You’ve seen him a thousand times. He’s on the grocery store end-cap in cardboard cutout form, he’s in the mall taking awkward photos with crying toddlers, and he’s definitely all over your Instagram feed every April. But have you ever actually looked at the modern imagery and realized the Easter Bunny is missing something fundamental? Not just a tail or a whisker. He’s missing his history.
Honestly, the version we have now is a bit of a hollow shell. He's a corporate mascot. He's a vessel for high-fructose corn syrup and plastic grass that stays in your carpet until July. When we say the Easter Bunny is missing something, we’re usually talking about the weird, slightly dark, and deeply symbolic roots that made this character more than just a delivery driver for Peeps.
👉 See also: Texas Tech Rec: Why the Robert H. Ewalt Student Recreation Center is the Hardest Place to Leave on Campus
Most people don't know that the rabbit didn't start out as a "bunny" at all. It was a hare. And in the old world, hares weren't exactly cute. They were mysterious. They were symbols of moonlight and madness. If you feel like your holiday is missing that "spark," it’s probably because we’ve sanitized the life out of the legend.
The European "Osterhase" and the Missing Logic
If you trace the lineage back to 16th-century Germany, you find the Osterhase. This wasn't some soft, cuddly creature in a bowtie. The Osterhase was a judge.
Think about it like Santa Claus. We all know Santa has the "Naughty or Nice" list. But somewhere along the line, the Easter Bunny lost his moral compass. Originally, he was supposed to decide if children had been well-behaved enough to deserve colored eggs. Today? Every kid gets a basket, regardless of whether they’ve been a terror all morning. The Easter Bunny is missing something critical here: the stakes. Without the judgment aspect, he’s just a random animal breaking into your house to leave treats.
Why the Hare Became a Rabbit
Hares are different from rabbits. They are born with their eyes open and full coats of fur. They are survivors. In folklore, particularly in Germanic traditions, the hare was linked to the goddess Eostre. While some scholars, like Ronald Hutton in The Stations of the Sun, argue that the link between Eostre and rabbits is more Victorian invention than ancient pagan fact, the cultural weight is still there.
When the tradition migrated to America with German immigrants (the Pennsylvania Dutch) in the 1700s, the "Osterhase" became the "Easter Bunny." The name changed. The species changed. The vibe changed. We traded the wild, untamed hare for a domesticated pet. This is where the "missing" feeling starts. We took a creature of the wilderness and turned it into a plush toy.
The Symbolism Gap: What Your Basket Is Actually Missing
Go to Target. Look at the aisles. It's a sea of pastel. But the Easter Bunny is missing something deeper in its current presentation—fertility and rebirth. I know, that sounds a bit "biology class," but that was the whole point.
Ancient people saw rabbits as a miracle. Because they have a unique reproductive system (superfetation), they can conceive a second litter while still pregnant with the first. To a medieval farmer, that looked like magic. It looked like life literally overflowing.
Now, we just have "hollow chocolate."
- The eggs represent the tomb (and the life inside).
- The rabbit represents the renewal of the earth.
- The "missing" part is the connection to the seasons.
If you’re just buying a pre-made basket, you’re missing the ritual. You're missing the "why." In many Orthodox traditions, the eggs are dyed red to represent the blood of Christ. In the secular version, we just use neon food coloring. There’s a disconnect. We have the symbols, but we’ve forgotten the definitions.
The "Creepy" Factor: Why the Modern Bunny Feels Off
Have you ever noticed how many "creepy Easter Bunny" lists go viral every year? There’s a reason for that. When we try to make a human-sized rabbit, something goes wrong in our brains. It’s the "Uncanny Valley."
✨ Don't miss: Frederick Wine and Dine: What Most People Get Wrong About This Cleveland Staple
The Easter Bunny is missing something human, which makes him terrifying when he’s six feet tall and wearing a vest. Traditionally, he was an invisible spirit. You didn't see him. You just saw the evidence of his visit. By forcing the Bunny to be a physical mascot we can touch and take selfies with, we’ve stripped away the mystery.
The mystery is what makes holidays feel special.
I talked to a folklore enthusiast last year who pointed out that when we over-explain or over-visualize these figures, they lose their power. The tooth fairy works because she’s invisible. The Easter Bunny started failing the "vibe check" the moment he started appearing in malls.
Let's Talk About the Candy: The Flavor Is Missing
Check the ingredients on a standard chocolate bunny. Is it chocolate? Or is it "chocolate-flavored candy"?
Most of the time, the Easter Bunny is missing something essential: actual cocoa butter. We’ve replaced quality with volume. We want the biggest bunny possible for the lowest price. This mirrors what’s happened to the holiday itself. We want the "aesthetic" of Easter without the labor of the traditions that used to define it.
Back in the day, Pennsylvania Dutch children would build "nests" out of their hats or bonnets. They had to prepare for the arrival. It was an active participation. Now, it’s passive consumption. You wake up, you eat sugar, you go to brunch.
How to Find What the Easter Bunny Is Missing
If you feel like the holiday is a bit hollow, you have to put the "hare" back in the "bunny." You have to re-introduce the elements that have been scrubbed away by decades of commercialization.
It’s not about being a traditionalist or a religious zealot. It’s about storytelling.
- Stop buying the pre-filled plastic eggs. Honestly, they’re terrible for the environment and they feel cheap. If the Easter Bunny is missing something, it’s the "hand-crafted" soul. Dye real eggs. Use onion skins for brown, beets for red, and turmeric for yellow. It takes longer. It’s messy. That’s the point.
- Lean into the Hare. Look up the "Three Hares" motif. It’s an ancient symbol found in churches, synagogues, and temples from China to England. It shows three hares running in a circle, their ears forming a triangle. It’s beautiful, mysterious, and way cooler than a cartoon rabbit with a lopsided bowtie.
- Read the actual folklore. Read about the Osterhase. Tell your kids that the bunny is a judge of character. It adds a layer of whimsy (and maybe a little bit of much-needed discipline) to the morning.
- Focus on the garden. The Easter Bunny is a creature of the earth. If you’re celebrating indoors under fluorescent lights, you’re missing the point. Get outside. Look for actual signs of spring.
The Missing Link Between Spring and Spirit
The Easter Bunny is missing something when he’s separated from the natural world. This is a "liminal" holiday—a bridge between the death of winter and the life of summer.
When we treat Easter like just another "sale event" at the department store, we lose that bridge. We’re just standing on one side, wondering why we don't feel the "magic" we felt when we were five. The magic wasn't the chocolate; it was the belief in something wild and invisible that could reward you for being good.
It was the idea that even in the mud and the cold, life was twitching its nose, waiting to pop out of a hole in the ground.
Moving Forward: Your Action Plan for a Better Holiday
Don't let the corporate version of the holiday dictate your experience. If you feel like the Easter Bunny is missing something, it’s up to you to fill that gap.
Start by changing your focus from "buying" to "doing."
Research the local flora in your area and see what’s actually blooming. If you have kids, have them build a nest out of natural materials—twigs, dried grass, leaves—instead of using a plastic basket. This connects the "Bunny" back to the wild hare he used to be.
Next, look at your food. Try making a traditional Osterbrot (Easter bread). The act of kneading dough and watching it rise is a much better metaphor for the holiday than opening a bag of jellybeans.
✨ Don't miss: Finding the Right Display for Hot Wheels Cars: Why Your Shelf Probably Sucks
Finally, embrace the weirdness. Folklore is supposed to be a little strange. It’s supposed to be more than just "cute." By acknowledging the deeper, older roots of the Easter Bunny, you aren't just following a trend—you're participating in a human story that's hundreds of years old. That’s how you find what’s been missing.
Stop looking for the holiday in the seasonal aisle. It’s not there. It’s in the history, the dirt, the effort, and the mystery of the wild hare. Go find it.