Ask any NFL player which trophy they actually want on their mantle, and you might be surprised. Most fans assume it’s the MVP or a Super Bowl ring. Those are great, obviously. But there’s a different kind of prestige attached to the Walter Payton NFL Man of the Year Award. It’s the only one that basically says, "You’re a Hall of Fame human being, not just a jersey with stats."
Honestly, the "Man of the Year" tag sounds a bit like a 1950s civic club honor. It’s actually the most competitive and emotional award in the league. Every year, 32 men—one from each team—are nominated. They aren't just nominated for writing checks. They’re picked because they’ve spent their Tuesdays (the players' only day off) in hospitals, schools, or disaster zones.
The Gladiator Patch and Why It’s a Big Deal
If you watch a game closely, you’ll notice a small gold patch on the chests of a few players. It looks like a caped figure. That’s the "Gladiator" trophy, modeled after the original statue created by artist Daniel Moore.
Only winners get to wear that patch for the rest of their careers.
It’s a permanent badge of honor. Think about it. Dak Prescott, Russell Wilson, and Calais Campbell all walk onto the field with that extra bit of weight on their jerseys. It tells every rookie and every opponent that this guy has done something bigger than tackle a quarterback.
Since 2017, the NFL has also made sure that current nominees wear a helmet decal. It’s a way to keep the conversation going throughout the playoffs. You see the sticker and you realize, "Oh, that guy just funded ten new libraries in his hometown."
Who Was Walter Payton?
The award wasn’t always named after "Sweetness." It started in 1970 as just the NFL Man of the Year. Johnny Unitas, the legendary Colts quarterback, was the first-ever recipient. But in 1999, the league changed the name to honor Walter Payton after he passed away.
👉 See also: Meaning of Grand Slam: Why We Use It for Tennis, Baseball, and Breakfast
Payton was the perfect blueprint.
He was a monster on the field for the Chicago Bears, but off the field, he was a relentless humanitarian. He didn't just play; he cared. Renaming the award after him wasn't just a PR move—it set the standard for what the league expected from its stars. To win, you have to show "excellence on the field" too. You can't just be a nice guy who sits on the bench. You have to be a playmaker who also happens to be a world-changer.
Arik Armstead and the 2024 Honor
The most recent winner, Arik Armstead, really drives home what this award is about. While he was putting up numbers for the San Francisco 49ers (and later moving to the Jacksonville Jaguars), he was quietly building the Armstead Academic Project.
He didn't just donate some money.
He’s directly impacted over 500,000 kids. We’re talking about literacy programs in Sacramento and "Sound Mind" production workshops for STEAM education. When he stood on that stage at the NFL Honors in February 2025, it wasn't about his 34.5 career sacks. It was about the $2 million he’s poured into helping underserved students unlock their potential.
The prize money is no joke either. As the national winner, Armstead saw a $265,000 donation go to the charity of his choice. Even the nominees who didn't win the big prize got up to $55,000 for their respective causes. That’s a lot of school lunches and mentorship hours.
✨ Don't miss: NFL Week 5 2025 Point Spreads: What Most People Get Wrong
How the Winner Actually Gets Picked
People think it’s a popularity contest. It really isn't.
A panel of judges handles the selection, and the lineup is pretty intense. It usually includes the NFL Commissioner (currently Roger Goodell), Connie Payton (Walter’s widow), the previous year's winner, and a rotating group of former players and media members. They look at the "depth" of the impact.
- Did the player start their own foundation?
- How many hours did they actually spend on the ground?
- Is the charity sustainable, or is it just a one-off event?
For the 2025 cycle, players like DJ Reader (Lions) and Jeffery Simmons (Titans) have been leading the charge. Simmons, for example, has been hosting huge Thanksgiving giveaways and youth empowerment camps through his "Give Em A Reason" Foundation. It’s the kind of work that makes the judges' jobs nearly impossible.
The Teams With the Most Heart
If you’re looking at the history books, a few teams seem to produce "Men of the Year" more than others. The Kansas City Chiefs, Pittsburgh Steelers, and Chicago Bears are currently tied for the most winners, with five each.
There’s something about the culture in those locker rooms.
The Steelers, for instance, have a long lineage of service. From Franco Harris in the 70s to Cameron Heyward winning it recently in 2023. Heyward spent years being a finalist before finally taking the trophy home for his "The Heyward House" foundation. It’s a reminder that persistence matters as much in charity as it does on a third-and-long.
🔗 Read more: Bethany Hamilton and the Shark: What Really Happened That Morning
The "Co-Winner" Oddity
Every now and then, the committee just can’t decide. It’s happened three times in history. In 2000, Jim Flanigan and Derrick Brooks shared the honor. In 2006, it was Drew Brees and LaDainian Tomlinson. Most recently, in 2016, Eli Manning and Larry Fitzgerald both took home the trophy.
It feels right, honestly. How do you choose between a guy helping New Orleans recover from a hurricane and a guy revolutionizing youth education in Arizona? You don't. You just give out two trophies.
What Fans Often Get Wrong
A big misconception is that this is a "lifetime achievement" award given to guys about to retire. While veterans like Andrew Whitworth (2021) have won it late in their careers, many winners are right in their prime.
J.J. Watt won it in 2017 after raising over $37 million for Hurricane Harvey relief in just a few weeks. He was at the absolute peak of his powers on the field. The award is about the now. It’s about who is using their platform while the spotlight is brightest.
How to Support the Nominees
If you want to get involved, the NFL usually runs a "Charity Challenge" on social media. Fans use hashtags for their favorite team's nominee. The player with the most mentions usually gets an extra $35,000 for their charity. It’s a simple way for the average fan to have a direct impact on these local nonprofits.
You should also look into the specific foundations. Most fans don't realize that when they buy a jersey of a Man of the Year winner, they are supporting a legacy that extends way beyond the stadium.
Actionable Next Steps for Fans:
- Check the 2025 Nominees: Head to the official NFL Man of the Year site to see which causes your team's nominee is supporting this year.
- Participate in the Charity Challenge: Use the designated hashtags on X (formerly Twitter) and Instagram during the voting window (usually December and January) to help your player win extra funding.
- Donate Locally: Most of these players focus on their "NFL city." If you're a fan of a specific team, look at their nominee's foundation. Often, a $20 donation there goes a lot further than buying more team gear.
- Watch the NFL Honors: Tune in during Super Bowl week in February 2026 to see the next winner announced. It’s the one part of the week that isn't about the score, but about the soul of the game.