The question pops up in barbershops, history forums, and viral TikTok threads every single year. Was President Lincoln Black? It sounds like a modern conspiracy theory, but the roots of this claim actually go back to the 1860s. Honestly, if you look at the grainy daguerreotypes of the 16th president, you see a man who didn't exactly fit the "Gilded Age" aesthetic of his peers. He had coarse, wiry hair, a very dark complexion for someone of European descent, and features that his political enemies used to cruel advantage.
People have been debating Abraham Lincoln's ancestry for over 150 years. This isn't just a "woke" re-imagining of history. It’s a messy, complicated look at how we define race in America and how political mudslinging can accidentally create a lasting historical mystery.
Where the Rumors Actually Started
It wasn't a secret. During the 1860 election, Lincoln’s opponents—the "Copperheads" and pro-slavery Democrats—were desperate to sink his campaign. They didn't just call him a radical. They called him "Abraham Africanus I." They circulated pamphlets claiming he was a "mulatto."
In the 19th century, accusing a politician of having "Negro blood" was a standard character assassination tactic. It was meant to stoke fear among white voters who were terrified of abolition. These cartoons often exaggerated his features to make him look less "white" by the standards of the time.
But here’s the thing.
Lincoln never spent much time defending his lineage. He was a man of humble beginnings—what he called "the short and simple annals of the poor." Because his mother, Nancy Hanks, was born out of wedlock, a massive vacuum of information existed. People filled that vacuum with whatever theories suited their agenda.
The Melungeon Theory
One of the most persistent arguments focuses on the idea that Lincoln was of Melungeon descent. If you aren’t familiar with the term, Melungeons are a group of people from the Appalachian region—specifically East Tennessee, Southwest Virginia, and Eastern Kentucky—who have a "tri-racial" isolate background.
🔗 Read more: Recent Obituaries in Charlottesville VA: What Most People Get Wrong
Research by historians like Dr. Brent Kennedy has suggested that these populations are a mix of European, African, and Native American ancestry. Lincoln’s father, Thomas Lincoln, and his mother Nancy both came from these frontier areas. Lincoln’s physical appearance—the deep-set eyes, the olive-toned skin that tanned easily, and the dark, unruly hair—aligned with the physical descriptions of Melungeon families.
The J.A. Rogers Perspective
If you’ve ever read World’s Great Men of Color by the Jamaican-American historian J.A. Rogers, you’ve seen the argument laid out in detail. Rogers was a pioneer in reclaiming Black history that had been "whitewashed" by Western academia. He didn't just guess; he pointed to descriptions from Lincoln’s own contemporaries.
He cited people like William Herndon, Lincoln’s law partner and biographer. Herndon once described Lincoln’s skin as "shriveled and yellow" and his hair as "black and lackluster." To Rogers, these weren't just descriptions of a weathered frontiersman. They were evidence of African heritage.
Rogers also highlighted the story of Lincoln’s mother. There were rumors—never proven—that Nancy Hanks was the daughter of an Ethiopian man. While most mainstream historians dismiss this as hearsay, it remains a cornerstone of the argument for those who believe Lincoln was the first Black president.
What the DNA and Genealogy Say
Let's get real for a second. We live in the age of 23andMe. Can’t we just test him?
Well, it’s complicated.
💡 You might also like: Trump New Gun Laws: What Most People Get Wrong
While we have locks of Lincoln's hair and bloodstains from the night at Ford’s Theatre, extracting a full genomic sequence from 160-year-old degraded samples is incredibly difficult. However, we do have the Hanks DNA Project.
- Geneticists have tested descendants of the Hanks family tree.
- The results overwhelmingly show "Haplogroup R1b," which is Western European.
- On the Lincoln side (the paternal line), the DNA traces back to Samuel Lincoln, who came from Hingham, England, in 1637.
Does this settle it? Mostly. But it doesn't account for the possibility of "non-paternity events"—basically, a child born to someone other than the person listed on the birth certificate. Since Nancy Hanks’ own father is a historical mystery, there is a tiny, microscopic sliver of doubt that keeps the theory alive.
Why the Story Won't Die
History isn't just about facts. It’s about how we feel about those facts.
The idea that President Lincoln was Black persists because it challenges the traditional American narrative. It suggests that the "Great Emancipator" wasn't just a white man helping Black people, but a man who shared a biological connection with the people he was freeing. It’s a powerful, poetic idea.
In the 1940s, Giuseppe Moretti, a sculptor, claimed that Lincoln’s facial structure was more consistent with certain African ethnicities than with Anglo-Saxon ones. Even if he was wrong, his observations show how much our eyes are trained by our cultural expectations.
The Physical Reality of Marfan Syndrome
Many doctors and historians, such as Dr. Harold Schwartz, have argued that Lincoln’s "unusual" appearance wasn't due to race, but to a genetic condition called Marfan Syndrome.
📖 Related: Why Every Tornado Warning MN Now Live Alert Demands Your Immediate Attention
This would explain:
- His incredible height (6'4" was giant-like in the 1800s).
- His long, spindly limbs and large hands.
- The sunken appearance of his chest and eyes.
When you combine Marfan Syndrome with the brutal life of a manual laborer on the frontier—working under a scorching sun without SPF 50—you get a man who looks exactly like the "Abe" we see in photos. Leathery, dark, and weary.
Actionable Insights for History Buffs
If you want to dig deeper into the mystery of Lincoln's heritage without getting lost in the weeds of internet rumors, here is how you should approach the research.
- Read the primary sources first. Go to the Library of Congress digital archives. Look at the 1860 campaign posters. You'll see the "racialized" caricatures for yourself. It’s a masterclass in how political propaganda works.
- Study the Melungeon Heritage Association. They have done extensive work on the "Hidden People of the Appalachians." It provides a much more nuanced look at American identity than the standard Black/White binary we usually use.
- Visit the Lincoln Home in Springfield. Seeing his clothing and personal items in person gives you a sense of his physical scale that photos just can't capture.
- Check out J.A. Rogers’ work. Even if you disagree with his conclusions on Lincoln, his books are an essential look at how history is constructed and who gets to write it.
The most likely reality is that Abraham Lincoln was a man of English and potentially Welsh descent who happened to have a "swarthy" complexion and a rare genetic growth disorder. But the fact that we are still asking "was President Lincoln Black?" tells us more about our own obsession with race and identity than it does about the man himself. We want him to be like us. We want to find ourselves in the people we admire.
Whether he had African ancestors or not, Lincoln remains a singular figure who broke the mold of what an American leader was supposed to look and act like. He was an outsider in every sense of the word. That’s probably why we keep trying to find new ways to explain him.