Rick Grimes wakes up. He's alone. The hospital is silent, smelling of rot and antiseptic. We all remember that moment from the pilot, but by the time we reached the season 6 premiere, Walking Dead First Time Again, the stakes had shifted from survival to soul-searching. It was a massive, black-and-white fueled gamble.
People forget how risky this episode actually was.
Greg Nicotero, the legendary makeup guru who directed this beast, decided to mess with our heads. He used a non-linear timeline. Half the episode is in stark, high-contrast black and white, representing the "past," while the "present" explodes in hyper-saturated color. It wasn't just a gimmick. It was a way to keep us from getting lost in a narrative that involved leading thousands of walkers out of a quarry. Honestly, it was one of the most ambitious things ever put on cable television.
The Quarry and the Chaos
Let’s talk about that quarry.
Imagine 30,000 walkers. That is a lot of decaying flesh. In the reality of the show, the survivors found this massive pit near Alexandria that was accidentally acting as a natural trap. It was keeping the community safe, but the ledge was crumbling. It was a ticking time bomb. Rick, being Rick, decided the only way to save the town was to let the monsters out on purpose.
Talk about a hard sell.
The episode oscillates between the planning of this "parade" and the execution of it. You’ve got Carter—played by Ethan Embry—who basically represents the audience's skepticism. He thinks Rick is a lunatic. He’s not entirely wrong. Rick has become this jagged, uncompromising force of nature. This is the era of "Rick-tatorship" 2.0, where if you aren't with the plan, you're a liability.
Watching Walking Dead First Time Again today, the tension feels different. We know who lives. We know who dies. But back then? The scale of the walker herd was genuinely suffocating. It took over 200 extras in full prosthetic makeup and a massive amount of digital extension to make that herd look like a literal river of death.
Why the Black and White Worked
Some fans hated it. They thought it was pretentious.
I disagree.
📖 Related: Why the Star Trek III: The Search for Spock Cast Almost Didn't Happen
The monochrome flashbacks allowed the show to breathe. We got to see the immediate aftermath of the Season 5 finale—Pete’s blood still fresh on the porch, Morgan and Rick’s awkward "reunion" gaze. It felt like a film noir. By stripping away the color, Nicotero forced us to focus on the expressions. Morgan, played by the incomparable Lennie James, serves as the moral mirror to Rick's brutality.
"I know you," Morgan says.
But does he? The Rick Grimes of the hospital bed wouldn't have executed a man in cold blood. The Rick of the quarry? He’d do it and then eat a handful of applesauce.
The Logistics of a Zombie Parade
How do you move ten thousand walkers? You use a motorcycle and a very loud horn. Daryl Dixon leading the dead on his bike is one of the most iconic images of the entire series. It’s slow. It’s methodical. It’s incredibly dangerous.
The plan required building massive walls of rusted metal to funnel the herd. One of the best moments is when the walkers reach the "red balloon" point. It’s a literal turning point in the mission. Everything is going perfectly until it isn't. Because in this universe, human error—or human malice—always wins over the best-laid plans.
- Abraham and Sasha are in the lead car.
- Glenn and Nicholas are trying to clear out a hardware store.
- Rick is running through the woods, screaming orders.
The pacing is erratic in the best way possible. You go from a quiet, whispered conversation about the ethics of killing to a cacophony of groans and gunfire. It shouldn't work, but it does.
The Carter Problem
Carter is the most "human" person in the episode, which is why he had to die. He represented the old world. He represented the part of Alexandria that thought you could still have meetings and votes. When he gets bit in the face—a truly gnarly practical effect—and Rick has to silence his screaming so he doesn't draw the herd? That’s the moment the "First Time Again" title really clicks.
It's the first time Alexandria is seeing the world for what it really is. And it’s the first time we see Rick fully embrace his role as a necessary monster.
🔗 Read more: Why Cutthroat Kitchen Season 1 Still Feels Like High-Stakes Gambling
The Sound of the Horn
Everything falls apart because of a horn. A long, sustained blare coming from Alexandria.
The herd starts to turn. They leave the road. They head toward the walls.
It’s one of the greatest cliffhangers in the show's history because it signaled a shift. The threat wasn't just the dead anymore; it was the fact that while the "warriors" were out playing shepherd, the home front was completely vulnerable. We later find out it was the Wolves attacking, but in that moment, in that first viewing, it was just pure, unadulterated dread.
Honestly, the sound design in this episode deserves an Emmy on its own. The way the horn cuts through the silence of the forest is chilling. It’s the sound of a plan failing. It's the sound of the world ending all over again.
What This Episode Taught Us About Survival
Looking back at Walking Dead First Time Again, there are some harsh truths that are still relevant to the franchise today.
First, consensus is a luxury. Rick didn't wait for everyone to be okay with the plan. He knew the ledge would break, and he acted. In high-stakes environments, waiting for a 100% agreement usually leads to 100% casualty rates.
Second, the past is always monochrome. We tend to remember things as simpler than they were. The use of black and white wasn't just a stylistic choice; it was a metaphor for how we process trauma. We strip away the vibrant, messy details until we're left with the "truth" of what happened.
✨ Don't miss: Why the Search for Have Sex with Elsa is Really About the Ethics of AI Porn
Third, you can't control the "herd." Whether it’s a literal group of walkers or just the chaos of life, you can nudge it, you can build walls, but eventually, something—a horn, a car crash, a mistake—will send it off the rails.
Actionable Insights for Your Next Rewatch
If you're going back to watch this episode, do these things to get the most out of the experience:
- Watch the background extras. The "Hero Walkers" are usually in the front, but the ones in the back of the quarry scenes are actually wearing simpler masks. It's a masterclass in forced perspective and budget management.
- Track Rick’s eyes. In the color scenes, Andrew Lincoln plays Rick with a frantic, wide-eyed intensity. In the black and white scenes, he’s more still, almost catatonic. It’s a subtle acting choice that many missed.
- Listen for the silence. The moments between the herds are deafening. The show uses "negative sound" to build anxiety before the big reveals.
The episode ends with a bird's eye view of the herd diverging. It’s a mess. It’s a failure. But it’s also the most "Walking Dead" the show ever felt. It was a reminder that no matter how many walls you build, the world outside is always hungry, and it’s always coming for you.
To really appreciate the technical side, look up the behind-the-scenes footage of how they built the "quarry." They used a real rock quarry in Georgia and spent weeks prepping it. It wasn't just a green screen. That dust, that heat, and that sheer scale were as real as it gets in Hollywood.
This episode wasn't just a season premiere; it was a statement. It told the audience that the show wasn't afraid to be weird, wasn't afraid to be slow, and certainly wasn't afraid to make its "hero" look like a villain. That’s why we’re still talking about it a decade later. It remains a high-water mark for what's possible in the horror-drama genre when you have a director who understands that the monsters aren't the point—the people are.