Honestly, the financial world loves to make things complicated. They’ll throw around terms like "alpha," "basis points," and "quantitative easing" until your head spins. But Warren Buffett, the guy who basically built a multi-billion dollar empire from a couch in Omaha, says most of us should just stop trying so hard. He’s spent decades telling anyone who will listen that a simple, boring Warren Buffett S&P 500 index strategy is the smartest move for the average person.
It sounds too easy, right?
You’ve got guys in $5,000 suits on Wall Street promising they can "beat the market." They have supercomputers. They have proprietary algorithms. They have interns who haven't slept since 2022. Yet, Buffett is sitting there with a Cherry Coke, essentially telling you to ignore them all.
The $1 Million Gamble That Changed Everything
Back in 2007, Buffett decided to put his money where his mouth is. He issued a challenge. He bet $1 million that a low-cost S&P 500 index fund would outperform a hand-picked portfolio of hedge funds over a ten-year period.
A guy named Ted Seides from Protégé Partners stepped up. He didn't just pick one hedge fund; he picked five "funds of funds." These were the elite of the elite. These were the people who were supposed to be the smartest guys in the room.
✨ Don't miss: Richest Person in Ohio: The Surprising Truth About Who Really Holds the Top Spot
The bet started on January 1, 2008.
Talk about bad timing. The global financial crisis hit almost immediately. In 2008, the S&P 500 dropped by a staggering 37%. The hedge funds actually did their job initially—they "hedged." They only lost about 24% that year. Seides was looking pretty smart for a minute there.
But then the recovery happened.
Between 2009 and 2014, the S&P 500 beat those hedge funds every single year. By the time the bet ended on December 31, 2017, it wasn't even close. The Vanguard S&P 500 index fund Buffett chose had compounded at about 7.1% annually. The hedge funds? They averaged a measly 2.2%.
Buffett didn't win by a little. He won by a landslide. The prize money went to Girls Inc. of Omaha, and a very public lesson was delivered to the world: fees eat your future.
Why the Index Wins (Hint: It’s Not Magic)
Most people think the Warren Buffett S&P 500 index advice is about the index being "better" at picking stocks. It’s not. The index is just a list of the 500 largest companies in America. It’s literally a bucket.
The reason the bucket wins is because of "frictional costs."
Think about it this way. If you own a farm, and you just sit on it and let the corn grow, you get all the profit from the corn. But if you hire a consultant to tell you when to sell, and a broker to execute the trades, and a manager to watch the consultant—suddenly, a huge chunk of your corn profit is going to people who aren't actually growing any corn.
- Management Fees: Hedge funds often charge "2 and 20." That’s 2% of your total money every year just for existing, plus 20% of any profits.
- Trading Costs: Every time a manager buys or sells a stock, there's a cost.
- Taxes: High-frequency trading creates short-term capital gains, which are taxed at much higher rates than long-term gains.
Buffett’s argument is basically math. If "Active Investors" as a group own the whole market, and "Passive Investors" (indexers) also own the whole market, their gross returns will be the same. But the active group has to pay those massive fees. Therefore, the passive group must end up with more money.
It’s not just a theory. It’s an inevitability.
The 90/10 Rule for His Own Family
You might think Buffett would have some secret, complex instructions for his family’s inheritance. Nope.
In his 2013 letter to Berkshire Hathaway shareholders, he laid out exactly what he told the trustee of his wife’s inheritance. He didn't tell them to buy Berkshire stock. He didn't tell them to find the next big tech startup.
He told them to put 10% of the cash in short-term government bonds and 90% in a very low-cost S&P 500 index fund. He even name-dropped Vanguard.
Why? Because he knows that even for his heirs, the biggest danger isn't the market—it's the people trying to sell them "help." He wants his family to be "know-nothing" investors who get "know-something" results.
Does This Mean You Shouldn't Buy Individual Stocks?
Buffett himself buys individual stocks. He owns Apple, Coca-Cola, and American Express. Isn't that hypocritical?
Not really.
Buffett recognizes that he (and his team, like Todd Combs and Ted Weschler) are professionals who spend 10 hours a day reading 10-K reports. Most of us have jobs, families, and hobbies that don't involve analyzing insurance float or railroad depreciation schedules.
He’s basically saying: "If you want to make this your life's work, go for it. But if you just want to retire wealthy without the stress, buy the index."
The Psychological Trap
The hardest part about the Warren Buffett S&P 500 index strategy isn't the buying. It’s the not selling.
Buffett often says that the stock market is a device for transferring money from the impatient to the patient. When the market drops 20%, people panic. They see red on their screens and they want to "do something."
But "doing something" is usually the worst thing you can do.
The S&P 500 has survived world wars, pandemics, the Great Depression, and the dot-com bubble. It always comes back because it represents the American economy. If the 500 biggest companies in the U.S. all go to zero, your money won't matter anyway—we'll be trading canned beans and shotgun shells.
Actionable Steps to Start Today
If you're ready to stop playing the "beat the market" game and start actually building wealth, here is how you implement this:
1. Choose a Low-Cost Provider
Don't just buy any fund that says "S&P 500." Look at the "expense ratio." You should be paying almost nothing. Vanguard (VOO), BlackRock (IVV), and State Street (SPY) are the big players. You’re looking for an expense ratio of 0.03% or lower. Anything higher is just a gift to the bank.
2. Automate the Process
Don't try to "time" the market. You won't win. Set up an automatic transfer from your paycheck or bank account every single month. This is called dollar-cost averaging. You buy more shares when prices are low and fewer when prices are high.
3. Ignore the Headlines
The news is designed to keep you agitated so you keep watching. "Market in Turmoil!" makes for a great headline, but it's noise. If you're following the Buffett plan, a market crash is actually a good thing for you if you're still in your earning years—it means the index is on sale.
4. Check Your Ego
This is the hardest part. You have to accept that you aren't smarter than the market. You have to be okay with being "average" in the short term to be "extraordinary" in the long term.
Buffett's win over the hedge funds wasn't a fluke. It was a demonstration of the power of simplicity over complexity. You don't need a PhD in finance to get rich. You just need a low-cost index fund and the discipline to leave it alone for thirty years.
Start by looking at your current 401(k) or IRA. Check the fees on the funds you own. If you're paying more than 0.50% in fees, you're essentially handing a huge portion of your retirement to a stranger. Switch to a low-cost S&P 500 tracker and let the compounding begin.