When the BBC announced they were tackling Tolstoy again in 2016, most people just rolled their eyes. Another stuffy period drama? Really? But then we saw the War and Peace TV cast, and everything changed. It wasn't just a list of actors; it was a bizarre, brilliant lightning-in-a-bottle moment where Hollywood heavyweights met British theater royalty. Honestly, looking back at it now, the sheer amount of talent packed into six hours of television is actually kind of insane.
You’ve got Paul Dano playing a fumbling Russian count, Lily James basically being the human embodiment of a sunbeam, and James Norton looking like he was sculpted out of marble and sadness. It worked.
The 2016 adaptation, directed by Tom Harper and written by the legendary Andrew Davies (the guy who gave us the iconic 1995 Pride and Prejudice), did something rare. It made 19th-century Russians feel like people you’d actually know—or at least people you’d definitely stalk on Instagram.
✨ Don't miss: Why Panic\! At The Disco Lyrics Still Hit Different Decades Later
The Big Three: Pierre, Natasha, and Andrei
At the heart of any War and Peace adaptation is the central trio. If you don't care about them, the whole thing falls apart faster than a Napoleonic retreat in the winter.
Paul Dano as Pierre Bezukhov was, frankly, a stroke of genius. Pierre is supposed to be this awkward, socially inept, massive guy who inherits a fortune and has no idea what to do with it. Dano isn't "big" in the physical sense Tolstoy described, but he nails the soul of the character. He’s got that wide-eyed, slightly terrified look that makes you want to give him a hug and tell him to stop hanging out with the Kuragins. He spent most of his early career playing creeps and weirdos in movies like There Will Be Blood, so seeing him be this pure-hearted, bumbling hero was a total shift.
Then there’s Lily James as Natasha Rostova. She’s the pulse of the show. If you've seen her in Cinderella or Downton Abbey, you know she does "charming" in her sleep. But her Natasha is different. She starts as this impulsive teenager and ends up as a woman who has seen way too much. People sometimes complain she’s "too British," but honestly, her energy carries the middle episodes when things get really dark.
And we have to talk about James Norton as Prince Andrei Bolkonsky. Before this, Norton was mostly known for playing a terrifying psychopath in Happy Valley. Switching from a local murderer to a brooding Russian prince is quite the leap, but he pulled it off. He plays Andrei with this cold, cynical shell that only starts to crack when he meets Natasha. It’s a tragic performance, mostly because you just want the guy to be happy for five minutes, but the war—and his own ego—won't let him.
The Villains We Love to Hate
A huge part of why the War and Peace TV cast felt so modern was the Kuragin family. They are basically the 1805 version of a chaotic reality TV family.
- Tuppence Middleton (Hélène Kuragina): She plays the "most beautiful woman in Petersburg" with a predatory edge. Hélène is manipulative, bored, and deeply messy. Middleton makes her feel dangerous rather than just a caricature of a "mean girl."
- Callum Turner (Anatole Kuragin): He’s the brother you hope your sister never meets. Turner plays Anatole with this effortless, greasy charisma. You can see exactly why Natasha falls for his nonsense, even though everyone with a brain is screaming at the screen.
- Stephen Rea (Prince Vassily): The patriarch of the mess. Rea plays him with a quiet, snake-like greed. He doesn't need to shout; he just lurks in the background of ballrooms, orchestrating everyone’s downfall.
Why the Supporting Cast is the Secret Sauce
If you look closely at the background of these scenes, you’ll see faces that have since become massive stars. It's like a "who's who" of 2020s acting.
Jessie Buckley as Marya Bolkonskaya is probably the standout of the supporting players. Back in 2016, she wasn't the Oscar-nominated powerhouse she is now. She plays Andrei’s sister, a woman stuck in the countryside with a mean father, and she breaks your heart in every single scene. Her chemistry with Paul Dano’s Pierre is subtle and sweet—it's the slow burn we all needed.
Then you have Jack Lowden as Nikolai Rostov. He’s the impulsive brother who loses all the family money in a card game (classic Nikolai). Lowden has since gone on to star in Slow Horses and Dunkirk, but here he’s just a young guy trying to prove he’s a soldier. His romance with Aisling Loftus (Sonya) is one of the more grounded, painful parts of the series.
And let’s not forget the "adults" in the room. Jim Broadbent as the grumpy, aging Prince Bolkonsky is terrifying and hilarious. Gillian Anderson pops up as Anna Pavlovna Scherer, the society hostess who knows everything about everyone. Even Brian Cox is there as General Kutuzov, long before he was Logan Roy, leading the Russian army with a weary, "I’m too old for this" vibe.
A Cast That Changed the Game
Usually, when you watch a massive literary adaptation, the actors feel like they’re wearing "costumes." In this version of War and Peace, they just felt like they were wearing clothes.
There was this huge debate when it aired about whether the show was "too sexy" or "too fast." People called it "War and Sex" because Andrew Davies added some scenes that were... let’s say, hinted at in the book but made very explicit on screen. But the cast handled it with enough sincerity that it didn't feel cheap. They made a 1,200-page book feel like a binge-watchable thriller.
The casting director, Julia Harkin, really deserves a trophy for this one. Finding a balance between American actors like Dano and British stalwarts like Broadbent could have been a disaster. It could have felt disjointed. Instead, it felt like a world.
Where Are They Now?
It’s been a decade since they filmed this, and the War and Peace TV cast has basically taken over the industry.
- Paul Dano: Went on to be The Riddler in The Batman and earned massive acclaim for The Fabelmans. He’s firmly in the "greatest actors of his generation" category.
- Lily James: She’s everywhere. From Mamma Mia! to playing Pamela Anderson in Pam & Tommy. She’s a total chameleon.
- James Norton: He’s been a perennial favorite for the next James Bond. Whether that happens or not, his work in Mr. Jones and One Love has proven he’s much more than just a handsome face in a uniform.
- Jessie Buckley: An absolute indie darling and Academy Award nominee. If you haven't seen her in The Lost Daughter or Men, you're missing out.
- Tom Burke (Dolokhov): He’s currently killing it as the lead in the Strike series.
How to Experience the Story Today
If you haven't seen it, or if it's been years, you should probably go back and give it a rewatch. The chemistry between the leads is something you just don't see in every miniseries.
Start with the visuals. Don't just watch for the plot. Watch how Paul Dano uses his physicality to show Pierre's growth from a clumsy boy to a man who has found peace. Notice how the lighting changes when Natasha moves from the bright halls of Moscow to the gray reality of the war hospitals.
Listen to the score. Martin Phipps composed a haunting, choral soundtrack that makes the Russian setting feel authentic. It’s not just "movie music"—it feels like it’s coming from the soul of the characters.
Read the SparkNotes (No, really). If you get confused by the names—and you will, because everyone has three names and a title—keep a family tree handy. Once you understand that the Rostovs are the "heart," the Bolkonskys are the "mind," and the Kuragins are the "poison," the whole show clicks into place.
The 2016 War and Peace didn't just adapt a book; it humanized an epic. It took these legendary figures off their pedestals and put them in the mud, in the ballroom, and in love. It's rare to see a cast this stacked actually deliver on the hype, but these guys did it. They made us care about 19th-century inheritance tax and Napoleonic troop movements, and that is a miracle in itself.
To get the most out of your next viewing, try watching the episodes in pairs. The series is structured to show the contrast between the "Peace" of the first half and the brutal "War" of the second. Pay close attention to the character of Platon Karataev in the final episodes; his brief interaction with Pierre is the key to the entire story's philosophy.