When you see Alexis Roderick standing next to Billy Joel on a red carpet or in a grainy Instagram photo at their Long Island estate, there’s usually a bit of a double-take. It’s not just the 33-year age gap—though that’s usually what the tabloids chew on first. It’s the fact that she seems so settled, so composed, and so fundamentally private compared to the high-octane supermodels and celebrity chefs of Billy’s past. Naturally, the internet does what it does best: it starts digging. People want to know if she was some Wall Street socialite with a string of ex-husbands or a quiet professional who just happened to meet a legend at a restaurant. So, was alexis roderick married before she became the fourth Mrs. Joel?
The short answer? No. Honestly, it’s one of the most common misconceptions about her. Because she entered the public eye in her late 20s and early 30s as the partner of one of the world’s biggest rock stars, there’s this weird assumption that she must have had a whole "previous life" in the matrimonial sense. But the records show she was a career-focused equestrian and finance professional who hadn't walked down the aisle until that surprise Fourth of July party in 2015.
The Mystery of Alexis Roderick’s Past
Before she was "Billy Joel’s wife," Alexis Roderick was basically living a life that most of us would find pretty intense, just without the paparazzi. She was a senior risk officer at Morgan Stanley. Think about that for a second. That’s not a "sit back and look pretty" job. She was grinding in the high-stakes world of New York finance.
When you spend your 20s navigating the brokerage world and competing in high-level equestrian events—she’s an active member of the United States Equestrian Federation—you don’t exactly have a lot of downtime for secret marriages. When she met Billy in 2009 at a restaurant in Huntington, Long Island, she was 29. He was 60.
A lot of people get confused because Billy’s dating history is so public and, frankly, kind of exhausting to keep track of. You’ve got:
- Elizabeth Weber Small: His first wife and former business manager.
- Christie Brinkley: The "Uptown Girl" herself.
- Katie Lee: The celebrity chef who was also significantly younger than him.
Because Katie Lee was also a young, beautiful woman who married Billy later in his life, people often conflate the two or assume Alexis followed a similar path of a previous high-profile marriage. But she didn't.
Why People Think Was Alexis Roderick Married Before
It’s the "Age Gap Math." We see a woman in her 30s marrying a man in his 60s and our brains automatically fill in the blanks. We think, "Oh, she must be a divorcee," or "She must have been around the block." It’s a bit of a projection.
In reality, Alexis was a bit of a "normie" by celebrity standards. She wasn't an actress looking for a break. In fact, Billy famously told reporters that when they first met, she wasn't particularly "impressed with the whole Billy Joel thing." She reportedly didn't even realize he was the Billy Joel at first, which, if you're a guy who has been famous since the 70s, is probably the most attractive thing you can hear.
They were friends for a long time before things turned romantic. They dated for about six years before they actually tied the knots. That’s a lifetime in celebrity years! Most Hollywood couples have met, married, and filed for divorce in the time it took these two to decide to have a wedding.
The Wall Street Factor
If you look into her background at Merrill Lynch and Morgan Stanley, there is absolutely zero evidence of a prior marriage. Her life was defined by the office and the stable. She’s a serious rider. She’s got the horses, the gear, the whole nine yards. That world is small. If there was an "ex-husband Mr. Roderick" or a previous name, the equestrian community would know. They don't. Because he doesn't exist.
The 2015 Surprise Wedding
The reason we even have to talk about was alexis roderick married before is because of how low-key their own wedding was. It wasn't some $10 million blowout at a cathedral.
On July 4, 2015, they invited friends and family to their annual Independence Day party. Standard Long Island stuff—grilling, drinks, maybe some fireworks. Then, surprise! Andrew Cuomo (the Governor of New York at the time and a long-time friend of Billy's) steps up and presides over a wedding ceremony.
👉 See also: Kathy Sabine Weight Loss: What Really Happened With the Denver Legend
At the time, Alexis was already pregnant with their first daughter, Della Rose. The timing was perfect, but it also meant the media focus was on the "surprise" and the "baby," which left a lot of people Googling her history to see where she came from.
A Quick Reality Check on the "Fourth Wife" Narrative
It’s easy to get lost in the numbers.
- Elizabeth Weber (1973–1982)
- Christie Brinkley (1985–1994)
- Katie Lee (2004–2009)
- Alexis Roderick (2015–Present)
Being the fourth wife of a legend comes with a lot of baggage. People look at you through the lens of the women who came before. But unlike the others, Alexis has stayed remarkably out of the spotlight. She doesn't have a cooking show. She isn't modeling on magazine covers. She’s mostly seen at equestrian events or supporting Billy at his record-breaking Madison Square Garden residency.
What Her Life Looks Like Now
Since getting married, Alexis has stayed busy, but not in the way you’d expect for a "trophy wife" (a label she definitely doesn't deserve). She’s been a massive support system for Billy, especially as he’s navigated some health issues in recent years, including his 2024 revelation about living with normal pressure hydrocephalus.
She’s also a "girl mom" through and through. They have two daughters together:
- Della Rose Joel (born 2015)
- Remy Anne Joel (born 2017)
She also seems to have a great relationship with Billy’s eldest daughter, Alexa Ray Joel. You see them in photos together all the time, and there doesn't seem to be any of that weird "wicked stepmother" energy you see in the tabloids. It feels... normal. Kinda boring, actually, which is probably exactly what Billy Joel needed after a few decades of rock star chaos.
The Takeaway
If you’re still wondering about her "secret past," you can stop. There’s no hidden first husband. There’s no messy divorce settlement from some other billionaire. Alexis Roderick is just a woman who was very good at her job in finance, very good at riding horses, and happened to fall in love with a guy who wrote "Piano Man."
It’s a reminder that not everyone in the orbit of a celebrity is searching for fame. Sometimes they’re just searching for a partner. And for Billy Joel, fourth time really was the charm.
👉 See also: Sam Cieri Net Worth: Why the AGT Star is Still a Working Musician at Heart
Practical Insights for Fans:
- Respect the Privacy: Unlike many celebrity spouses, Alexis doesn't maintain a public-facing Instagram for "influencing." Most photos of her come from Billy’s official accounts or equestrian news.
- Verify the Source: If you see "clickbait" articles claiming she had a secret marriage, check the legal filings. New York marriage records are public, and there’s nothing there.
- Focus on the Career: If you're interested in her as a person, look into her equestrian work. She is highly respected in that field on her own merits, not just because of her last name.
Next time you’re debating celebrity trivia, you can confidently clear the air: Alexis Roderick’s first and only marriage is to Billy Joel.