When the confetti stops falling at the NFL Honors and the MVP trophy gets hoisted, there is usually a quieter, almost more reverent moment. It's when the "Man in the Cape" is introduced. You know the one—the small, bronze silhouette of a player standing on the sidelines in a long overcoat. Honestly, it’s the most prestigious award in football, and most casual fans barely know the half of it.
For the walter payton man of the year recipients, that trophy isn't about how many touchdowns they snagged or how many times they leveled a quarterback. It’s about who they are when the cameras aren’t on. It’s about the work that happens in the gritty corners of the community that don't make the Sunday highlights.
It’s Not Just a "Good Guy" Award
People often think this is just a participation trophy for being "nice." Not even close. You've got to be a stud on the field to even get a sniff. We're talking about guys who are absolute terrors on game day but spend their Tuesdays in hospitals or boardrooms for non-profits.
The list of past winners reads like a Hall of Fame invitation list. Think about it: Walter Payton himself (the 1977 winner), Joe Montana, Dan Marino, and Peyton Manning. In 2024, Arik Armstead took home the honors for his massive work with education equity. Before him, it was the Steelers' Cameron Heyward in 2023. These aren't just benchwarmers with a heart of gold; they are the heart of their teams.
The 2025 Nominees: A New Crop of Legends
Just this past December, the 2025 club nominees were announced, and the list is kind of incredible. You've got 32 guys, one from every team, all wearing that special decal on their helmets.
Travis Kelce is the nominee for the Kansas City Chiefs, and he just won the Charity Challenge for the third time, which is basically a massive fan-vote win that nets his charity, Operation Breakthrough, an extra $35,000. Then you have Garett Bolles from the Broncos. He’s been super open about his struggles with learning disabilities and has poured his life into helping kids with similar challenges.
Check out some of the 2025 club winners who are currently in the running for the big national prize:
🔗 Read more: Buddy Hield Sacramento Kings: What Really Happened Behind the Scenes
- Jordan Love (Packers): Working on mental health and youth sports via his "Hands of 10ve" foundation.
- Ted Karras (Bengals): He’s literally raised hundreds of thousands of dollars by selling "Cincy Hats" to support adults with intellectual disabilities.
- Dion Dawkins (Bills): A constant force in the Buffalo community.
- Demario Davis (Saints): One of the most respected voices in the league for social reform.
The national winner is set to be announced on February 5, 2026, during the NFL Honors. Whoever gets it joins a club so exclusive that current winners get to wear a special patch on their jersey for the rest of their careers. It’s the only award that sticks with you like that.
Why the Patch Matters So Much
If you ever see a player with a small gold patch on their chest—the one with the caped man—that’s a Walter Payton Man of the Year winner. As of right now, only a handful of active players have them: Dak Prescott, Russell Wilson, Calais Campbell, Arik Armstead, and Cameron Heyward.
When these guys walk into a room, that patch says everything. It tells the rookies that you can be a multi-millionaire superstar and still care about someone other than yourself. Basically, it’s the ultimate "I’ve made it" badge in the NFL.
The Impact is Real (And Expensive)
This isn't just about a trophy for the mantle. The NFL and Nationwide put real money behind this. The national winner gets a $250,000 donation to the charity of their choice. Even the 31 other nominees get up to $40,000 for their causes.
Take Arik Armstead, for example. He didn't just "show up" to a school. His foundation, the Armstead Academic Project, has raised over $2 million for kids in Sacramento and the Bay Area. He helped pass a literacy bill in California. That’s not just a photo op; that’s changing the actual law.
Or look at Ted Karras. He personally matched $100,000 in donations to help build "The Cincy Hat House," an apartment complex for adults with developmental disabilities. He’s out there selling hats and meeting fans just to make sure these folks have a place to live.
💡 You might also like: Why the March Madness 2022 Bracket Still Haunts Your Sports Betting Group Chat
The History of the "Man in the Cape"
The trophy itself has a weirdly cool history. It was created in 1969 by an artist named Daniel Bennett Schwartz. He used an offensive lineman named Steve Wright as the model, but he made the figure look "undistinguished" on purpose.
Why? Because the award is for everyone. It doesn't matter if you're the backup punter or the MVP quarterback. If you're doing the work, you're the Man of the Year. It was originally just called the NFL Man of the Year Award, but they renamed it in 1999 after Walter Payton passed away. Payton was the "Sweetness" of the league, and his family—specifically his widow, Connie—is still heavily involved in picking the winner today.
What You Probably Didn't Know
- The Double Winner Year: In 2006, they actually had two winners: Drew Brees and LaDainian Tomlinson. Both were so impactful after Hurricane Katrina and in their respective communities that the judges couldn't pick just one.
- The Helmet Decal: Every nominee gets to wear a decal on their helmet from Week 14 through the end of the season. It’s a subtle nod that lets other players know, "Hey, this guy is doing it right."
- The "Gladiator" Product: Starting this year, there's even special merchandise where the proceeds go back to the players' charities. The NFL doesn't take a dime of it.
How the Winner is Actually Picked
It’s not just a random vote by the Commissioner. There’s a panel of judges that includes:
- The NFL Commissioner (Roger Goodell).
- Connie Payton.
- The previous year’s winner (so Arik Armstead is on the panel this year).
- A handful of former players.
They look at the "body of work." They want to see long-term commitment, not just a one-time donation. They want to see the player’s own foundation, their hours spent on the ground, and how they use their platform to influence others.
Actionable Insights for Fans
If you care about what these guys are doing, you don't have to just sit and watch the awards show.
First, look up your own team's nominee. Every year, there's a guy on your favorite team doing something incredible. Whether it's Bobby Wagner in Washington or Baker Mayfield in Tampa, these guys are usually looking for local volunteers or small donations to their foundations.
📖 Related: Mizzou 2024 Football Schedule: What Most People Get Wrong
Second, participate in the Charity Challenge next year. It usually runs from December to early January. A simple tweet with a hashtag like #WPMOYChallenge and the player's name can literally earn their charity tens of thousands of dollars. It’s the easiest way to help your team win something off the field.
Third, support the "My Cause My Cleats" initiative. Many of these Man of the Year recipients use that week to showcase their specific charities on their footwear. Those cleats are often auctioned off later, with 100% of the money going to the cause.
The walter payton man of the year recipients represent the best of what sports can be. In a world of contract holdouts and "me-first" attitudes, these 32 men every year remind us that the platform of the NFL is a tool for good.
Keep an eye on the screen during the Super Bowl pre-game. You'll see all 32 nominees standing on the field. They might not all get the trophy, but they've all changed lives, and that’s a whole lot better than a Super Bowl ring.
To see the full impact of these players, you can head over to the official NFL Man of the Year site and read the deep-dive stories on all 32 current nominees. Each one has a unique story, from supporting foster kids to funding cancer research, proving that the "Man in the Cape" is a legacy that won't be fading anytime soon.