The baseball world was buzzing back in late 2024 when Walker Buehler decided to pack his bags for Boston. It was one of those "prove-it" deals that made perfect sense on paper but felt like a massive gamble for everyone involved. The Red Sox, a team desperately trying to claw back into the AL East conversation, threw $21.05 million at a guy whose right arm has been through more procedures than some medical textbooks.
Honestly, it was a move that felt very "new era" Red Sox. Chief Baseball Officer Craig Breslow and pitching coach Andrew Bailey were selling a vision. They wanted Buehler to ditch the four-seamer—the pitch that made him a superstar in Los Angeles—and lean into the "pitch design" revolution happening at Fenway.
It didn't work. Like, at all.
The $21 Million Gamble That Went South
When Buehler signed that one-year contract, he wasn't just looking for a paycheck. He was looking for a resurrection. Coming off a second Tommy John surgery and a rocky 2024 return with the Dodgers, he chose Boston because they promised to help him evolve. He even swapped his iconic No. 21 for No. 0, a symbolic fresh start for a pitcher who used to be the baddest man on any mound he stepped on.
But the reality of the 2025 season was harsh.
By the time August rolled around, the Red Sox had seen enough. Buehler wasn't the ace they hoped for; he wasn't even a reliable mid-rotation starter. He was sitting on a 5.45 ERA through 22 starts. His velocity, which used to sit comfortably at 97 mph, was hanging around 94 mph. In the unforgiving environment of the AL East, 94 mph with shaky command is basically BP for guys like Aaron Judge or Vladimir Guerrero Jr.
The Red Sox officially pulled the plug on August 29, 2025. They released him. Just like that, the experiment was over. They ate the remainder of that $21 million salary and handed the ball to a kid named Payton Tolle. It was a cold, business-first move that signaled Boston was ready to move on from "reclamation projects" and start trusting their own young arms.
🔗 Read more: Why the Philadelphia Eagles Schedule 2023 Was Way Harder Than It Looked
Why the Red Sox Marriage Failed
People often ask why a guy with Buehler’s "championship pedigree" couldn't figure it out in Boston. It wasn't just one thing. It was a perfect storm of mechanical rust and a refusal to fully let go of the pitcher he used to be.
- Fastball Decay: In his prime, Buehler’s four-seamer had elite "rise" and life. In 2025, it was flatter. Hitters weren't swinging through it anymore; they were launching it.
- The Command Crisis: You can survive lower velocity if you can paint the corners. Buehler couldn't. He walked over 10% of the batters he faced in a Red Sox uniform. You can’t give free passes in Fenway Park and expect to survive the third inning.
- The Adjustment Period: Buehler was vocal about his struggles. He mentioned in interviews that his "back leg wasn't working right" and that he was overthinking the sequencing. Sometimes, when you try to reinvent yourself in the middle of a pennant race, you end up lost in the woods.
It’s easy to blame the coaching staff, but Andrew Bailey’s system has worked for almost everyone else. Look at Tanner Houck. Look at what they did with Garrett Crochet. The system is fine; the player just wasn't physically ready to execute the plan.
Life After Boston: The Philadelphia Pivot
If you stopped following the story after he left Fenway, you missed the weirdest part. After being DFA'd and released by Boston, Buehler didn't just go home and wait for 2026. The Philadelphia Phillies—a team that never met a veteran pitcher they didn't like—snagged him on a minor league deal in September 2025.
And wouldn't you know it? He actually looked... okay?
He threw 13.2 innings for Philly at the tail end of the season and looked much more like the "Big Game Walker" of old. He even made their NLDS roster. It makes you wonder if the pressure of being "The Guy" in Boston was part of the problem. In Philly, he was just another arm in a deep staff.
The 2026 Reality for the Red Sox
As we sit here in early 2026, the Red Sox rotation looks completely different. They didn't dwell on the Buehler miss. Instead, they went out and spent big on Ranger Suarez, giving him $130 million to lead a staff that now includes Sonny Gray and a much-improved Brayan Bello.
The "Walker Buehler Red Sox" era will likely be remembered as a footnote—a bridge that didn't quite reach the other side. It was a high-upside play that didn't pay off, but it paved the way for the aggressive spending we’re seeing from the front office now.
If you’re a Sox fan, you’re probably just glad the team is finally done with the "one-year flyer" strategy and actually buying established talent.
What to Watch for Next
If you are still tracking Buehler’s journey or wondering how the Red Sox are filling that gap, keep an eye on these specific developments:
✨ Don't miss: Greg Rusedski: What Most People Get Wrong About the 149mph Serve King
- Buehler’s New Market: He is a free agent again right now. Word is he might be looking at a $15-17 million deal with a smaller-market team like the Reds or Tigers. He needs a low-pressure environment to finally find his 2.0 version.
- Payton Tolle’s Development: The lefty who replaced Buehler in the rotation is the real deal. His performance in spring training this year will determine if the Red Sox were geniuses for cutting bait when they did.
- The Four-Seam Usage: Watch the Red Sox's overall pitching metrics this season. If they continue to rank near the bottom of the league in four-seam usage, it proves they haven't abandoned the philosophy that Buehler struggled to adopt.
The Buehler experiment was a failure of timing, not necessarily a failure of talent. He just wasn't the right pitcher at the right time for a city that has zero patience for a 5.00 ERA.