddy Ruel scrambled home. Washington won its only World Series title as the Senators.
It was the peak. The Senators went back to the World Series in 1925 and 1933, but they lost both times. After 1933, the "dark ages" really set in. Attendance cratered. The stadium, Griffith Stadium, was falling apart. In 1960, owner Calvin Griffith (Clark's nephew) decided he’d had enough and moved the whole operation to Minnesota. They became the Twins.
The Expansion Senators: 1961–1971
Major League Baseball felt bad about leaving D.C. without a team, so they immediately granted the city an expansion franchise for 1961. They even let them keep the name "Senators."
This version was somehow even more frustrating than the first. They had one superstar: Frank "Hondo" Howard. He was a mountain of a man who hit 44 home runs three years in a row (1968-1970). He was the only reason people bought tickets.
The high point—if you can call it that—was 1969. The legendary Ted Williams came out of retirement to manage the team. They actually finished with a winning record (86-76). Fans thought the tide was turning. It wasn't.
The owner, Bob Short, was deep in debt. He started trading away young talent for quick cash. By 1971, he was ready to bail. The final game at RFK Stadium ended in a forfeit because angry fans literally stormed the field and stole the bases while the team was winning. They moved to Arlington and became the Texas Rangers.
The Name Confusion: Senators vs. Nationals
Here’s the thing that trips everyone up. From 1905 to 1955, the team's official name was the Washington Nationals. The owners thought "Senators" sounded too stuffy.
But the fans didn't care. They kept calling them the Senators. The newspapers used both names interchangeably. It wasn't until 1956 that the team officially switched the name back to Senators to match what people were actually saying. This is why you see "W" hats on some old photos and "Nationals" on others. It's the same guys.
Why the History Matters Now
You’ve got to understand that for 33 years, D.C. was a baseball graveyard. When the Montreal Expos moved to town in 2005 to become the new Nationals, they inherited a city that was still bitter about 1961 and 1971.
The reason the 2019 World Series win was such a big deal wasn't just about that specific team. It was about exorcising a century of "first in war, first in peace, last in the American League."
Actionable Next Steps for Baseball History Buffs:
If you want to dive deeper into the gritty details of Washington senators baseball history, don't just look at the Hall of Fame plaques.
👉 See also: NCAA Big Ten Basketball Standings: Why the New 18-Team Map is Chaos
- Check the 1924 Box Scores: Look at the play-by-play of Game 7. The fact that Walter Johnson pitched four innings of relief on one day of rest is still one of the gutsiest moves in postseason history.
- Research the "Grays": While the Senators were losing, the Homestead Grays of the Negro Leagues were playing at Griffith Stadium and winning championships. Their history is just as much a part of D.C. baseball as the Senators'.
- Visit the Library of Congress: They hold the original photos and newspapers from the 1924 parade. Seeing the city shut down for a baseball team in the 20s puts the modern "Nats" fever into perspective.
Understanding the Senators isn't just about stats; it's about a city that kept losing its heart and finally found a way to win it back.